The 1-2-3-4 punch of MAYHEM or ARTPOP?

[MountainMonster 2,650]

MAYHEM. Truly, I always feel like the newest Gaga album is my favorite. But I do think this one will endure as an all time favorite for me. 

[GerMonsterNotta 2,132]

Is the 1234 punch of BTW an option…

MTN🔥 - BTW👽 - GH 💋- Judas 🏍️

[REALITY 80,140]

MAYHEM, but I like both runs.

I like GUY and Sexxx Dreams, Venus is good too, but a little less so for me, and tbh I've never been a huge fan of Aura.

Abra and GOE are the two standouts, and I like PC. I still like Disease, but I've replayed it so much that I need a break from that one

[27monster27 15,806]

4 hours ago, nATAH said:

it was a mess from day 1 chile i'll never understand those who say it's her best 

she has some really stunning moments but my god she crammed every idea she had on the mood board into it

This is because of what happened with her management. She promised fans so many visuals, and her management fall meant that it never happened. This is why the music video is technically multiple in one (Venus, GUY, MANiCURE), because this was really both a gift to fans AND a message about capitalism in the industry making artists appear disposable (which is what her management did).

[MACATL 2,102]

Mayhem without a second thought.  ARTPOP production is garbage.  

[Red 99,100]

MAYHEM humiliates ARTPOP in every way, shape and form 

[TimotheeChalamet 6,936]

The first half of Mayhem is the best run in a Gaga album ever

[angelduuh 562]

Mayhem x10

I'm ready to admit that ARTPOP didn't age well for me at all, don't hate me 

[nATAH 56,565]

8 hours ago, 27monster27 said:

This is because of what happened with her management. She promised fans so many visuals, and her management fall meant that it never happened. This is why the music video is technically multiple in one (Venus, GUY, MANiCURE), because this was really both a gift to fans AND a message about capitalism in the industry making artists appear disposable (which is what her management did).

the Venus GUY Manicure mashup isn't the issue, it's the really corny stuff like the bad CGI on andy and her, the resurrection of dead legends, "Minecraft ARTPOP mode", the real housewives playing the instruments... really lowered the quality

but the fashion, the pool scenes, the stunning architecture, the wig, choreography, the real housewives as body guards and anti-label storyline were all great and solid on their own

there's such a clear difference in quality between some scenes

[Panchecco 17,855]

MAYHEM devours ARTPOP imo

my tops would be:

1. Disease                       Venus
2. Perfect Celebrity      Aura
3. Abracadabra             G.U.Y.
4. Garden Of Eden       Sexxx Dreams

[Haldy 1,295]

Mayhem demolishes ARTPOP in this. The only fair fight if G.U.Y vs Garden of Eden and I'd still call it a tie.

[bim 797]

Disease is one of the best songs of her career imo. Especially when we have those live acoustic antidote and poison versions. It’s also wild to think that was the first live performance from Mayhem, worked perfectly. 

[monketsharona 90,030]

MAYHEM 

[monketsharona 90,030]

Also let's give some flowers to the old sis The Fame & The Fame Monster because those punched ever harder :

Just Dance - LoveGame - Paparazzi - Poker Face 🔥

Bad Romance - Alejandro  - Monster 💥

[27monster27 15,806]

4 hours ago, nATAH said:

the Venus GUY Manicure mashup isn't the issue, it's the really corny stuff like the bad CGI on andy and her, the resurrection of dead legends, "Minecraft ARTPOP mode", the real housewives playing the instruments... really lowered the quality

but the fashion, the pool scenes, the stunning architecture, the wig, choreography, the real housewives as body guards and anti-label storyline were all great and solid on their own

there's such a clear difference in quality between some scenes

I actually can see this point. I just feel bad and like to give her a handicap with music videos this era just because of how her management did not honor her creativity, and eventually abandoned her.