Jump to content

Gaga Charts Discussion - Gaga Earns 3rd #1 Album


Arturo

Featured Posts

Hope it stays in Top 100 :ohno:

It isnt now. Didnt somebody said is 101?

 

No worry. They will discount it again next week, for the special announcement of Gypsy as 4th single or the album will be out of Billboad 200. :oops:

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 20.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

It isnt now. Didnt somebody said is 101?

No worry. They will discount it again next week, for the special announcement of Gypsy as 4th single or the album will be out of Billboad 200. :oops:

I missed out that post :giveup:

Urgh they better start buying ARTPOP

Link to post
Share on other sites

Aurajandro

ARTPOP is back at full price..

Come on... Just let it be discounted until she finishes the NA leg of the tour...  :toofunny:

Link to post
Share on other sites

How could it be 2.3 millions copies sold knowing that it's been out of top 100 (or top 200) in most country..

 

I'm not a hater but 2.3 million is impossible, really. 

The 2.3 million figure came from IFPI, the only reputable source out there in terms of worldwide record sales recognized by the music industry and not just the social media community. Even prior to the release of ARTPOP, the figures from IFPI have been universally regarded as the closest to the actual sales, considering there's currently no Nielsen SoundScan counterpart which tracks all record sales worldwide. I don't understand why suddenly the data from IFPI should be regarded as shipments now just because they're showing ARTPOP has sold 2.3 million, when in the past, even prior to the rise of Gaga, they're widely accepted as sales.  

Link to post
Share on other sites

It's only impossible to those who want to be negative and the haters. To everyone else we can just check a pdf file stating sales reports. Facts >>>>>> what we think/believe/our opinion

 

Agreed. The figure released is technically a fact. Unless someone discredit the entire reputation of IFPI, then that'll be the only time for it to be opened for contention. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

monketsharona

The 2.3 million figure came from IFPI, the only reputable source out there in terms of worldwide record sales recognized by the music industry and not just the social media community. Even prior to the release of ARTPOP, the figures from IFPI have been universally regarded as the closest to the actual sales, considering there's currently no Nielsen SoundScan counterpart which tracks all record sales worldwide. I don't understand why suddenly the data from IFPI should be regarded as shipments now just because they're showing ARTPOP has sold 2.3 million, when in the past, even prior to the rise of Gaga, they're widely accepted as sales.  

oh thanks ! I didn't know ! :)

I though Media traffic was the most reliable source for WW sales

Link to post
Share on other sites

VforVendetta

The 2.3 million figure came from IFPI, the only reputable source out there in terms of worldwide record sales recognized by the music industry and not just the social media community. Even prior to the release of ARTPOP, the figures from IFPI have been universally regarded as the closest to the actual sales, considering there's currently no Nielsen SoundScan counterpart which tracks all record sales worldwide. I don't understand why suddenly the data from IFPI should be regarded as shipments now just because they're showing ARTPOP has sold 2.3 million, when in the past, even prior to the rise of Gaga, they're widely accepted as sales.

This, shipments or not, it is what it is and it is not counting only for Gaga but for everyone else as well. So its a fact and its official.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Agreed. The figure released is technically a fact. Unless someone discredit the entire reputation of IFPI, then that'll be the only time for it to be opened for contention. 

Exactly! We cannot just say shipments like that. Since facts point towards them being actual sales then until someone discredits that people (especially MONSTERS) should stop pushing the 1.8M figure. I am certain that had IFPI written shipments or sales to retailers no one would be disputing it. And therefore no one should assume the 2.3M figure is not sales.

The 2.3 million figure came from IFPI, the only reputable source out there in terms of worldwide record sales recognized by the music industry and not just the social media community. Even prior to the release of ARTPOP, the figures from IFPI have been universally regarded as the closest to the actual sales, considering there's currently no Nielsen SoundScan counterpart which tracks all record sales worldwide. I don't understand why suddenly the data from IFPI should be regarded as shipments now just because they're showing ARTPOP has sold 2.3 million, when in the past, even prior to the rise of Gaga, they're widely accepted as sales.  

tumblr_mrt3zbyh9G1ruhqgxo1_250.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites

VforVendetta

Exactly! We cannot just say shipments like that. Since facts point towards them being actual sales then until someone discredits that people (especially MONSTERS) should stop pushing the 1.8M figure. I am certain that had IFPI written shipments or sales to retailers no one would be disputing it. And therefore no one should assume the 2.3M figure is not sales.

Even if they are shipments anyway, these are the official numbers since forever, they make the rule. These numbers aren't only for Gaga but for all other artists so they are very fair.
Link to post
Share on other sites

The 2.3 million figure came from IFPI, the only reputable source out there in terms of worldwide record sales recognized by the music industry and not just the social media community. Even prior to the release of ARTPOP, the figures from IFPI have been universally regarded as the closest to the actual sales, considering there's currently no Nielsen SoundScan counterpart which tracks all record sales worldwide. I don't understand why suddenly the data from IFPI should be regarded as shipments now just because they're showing ARTPOP has sold 2.3 million, when in the past, even prior to the rise of Gaga, they're widely accepted as sales.  

:tea:  ... Thank you! It's as if Monsters want ARTPOP to sell less ...

Link to post
Share on other sites

VforVendetta

But 700 000 in the US for 2.3 M WW 1 600 000 outside US...

And where is the problem exactly? BTW has sold 2.2M in the US and 8M WW, so 6M outside for the US. Its a very healthy ratio for Gaga.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Even if they are shipments anyway, these are the official numbers since forever, they make the rule. These numbers aren't only for Gaga but for all other artists so they are very fair.

True, but since nowhere does it state they are shipments or sales to retailers we should not assume they're shipments. They have been reported as sales (and not sales to retailers).

 

 

:tea:  ... Thank you! It's as if Monsters want ARTPOP to sell less ...

:yes:

And where is the problem exactly? BTW has sold 2.2M in the US and 8M WW, so 6M outside for the US. Its a very healthy ratio for Gaga.

:trootea:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...