Vanish Into You deserved better

[MaybeKermit 4,935]

3 minutes ago, MACATL said:

A record company is not financing a music video if they aren’t promoting a single that will well sell more albums.  They are business people, not artists.  

Im sure an artist of Gaga’s status can release an extra video if they WANT to. They are not struggling artists who need to prove they can get a first no1 hit. 

[bpmMonkey 5,944]

7 minutes ago, MACATL said:

what does her performing it live in concerts have to do with single releases? 

I wasn't referring to it being a single or not since it's a silly thing to cry for to begin with. The title of the thread it "VIY deserves better", that's what my comment was for. Imo VIY is well loved by her, she performed it every chance she got to in a concert setting and even closes the concerts with it (excluding the encores), therefor I think VIY is just fine where it is 😊

[holy scheisse 22,272]

19 minutes ago, MACATL said:

It’s not part of Mayhem.  

who said it was 

[Emvee 8,403]

I played VIY in my car yesterday and my mom said, “Lady Gaga has a great voice.” 

Ugh the GP would have eaten it up 

[dubstep111 666]

Thanks I’m so sick of the constant touring with albums. It takes away from singles and promo. Not everybody can afford concerts!!

Edited Monday at 02:29 PM by dubstep111

[Bronco 11,369]

59 minutes ago, MaybeKermit said:

Im sure an artist of Gaga’s status can release an extra video if they WANT to. They are not struggling artists who need to prove they can get a first no1 hit. 

Flop singles wreck eras and future prospects. 

But beyond that - why would you spend 6+ figures on a music video? And in the middle of an album era, when are you going to find the time in between the stuff you are contractually obliged to do? 

 

[chun li 2,907]

1 hour ago, Nicklev said:

I can't understand people who take it on the artist when they don't release their fave song as a single. At the point of insulting them or saying that they will stop stanning or listen to their songs. Such an infantile behavior like ranting for a 60 seconds closing song.

 

Vanish Into You is FAR from being my favourite song.
Lady Gaga isn't even my favourite singer anymore, I even said I don't listen to Mayhem nowadays.
I was just trying to understand why such an earworm of a song wasn't released as a single when it was time, from a business/exposure point of view

[chun li 2,907]

2 hours ago, bpmMonkey said:

True. She only performed the song for roughly 3M people in person til now, it really gets no love WHAT SO EVER ! SUCH A SHAME, SHE AND HER TEAM ARE TRYING TO RUIN HER CAREER.. 

I'm talking about releasing as a single and promoting it the same way Abracadabra was? Because it's a song that gets stucked in people's head...? 
What does performing have to do with this

[BELLYACHE 1,277]

Honestly only heard VIY once never cared to play it again, as well as HBDUWM and DCT

Edited Monday at 03:37 PM by BELLYACHE

[PapaLegba 9]

Defo single-worthy. I can't fathom the fact that there Eden and Vanish did get to become singles. Another wasted era of coulda woulda shoulda.

[princedeeblebleble 1,642]

5 hours ago, nATAH said:

girl  you're not as objective as you think you are

I mean it could have had some memeable uses :p using the Together horror film monents or the gay couples who look alike for "saw your face and mine" part, or can I am vanish into you for xxx related jokes etc.. also for wedding moments and proposals, its up there with DWAS in terms of ronance, but more fun!

[River 116,811]

I don't even care for a music video, just release it as a single officially to the radio and playlists 

[Ladle Ghoulash 24,611]

1 hour ago, chun li said:

Vanish Into You is FAR from being my favourite song.
Lady Gaga isn't even my favourite singer anymore, I even said I don't listen to Mayhem nowadays.
I was just trying to understand why such an earworm of a song wasn't released as a single when it was time, from a business/exposure point of view

“I don’t even listen to MAYHEM nowadays” should we throw a party? should we invite Madonna?

[suchheights8 286]

3 hours ago, MaybeKermit said:

Im sure an artist of Gaga’s status can release an extra video if they WANT to. They are not struggling artists who need to prove they can get a first no1 hit. 

I tend to agree with you. She did release John Wayne as a "just because" MV and there was no push for that song afterwards. Maybe we will get one more video after Dead Dance...we can only hope! 

[nATAH 49,304]

2 hours ago, chun li said:

I'm talking about releasing as a single and promoting it the same way Abracadabra was? Because it's a song that gets stucked in people's head...? 
What does performing have to do with this

because that's promotion and if it's not sticking when performed for around 2 million people on one beach for free, it's obviously a waste of money

idc for charts but i understand that for gaga as a pop musician, music means business and business means profit. the label is making a tonne of money from an already sold out tour, financially there is no need for another single cycle...

that's just the state of pop music these days, there's a lot less going on because it's *cheaper* to just playlist a song and hope for the best vs booking a bunch of promotional spots, hiring crew, planning performances etc and hoping for the best

am I happy with this? no, it's made pop music incredibly boring but it's also tiring to see people blame gaga's team for fumbling when they haven't realised the reality of the pop music scene these days

and yes, she probably could afford to make a video out of her own pocket unless there's some legal ties holding her back requiring label permission or whatever... or she simply doesn't wish to

Edited Monday at 06:15 PM by nATAH