Gaga's worst song is a concept

[tomdsgn 1,913]

30 minutes ago, KARMA said:

That is why she made it so generic to prove said issue, and it works, people are talking about it and criticizing about how bad it is.

Pretty sure DJWS was a bit offended by the idea that they purposely made a “bad” song. They didn’t intend to make a “bad” song, just an unapologetic chart pop song. 

[crybrowz 3,241]

Just dropping in to say Plastic Doll is a career highlight 

 

That is all 

[rumours 45,521]

While Plastic Doll is indeed terrible, I’m not sure it’s fair to say it’s WDYDT or Donatella level bad. 

[HausOfAntonio 8,021]

24 minutes ago, Lorde Von Kok said:

ENOUGH WITH THE PLASTIC DOLL HATE

Don't you get it ? It is superb and meant to be, just enjoy it.

TASTEEEEE SHOWED I CAME HERE TO SAY THIS 

 

Plastic Doll is a slap. Period. 
 

People can’t genuinely be saying its her worst song when literal Money Honey exists 

 

And Money Honey is still a good song 

[Guest]

30 minutes ago, 21st Century Karen said:

Do you mean

Where are you?
'Cause I can't see
But I feel you watchin' me
Dilated, falling free
In a modern ecstasy

part?

Repent. 

1:50 - 3:04 It wasnt love, it was a perfext dellusion x10000 

[KARMA 1,022]

16 minutes ago, tomdsgn said:

Pretty sure DJWS was a bit offended by the idea that they purposely made a “bad” song. They didn’t intend to make a “bad” song, just an unapologetic chart pop song. 

Yes, cheers to that...it is purposely made playful and is meant to be just that

[HausOfAntonio 8,021]

1 minute ago, Kapi09 said:

1:50 - 3:04 It wasnt love, it was a perfext dellusion x10000 

Perfect Illusion is her most underrated song it deserved to smash harder than BTW AT LEAST 

[ChromaticRaccoon 1,761]

WDYDT is a BOP, Y'all gotta stop hating on things for being 'generic' LMAO that doesn't make it bad 

[PartySick 153,480]

1 hour ago, 21st Century Karen said:

Didn't  explain that they made Why Did You Do That on purpose? Like, it supposed to be generic? 

I still like this song, l@l, for me it's better than Heal Me. 

 

1 hour ago, KARMA said:

Yes!! But alot of people buys it as a serious song lol 

She said the exact opposite, actually. WDYDT and some of the other pop songs were actually demos that were being considered for Gaga's album but fit into the film better.

Source: those leaked court documents

[Massive Monster 4,988]

If you think Plastic Doll is badly written I feel sorry for you

[Defmix100 6,206]

1 hour ago, 21st Century Karen said:

Didn't  explain that they made Why Did You Do That on purpose? Like, it supposed to be generic? 

I still like this song, l@l, for me it's better than Heal Me. 

I thought she took it seriously and didn't know they were basically going to trash it in Scene 98

[Pennywise 36,007]

I think Plastic Doll is not only badly written, it's worse. It's cheesily written. Now I know Gaga has some really cheesy lines that we all know and love (it when you call me legs, in the morning buy me eggs), but for Plastic Doll it is the whole song. It sounds really amateur-ish in terms of songwriting. And it doesn't help that it is also not really well-produced. I honestly don't know what they were thinking when they were putting it on the album tbh. 

And no, this is not flamebait, thank you. 

 

Spoiler

 

[Phlop 4,773]

And Enigma

[KARMA 1,022]

6 minutes ago, Pennywise said:

I think Plastic Doll is not only badly written, it's worse. It's cheesily written. Now I know Gaga has some really cheesy lines that we all know and love (it when you call me legs, in the morning buy me eggs), but for Plastic Doll it is the whole song. It sounds really amateur-ish in terms of songwriting. And it doesn't help that it is also not really well-produced. I honestly don't know what they were thinking when they were putting it on the album tbh. 

And no, this is not flamebait, thank you. 

 

  Hide contents

 

You have the right to your opinion

[Flippy 12,252]

I actually love and enjoy Plastic Doll + WDYDT & don't consider them 'bad' so.... Yeah...