"Sine from above" was intented for Elton only 7 years ago

[S0436 10,215]

They brought in a lot of other producers, so it was probably vastly changed and only the dna of the track from Axwell remains.  

[BetrayedSTAN 1,839]

She reworked a 7 years old song that it was not meant for her and at the same time she kept sitting on frankensteined despite the fact that it's a phenomenal song that would revolutionize pop music again ..

Gaga's mind can't fail to confuse me sometimes 

Edit: i loved sine from above btw but JUSTICE for FRANKENSTEINED 

[AlwaysLoveGaga 4,297]

2 minutes ago, Red said:

I imagine Gaga re-wrote the lyrics

My guess is the production was a constant and possible some of Elton's verse. I wouldn't be surprised if the concept of the "sine" along with most of the lyrics were all Gaga.

[Gracious Gaga 17,163]

yeah a good amount of songs on this album sound like they've been sat on for years & years 

[holy scheisse 22,388]

Sine from above is perfect. It's like the wise spiritual song of the album lol

[DC 25,164]

4 minutes ago, Sneaky said:

"7 years ago"

Yeah, it shows

Like don't even @ me, it sounds dated no matter how you cut it lol. 

But dated doesn't automatically mean BAD either, so..

No I'm @ing you. I'm disappointing by your statement.

[Red 98,356]

Just now, Gracious Gaga said:

yeah a good amount of songs on this album sound like they've been sat on for years & years 

Poor songs, they must be flat now

[sadboy 375]

1 hour ago, Sneaky said:

"7 years ago"

Yeah, it shows

Like don't even @ me, it sounds dated no matter how you cut it lol. 

But dated doesn't automatically mean BAD either, so..

How does it sound 'dated' to you? It's literally one of the most experimental tracks on the album talking production wise imo

[OMonster 14,761]

5 minutes ago, moonsago said:

I love it but I still skip the end, its the one part I do not understand lol

The end, imo, is meant to be a visceral explosion of how music saved both Gaga and Elton. 

It's the manifestation of all they're singing about - it's the 'sine' they heard. 

I also think, if you listen to it, it sounds a lot like a fast-forward track. So, the song itself depicts when they heard the sine and the end of the track takes us to the present where they're both established superstars healed by music. 

It's supposed to sound chaotic and explosive and unbalanced to represent the deep, unexplainable passion they have for music. 

That's just my view, of course. But with this interpretation, the song really moves me. There's something stunning about two major artists singing about how music saved them - particularly considering their past traumas. 

[Gracious Gaga 17,163]

9 minutes ago, Sneaky said:

"7 years ago"

Yeah, it shows

Like don't even @ me, it sounds dated no matter how you cut it lol. 

But dated doesn't automatically mean BAD either, so..

agree w/ u

[Awakened M 3,057]

Comments about it being dated are dated.  Shut up!

[BleepBloop 10,316]

1 minute ago, ProjectJoanne said:

No I'm @ing you. I'm disappointing by your statement.

Doesn't change the fact that I'm right, though

[DC 25,164]

Just now, Sneaky said:

Doesn't change the fact that I'm right, though

In your delusional world, yes 

For the rest of us, no 

 

 

Spoiler

How long are we gonna keep this up? 

[FentyGa 14,340]

she just had to keep elt*n on it huh lol

still a great song tho!

[Enzo 37,977]

People acting as as if the song we have was fully made 7 years ago and not produced again by Bloodpop or something