Pitchfork gets dragged for their review of Zayn’s new album

[BUtterfield 8 22,000]

So originally they wrote this and they edited it 

Read the full review here

[NORMANDIE 1,417]

[Red 79,533]

I despise "reviews" that review the personal life, the love life, the past work, the color of the underwear, everything of the artist except the body of work they are supposed to review. Literally every ARTPOP review was like that, it was an essay about how Gaga was a decadent attention w.hore with two lines abou ARTPOP.

[MadreMonster 702]

.

Edited January 20 by MadreMonster

[swakby 3,694]

Their other points are very strong though. Countless albums in, he sounds like an absolute amateur. 

[Lucas 13,127]

1 minute ago, swakby said:

Countless albums in

Erh he has only 3 albums out, but yeah the quality is declining. Mind of Mine was excellent, the 2 next were really disappointing

[DelusionalGaga 25,956]

Dragged by one fan account dedicated to Zayn? OK

[swakby 3,694]

Just now, Lucas said:

Erh he has only 3 albums out, but yeah the quality is declining. Mind of Mine was excellent, the 2 next were really disappointing

Doesn’t he have 4-5 albums with 1D? I’d say it’s enough experience to shape him as a musician.

[BUtterfield 8 22,000]

10 minutes ago, DelusionalGaga said:

Dragged by one fan account dedicated to Zayn? OK

So you agree with the use of the capitol riots for a review about an album?

[omagaga 141]

LOOOOOOOOL SO TRUE JADORE

[Poissonche 12,285]

31 minutes ago, Red said:

I despise "reviews" that review the personal life, the love life, the past work, the color of the underwear, everything of the artist except the body of work they are supposed to review. Literally every ARTPOP review was like that, it was an essay about how Gaga was a decadent attention w.hore with two lines abou ARTPOP.

And even that review that was all about "She wore a meat-dress and came to the Grammys in an egg, urgh, so unnecessary, this is why Joanne is bad"

[InstantDejavu 243]

I don't see a bad thing? They literally say Zayn posted his phone number 5 days after the riots to let people talk about something else.

In the screenshot posted there is aboslutely no link between the album review and riots? Therefore they don't use the riots in an album review. 

The riots were an action and Zayn reacted which led to his album. 

If they said something like "zayn's album is as bad ad the riots were" then I would agree but with this screenshot, nope.

[ItWasntLaauv 4,686]

I dont think it’s racist, it’s just f*cking dumb and tone deaf. Why reference that in a review for anything?

[DelusionalGaga 25,956]

49 minutes ago, BUtterfield 8 said:

So you agree with the use of the capitol riots for a review about an album?

I'm indifferent about it. It's not like they made fun of the riots or something. Their point is that Zayn is out of touch. It's a stupid comparison but whatever. 

[dolce vita 12,329]

It’s why I don’t take reviews seriously. Looking to pretentious music journalists to see if an album is good or not in 2021 is just...not what we need to do