Better Song: Kill For Love vs Shape Of A Woman

[Controversiaga 14,742]

SHAPE!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Ladle Ghoulash 47,747]

Shouldn’t even be close, tbh. KFL is an excellent song, SOAW is flaming hot garbaggio.

KFL’s instrumental, vocal, grooves, and hook are all excellent. The band is tight asf, the sound is classic.

SOAW sounds like a stock instrumental from ANTM that someone drunkenly recorded concept vocals over and never finished writing.

Edited 5 hours ago by Ladle Ghoulash

[Ladle Ghoulash 47,747]

12 minutes ago, NUTELLA said:

Shape Of A Woman's first 15 seconds >

Kill For Love's first 7 seconds >

 

Shape Of A Woman >

 

Kill For Love

 

The way you evaluate music is so fascinating to me. It’s kind of giving:

Pizza with no cheese vs. chicken salad (no mayo)

 

[dynamite 66,009]

13 minutes ago, NUTELLA said:

I don't really wanna listen to either 

But KFL has something!!

SOAW sounds like AI-KFL

Edited 5 hours ago by dynamite

[princedeeblebleble 3,265]

Pff idk, both suffer crom being very repetitive, but I guess overall Kill for love clears!

[NUTELLA 23,405]

3 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

Pizza with no cheese vs. chicken salad (no mayo)

Just leave it on the porch.

No tip

4 minutes ago, dynamite said:

KFL has something!!

Yeah, it has kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love,

[Lucas 30,518]

I listened to SOAW literally once. KFL like 10 times, this song is so forgettable, I always skip it and can never remember how it sounds like tbh

[Ladle Ghoulash 47,747]

1 minute ago, NUTELLA said:

Just leave it on the porch.

No tip

Yeah, it has kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love, kill for love, i'd kill for love, looove, it'd killll for, kill for love,

And the way the groove and melody of those sections clears every time she sings the “shape of a woman” a million times over the same drab melody. Ugh, KFL the SMASH you are. 

[NUTELLA 23,405]

5 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

And the way the groove and melody of those sections clears every time she sings the “shape of a woman” a million times over the same drab melody. Ugh, KFL the SMASH you are. 

Here are some concessions I will make:

 

I find SOAW's "etheeerealll" to be a bit sonically grating

& I think KFL's verses are adorable ("you know what I am baby & I know you're gonna ^be^ mine" sounds especially cute)

 

But despite a marvelous brass section near the end, KFL wears out its welcome before it ends

SOAW never does, imo

Edited 5 hours ago by NUTELLA

[Ladle Ghoulash 47,747]

2 minutes ago, NUTELLA said:

Here are some concessions I will make:

 

I find SOAW's "etheeerealll" to be a bit sonically grating

& I think KFL's verses are adorable ("you know what I am baby & I know you're gonna ^be^ mine" sounds especially cute)

 

But despite a marvelous brass section near the end, KFL wears out its welcome before it ends

SOAW never does, imo

SOAW loses me within the first 15-20 seconds tbh. Intro is fine (a bit bland, generic), verse melodies and lyrics are horrible (the fact that melody of the first line is phrased like the second line/resolution phrase and the first lyric sounds like it’s starting mid sentence drive me nuts), pre-chorus is unforgivably repetitive *and* bland, chorus is serviceable, but doesn’t make up for what it took to get there, then the post-choruses and bridge are let downs because they’re just rehashes of the stale pre-chorus. 

Edited 5 hours ago by Ladle Ghoulash

[gagacabana 6,130]

After having listened to SOAW approximately 110 times and KFL about 300 times, I can say for sure, kfl 

[DESTROY UR DISEASE 19,071]

I love Kill For Love and I know this might be too much for some of y'all to comprehend but I don't really seem to care

[ANVEEROY 65,031]

Why so close!!!!

Edited 4 hours ago by ANVEEROY

[Head Empty 26,668]

Both great productions yet lyrically lackluster.

KFL has better moments musically and it feels more 'alive' because of the instrumentation, but it drags too much for me. The vocals become a little too much to handle - I would've loved some more variety in her delivery during the second half of the song.

SOAW is a more comfortable listening experience. I adore the chorus and the growing synths that start after the second chorus. It gets me moving every time. It packs less of a punch but I definitely prefer it over KFL. I had it on replay for days after it released.

Edited 4 hours ago by Head Empty

[Kayioshka 3,123]

SOAW is so underrated 

It sounds so ethereal, passionate, haunting, heavenly and devilish.

Vocals :

Instrumental : 

So detailed. Too exquisite to be qualified of "Filler song".

Edited 3 hours ago by Kayioshka