Jump to content
question

Talented singers whose music is average?


StrawberryBlond

Featured Posts

JaysAMess
27 minutes ago, flyaway said:

TW: This opinion may offend some of you, but I feel Gaga has yet to release an album up to her talents as an artist, a songwriter and a vocalist. An artist like Gaga truly deserves a masterpiece album, and I know she could make it. BTW was a close effort.

Don't get me wrong, she already has many great songs and amazing ideas. But her albums often feel half baked, unfinished or too constricted to appeal to the masses. And when it comes to Chromatica, it was mostly conceived by her producers.

a18b6c5b1406a0a93b114f3154412ccd.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 64
  • Created
  • Last Reply
2 minutes ago, Blastertoyo said:

Um 

How can yall call Gaga queen of versatility and say these are all the same 

 

If you like Mariah, check out JoJo.

ESCjx5rUUAAd_qX.jpg

They are friends after all.

Link to post
Share on other sites

flyaway
19 minutes ago, holy scheisse said:

I think this is a weird comment lol. This whole threads weird tbh. But if Gaga has yet to create an album that showcases her talent.... When will she ever? I think you're projecting some kind of expectation and vision of her talent onto her that doesn't exist. Gaga puts her all into her albums and if it doesn't come off as talented to you, you might just be delulu over what you think she's capable of 

Not necessarily. I speak from what we've experienced so far that goes beyond the albums. I love the work, but I know she has yet to reach her artistic peak with what she's able to do and has demonstrated in the past through her work.

On one side, she has several cover performances where she showcases many of her abilities as a vocalist that on most of her albums are missing. Then there are many ideas (like the whole ARTPOP experience) that seem unfinished and made too quickly, and there is some big potential that could be fully exploited in the future. Or albums like Joanne that have some of her best work, but suffer from lack of commitment to the sound.

Gaga's career has been very turbulent, and in a way has forced her to change direction in some unexpected ways. Either because of time, a record label's expectations, some questionable decisions, an emotional state, there are factors that have affected the work that is out there.

But then this is just my personal view on things, it's what I feel she's capable of.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Starmie25

So many artists listed here actually dropped solid projects overtime and really switched it up, y'all gotra give em a shot - Chris Tina, Halsey, Jessie J 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Defmix100

Jessie J is the main one who comes to mind, but I agree about Pink now too. I really love Pink's voice and haven't minded her recent singles but they feel pretty similar now and think she should diversify more.

Also now thinking about it I do kind of agree with the Gaga comment too, but I like the variety of her body of work how she can go from Donatella style to AWRUTW

Link to post
Share on other sites

hijadeputa
41 minutes ago, StrawberryBlond said:

Doja Cat - She's so unique and her way of expressing all those different ways of singing Say So was very creative but yet, her music, especially her earlier stuff is kinda...weird and niche. She's improving since she's hit the big time but its baby steps. I'm still annoyed that the bland Say So was what gave her her big break and not the amazing Rules from the same album, which is probably her best ever song.

 

She can legit rap, sing and write/produce her own stuff. Did you listen to Planet Her? Album of the Year.

Link to post
Share on other sites

ANVEEROY
45 minutes ago, flyaway said:

TW: This opinion may offend some of you, but I feel Gaga has yet to release an album up to her talents as an artist, a songwriter and a vocalist. An artist like Gaga truly deserves a masterpiece album, and I know she could make it. BTW was a close effort.

Don't get me wrong, she already has many great songs and amazing ideas. But her albums often feel half baked, unfinished or too constricted to appeal to the masses. And when it comes to Chromatica, it was mostly conceived by her producers.

 

Sis, say Gaga needs to release Ray of Light or Like A Prayer :ally:

Stream Kylie-Janet Discographies!
Link to post
Share on other sites

littlepotter
47 minutes ago, flyaway said:

TW: This opinion may offend some of you, but I feel Gaga has yet to release an album up to her talents as an artist, a songwriter and a vocalist. An artist like Gaga truly deserves a masterpiece album, and I know she could make it. BTW was a close effort.

Don't get me wrong, she already has many great songs and amazing ideas. But her albums often feel half baked, unfinished or too constricted to appeal to the masses. And when it comes to Chromatica, it was mostly conceived by her producers.

I don't think any of her albums sound half baked, but I guess I see what you're trying to say. I also feel like Gaga has so much more musical potential in her and she's going to fuck us all up one day

chaeri pls
Link to post
Share on other sites

ANVEEROY
2 minutes ago, dojo said:

She needs her RARE

She needs Pink Friday: Roman Reloaded – The Re-Up

Stream Kylie-Janet Discographies!
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...