Jump to content

US Charts Discussion


Arturo

Featured Posts

omg you annoy me so much ...

Just because TEOG is safe doesn't mean It's not artistic. . .  And just because you can't find Gypsy interesting, doesn't mean It's not ... 

In my opinion (And most of the fans since Gypsy and GUY are fan favourites and Venus is far behind) Gypsy is the best song on ARTPOP ...

Starts off as piano ballad ---->  goes mid-tempo ---->  then goes uptempo ..  THERE IS LITERALLY NO OTHER SONG LIKE IT .

 

Gypsy is hair 2.0

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 34.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

I'm gonna go watch Supernatural and dream of an era where Gaga is experimental and not releasing singles for chart success Venus, ARTPOP, Dope, Aura

I don't wanna be alone forever but I can be tonight might as well get into it....

Well I don't know how you have staned for Gaga because

After Poker Face every single has been released for chart success :toofunny:

Lovegame

Paparazzi

Bad Romance

Telephone ft. Bey

Alejandro

Born This Way

Judas (well i don't know what were they thinking but It definitely has to do with the fact that Judas is BR's little sis)

The Edge Of Glory

You and I (probably because of the Adele Impact)

Marry The Night (they were thinking it's the biggest smash on BTW :rip: )

Then Applause

 Do What U want

And now Gypsy ..

Gypsy is hair 2.0

Great :party:  I was always for Hair to be the 5th single Instead of Marry The Night :party: It would've been top 10 ... And  Billboard also said the same thing - that Boys Boys Boys, Speechless, Monster and Hair are Gaga's top 10s that never got a chance !

Link to post
Share on other sites

Well I don't know how you have staned for Gaga because

After Poker Face every single has been released for chart success :toofunny:

Lovegame

Paparazzi

Bad Romance

Telephone ft. Bey

Alejandro

Born This Way

Judas (well i don't know what were they thinking but It definitely has to do with the fact that Judas is BR's little sis)

The Edge Of Glory

You and I (probably because of the Adele Impact)

Marry The Night (they were thinking it's the biggest smash on BTW :rip: )

Then Applause

 Do What U want

And now Gypsy ..

Doesn't matter what they thought...paparazzi wasn't a sure fire hit cause nothing was like it on the radio and besides it has that Gaga quality about it I don't even know how to describe it, Alejandro was safe yes but the video wasn't, telephone was definitely made for the charts yes, LoveGame was the first song of Gaga I've heard and it's a Gaga classic due to the disco stick line, it's different. All those songs have that special something (except for telephone which is her worst single ever) that Gypsy...lacks. I find Gypsy bland, not boring, just very plain, there's nothing about that makes me go yaaaaaas now this is what I'm talking about!!!! It just doesn't, I'm sorry.

Link to post
Share on other sites

To be honest I still a little bit mad for the DWUW video... Really I can't accept that we are not gonna have the video for the second single, she waisted a lot of time to promote it for nothing, I really can't at this.

Link to post
Share on other sites

hausofmike

To be honest I still a little bit mad for the DWUW video... Really I can't accept that we are not gonna have the video for the second single, she waisted a lot of time to promote it for nothing, I really can't at this.

Ik. That's what's getting me. This song could have been bigger than that horrible lead single. If only it had a video.

Link to post
Share on other sites

BTW singles were more ARTPOP then ARTPOP singles :toofunny: where's the controversy? Where are the cheeky, fun, crazy songs that made me fall in love with Gaga?

 

This

 

I'm gonna go watch Supernatural and dream of an era where Gaga is experimental and not releasing singles for chart success :emma: Venus, ARTPOP, Dope, Aura :legend:

 

this this this this this

 

@Mariano: Billboard also said that Unconditionally is a sure #1 hit :) Gypsy isn't unique. It's a re-made Hair lol. And Hair is much better than Gypsy.

 

Born This Way >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ARTPOP

Link to post
Share on other sites

Doesn't matter what they thought...paparazzi wasn't a sure fire hit cause nothing was like it on the radio and besides it has that Gaga quality about it I don't even know how to describe it, Alejandro was safe yes but the video wasn't, telephone was definitely made for the charts yes, LoveGame was the first song of Gaga I've heard and it's a Gaga classic due to the disco stick line, it's different. All those songs have that special something (except for telephone which is her worst single ever) that Gypsy...lacks. I find Gypsy bland, not boring, just very plain, there's nothing about that makes me go yaaaaaas now this is what I'm talking about!!!! It just doesn't, I'm sorry.

but this is your opinion again... I find Gypsy to be one of Gaga's best songs.  And I am not alone, u know ?

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=454797   Venus is not even top 5 :giveup:

And I can't find the Gagadaily poll but Gypsy and GUY were also the top 2 songs ...

 I mean the majority loves Gypsy over Venus, That definitely means something u know ?

I just don't like how you (venus stans) are talking about Gypsy, if anything about Gaga is pretentious, It's her fans sometimes. 

Venus not being top 5 MUST MEAN SOMETHING u know ...

