Good 4 U vs Butter

[Aphasic 4,033]

I just heard Butter by BTS and I won't sugarcoat it, it's an awful song. But I know everyone has different taste. So what song you like more. I won't put a none/neither option because the point is to see which one you like better even if you don't super enjoy either song.

 

 

 

[Pennywise 36,079]

Good 4 U just to spite BTS fans tbh 

[gothicdream 39,548]

I don't like either. BTS I guess has a more catchy rhythm?

I just realized how much Good 4 U sounds like Misery Business to me, esp the chorus.

[holy scheisse 22,254]

Good 4 u appeals to my emo millenial soul

[tyler k 5,330]

is this a joke?

GOOD 4 U DUHHHH

[Aphasic 4,033]

5 minutes ago, Pennywise said:

Good 4 U just to spite BTS fans tbh 

But kinda "objectively" speaking Good 4 U has more merit because it was written by Olivia Rodrigo and Daniel Nigri where BTS’ second English-language track was written by Rob Grimaldi, Stephen Kirk (vocal production), Alex Bilowitz, Sebastian Garcia, Ron Perry, RM, and Jenna Andrews.

[PEZ 6,227]

I thought Butter had lyrics that were a bit clunky in parts. It's fairly cute otherwise but eh, wouldn't seek it out again. So I voted for Good 4 U, I thought it was a bit better constructed as a track.

[Pennywise 36,079]

Just now, Aphasic said:

But kinda "objectively" speaking Good 4 U has more merit because it was written by Olivia Rodrigo and Daniel Nigri where BTS’ second English-language track was written by Rob Grimaldi, Stephen Kirk (vocal production), Alex Bilowitz, Sebastian Garcia, Ron Perry, RM, and Jenna Andrews.

That IS true. But you could put literally any song there and I'd pick that instead of Butter because I'm mean and I don't want those children to be happy 

[Aphasic 4,033]

Just now, PEZ said:

I thought Butter had lyrics that were a bit clunky in parts. It's fairly cute otherwise but eh, wouldn't seek it out again. So I voted for Good 4 U, I thought it was a bit better constructed as a track.

Well Butter has 7 writers and Good 4 U has 2 (Olivia herself and Daniel Nigro).

[Aphasic 4,033]

2 minutes ago, Pennywise said:

That IS true. But you could put literally any song there and I'd pick that instead of Butter because I'm mean and I don't want those children to be happy 

They Beyoncéd their song 

[Lucas 26,806]

Just listened to both and I have to say none of them deserve to even be top 5 

[OhGG 433]

None 

[MonSwiftAnton 3,746]

I think butter is ok, but Good 4 u is a great song! Such a throwback to mid-late 00's emo music. 

[StarstruckIllusion 52,575]

Butter is pop perfection and good 4 u is meh. We will be rooting for ha buttery success ✨

[Aphasic 4,033]

6 minutes ago, StarstruckIllusion said:

Butter is pop perfection and good 4 u is meh. We will be rooting for ha buttery success ✨

Sorry to disagree but Butter will be forgotten in 3, 2, 1, boom it made no impact where Olivia has already created a bigger pop cultural impact with just 3 singles, 2 of which debuted at No 1.