Does Shadow Of A Man...

[NUTELLA 16,228]

Just now, AVeryGagaHolyDick said:

it’s probably in her top 100

When I catch you

[Gorehound 4,920]

3 minutes ago, dynamite said:

You're taking it as a criticism 

I love the song including the chorus

Musically it rocks, I guess I mean vocally it's very chill, she's almost talking the chorus

I don't think you realise the sheer amount of vocal gymnastics and techniques going on throughout PC, even if she is singing in a softer tone on the verses. And that growling, angry chorus doesn't sound like talking to me, that kind of thing goes to the likes of 911, not this banger.

[Ladle Ghoulash 33,011]

Just now, Gorehound said:

I don't think you realise the sheer amount of vocal gymnastics and techniques going on throughout PC, even if she is singing in a softer tone on the verses. And that growling, angry chorus doesn't sound like talking to me, that kind of thing goes to the likes of 911, not this banger.

I mean, as a singer, you’re 100% right. The vocals on that song (and the album in general) are insanely impressive, but I also don’t think they were trying to drag it as much as they weren’t describing how they felt about it that precisely lol

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 27,960]

1 minute ago, NUTELLA said:

When I catch you

Don’t worry, it goes top 10 when I’m drunk 

[Gorehound 4,920]

Just now, Ladle Ghoulash said:

I mean, as a singer, you’re 100% right. The vocals on that song (and the album in general) are insanely impressive, but I also don’t think they were trying to drag it as much as they weren’t describing how they felt about it that precisely lol

I didn't know you're a singer! That's awesome. 

Question for you then purely out of interest, what would you consider to be the top 5 hardest Gaga songs to sing?

[Ziggy 12,531]

1 hour ago, PartySick said:

The only thing that irks me is EVERYONE says it's straight up an MJ song and me, who has listened to MJ for 30 years now, finds more MJ vibes in other songs from this album  

It's Smooth Criminal-esque but she has a whole ass Dirty Diana on the same album????

Tbf it’s bc she sings like him, too. The beast also does sound like him 100% but I think it has a few less specific MJ hallmarks—soam has those descending runs, the quick, cutting cadence, harmonies sound similar to his, ad libs, etc. She sings like him on the beast, too, but has a little more of her Meatloaf-y Gagaisms to distinguish it

the beast sounds more an homage the same way black jesus does imo

However

kill for love I think actually sounds the absolute most like his stuff since it damn near cribs thriller’s intro (great song though)

 

Edited yesterday at 12:24 AM by Ziggy

[NUTELLA 16,228]

Just now, Gorehound said:

I didn't know you're a singer! That's awesome. 

Question for you then purely out of interest, what would you consider to be the top 5 hardest Gaga songs to sing?

For her? The Cure is probably number one

[Gorehound 4,920]

2 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

I also don’t think they were trying to drag it as much as they weren’t describing how they felt about it that precisely lol

Oh ye I'm too defensive of PC cuz I consider it one of the greatest songs she's ever done. 

[Gorehound 4,920]

1 minute ago, NUTELLA said:

For her? The Cure is probably number one

Now this we can agree on 

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 27,960]

2 minutes ago, Gorehound said:

I didn't know you're a singer! That's awesome. 

Question for you then purely out of interest, what would you consider to be the top 5 hardest Gaga songs to sing?

If dancing, 911 is up there cause you have no time to breathe 

[weed 75,716]

this plays in my head when I hear SOAM and it makes it even more exciting 

 

[Gorehound 4,920]

1 minute ago, AVeryGagaHolyDick said:

If dancing, 911 is up there cause you have no time to breathe 

Very true, but you could say that for a lot of her songs

[dynamite 62,514]

12 minutes ago, Gorehound said:

I don't think you realise the sheer amount of vocal gymnastics and techniques going on throughout PC, even if she is singing in a softer tone on the verses. And that growling, angry chorus doesn't sound like talking to me, that kind of thing goes to the likes of 911, not this banger.

I realise the vocal quality of PC. This is all subjective and about my perception of "exciting". You're still taking it negatively. 

I also wasn't talking about the whole song, as the thread is about her most exciting chorus. The chorus is rocking and vocally it's great but it's more vibey and feels almost laid back vocally (even if it isn't...) When I think of most exciting I'd probably choose something anthemic with intense, uplifting vocals like TEOG, VIY, Hair etc. again, it's not a criticism. It's the intentional style of the song to not be like that and it's probably in my top 15.

I do find the song exciting.

Again it's subjective, so I'm going to leave it there 

Edited yesterday at 12:32 AM by dynamite

[Ziggy 12,531]

29 minutes ago, Lord Mayhem said:

I mean...why else would Gaga have teased it at the end of the Chromatica Ball film? I believe the era was intended to start not long after but things changed and Disease was chosen instead and well...

Bc she wanted to tease new music coming without revealing any potential singles tbh

the era was designed to start around joker. No way no how was it any other way given how orchestrated that was. It was super clear they wanted that movie to be the big buzzy springboard for her new era and instead it nearly tanked it so thank god the music was good lmfao

[Gorehound 4,920]

2 minutes ago, dynamite said:

I realise the vocal quality of PC. This is all subjective and about my perception of "exciting". You're still taking it negatively. 

I also wasn't talking about the whole song, as the thread is about her most exciting chorus. The chorus is rocking and vocally it's great but it's more vibey and feels almost laid back vocally (even if it isn't...) When I think of most exciting I'd probably choose something anthemic with intense, uplifting vocals like TEOG, VIY, Hair etc. again, it's not a criticism. It's the intentional style of the song to not be like that and it's probably in my top 15.

I do find the song exciting.

Again it's subjective, so I'm going to leave it there 

Totally get your point man. Dw I wasn't digging at you x