Born This Way >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ARTPOP

I agree. 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

The Fame Monster

#37 Luxembourg (+15)
#43 Sweden (+51)
#49 Finland (+27)
#91 Norway (+12)
#120 Denmark (+160)
#143 Ireland
#148 Ukraine
#151 New Zealand (+146)
#152 Belgium (+203)
#154 Austria (+199)
#156 Portugal
#172 Spain (+154)
#181 Ireland
#202 Netherlands (+188)
#214 Costa Rica
#217 United Kingdom (+66)

 

#Monster3rdSingle 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Born This Way >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ARTPOP

I prefer BTW the album to ARTPOP but as far as singles go ARTPOP had the potential to crap all over BTW singles (except for the goddess that is TEOG) and instead it feels so underwhelming. Most boring single choices.

Still stanning for her and I don't want to introduce any negativity but really, the disappointment hit me like a blow to the chest. I was here for an experimental era not this. Sure she may yet release an experimental songs but what if Gypsy doesn't become a hit? Are we always going to have to release safe singles before we try an experimental one? :rip: I stan for Gaga because she's different than anyone else, her releasing songs which do not differentiate her and have that Gaga-ness just make her and her singles blur into all other top 40 songs and that's very...underwhelming and unexciting.

but this is your opinion again... I find Gypsy to be one of Gaga's best songs.  And I am not alone, u know ?http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=454797   Venus is not even top 5 :giveup:

And I can't find the Gagadaily poll but Gypsy and GUY were also the top 2 songs ...

 I mean the majority loves Gypsy over Venus, That definitely means something u know ?

I just don't like how you (venus stans) are talking about Gypsy, if anything about Gaga is pretentious, It's her fans sometimes. 

Venus not being top 5 MUST MEAN SOMETHING u know ...

I agree.

I'm not talking about what our favourites are or which is the best song though :awkney: this is not about Venus vs gypsy. you know gypsy is in my top 5 I've said it countless times. But I thought this would be a different era and instead it's looking like a normal top 40 artist releasing songs to smash hard and get dem sales and dem receipts....
Link to post
Share on other sites

I prefer BTW the album to ARTPOP but as far as singles go ARTPOP had the potential to crap all over BTW singles (except for the goddess that is TEOG) and instead it feels so underwhelming. Most boring single choices.

Still stanning for her and I don't want to introduce any negativity but really, the disappointment hit me like a blow to the chest. I was here for an experimental era not this. Sure she may yet release an experimental songs but what if Gypsy doesn't become a hit? Are we always going to have to release safe singles before we try an experimental one? :rip: I stan for Gaga because she's different than anyone else, her releasing songs which do not differentiate her and have that Gaga-ness just make her and her singles blur into all other top 40 songs and that's very...underwhelming and unexciting.

I'm not talking about what our favourites are or which is the best song though :awkney: this is not about Venus vs gypsy. you know gypsy is in my top 5 I've said it countless times. But I thought this would be a different era and instead it's looking like a normal top 40 artist releasing songs to smash hard and get dem sales and dem receipts....

You should've realized that with the release of Applause. You are saying that just to shade Gypsy, NO THANKS !

Link to post
Share on other sites

but this is your opinion again... I find Gypsy to be one of Gaga's best songs.  And I am not alone, u know ?

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=454797   Venus is not even top 5 :giveup:

And I can't find the Gagadaily poll but Gypsy and GUY were also the top 2 songs ...

 I mean the majority loves Gypsy over Venus, That definitely means something u know ?

I just don't like how you (venus stans) are talking about Gypsy, if anything about Gaga is pretentious, It's her fans sometimes. 

Venus not being top 5 MUST MEAN SOMETHING u know ...

I agree. 

 

But ATRL stans for KATY which should TELL YOU SOMETHING, you know ? I'd like an official poll to be made, like the one in the BTW era about the 4th single, to really see which is the fan favourite. I really doubt it's Gypsy. Most polls are made by users, not by the site itself - and not even half of the site votes. If we'd have a poll made by the admin on the NEWS PAGE, we'd probably get much more accurate info regarding the fan favourites ;)

Link to post
Share on other sites

And please stop with the experiment bull****, obviously you don't know **** about RISK TAKING MANAGEMENT in the Media Industry.

When Risk is going to be taken it needs to have a huge chance of success.  Venus' chance of flopping is way bigger than Its chance of smashing .  .  . Even if it gets released as a single, It won't be because It will smash, It will be released just for the sake of it  or because Gaga wants it or because of the great Visuals...

Link to post
Share on other sites

But ATRL stans for KATY which should TELL YOU SOMETHING, you know ? I'd like an official poll to be made, like the one in the BTW era about the 4th single, to really see which is the fan favourite. I really doubt it's Gypsy. Most polls are made by users, not by the site itself - and not even half of the site votes. If we'd have a poll made by the admin on the NEWS PAGE, we'd probably get much more accurate info regarding the fan favourites ;)

Ok let me send you another poll

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=490287

More people stan for Kelly Clarckson and Ellie Goulding than  Katy Perry :lmao:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...