Alii 2,039 Posted June 7, 2019 Share Posted June 7, 2019 12 hours ago, Economy said: If our government would just raise retirement age like other developed nations are doing to compensate for longer life expectancies and lower birth rates maybe we Wouldn't have to accept such a large number of immigrants to keep our workforce and demographics stable Harper did what was necessary when he raised it to 67 and Trudeau for campaigning went and reversed a necessary reform And what does he do Instead to keep demographics stable? Raise immigration from 250,000 a year to 330,000 a year, a number that is hard to absorb without infrastructure and housing constraints (and housing was already tight to begin with before his annual increase) Our economic challanges will never be solved as long as people oppose making necessary sacrifices Until ppl in this country accept that we can't keep retirement age at 65 anymore, there's gonna be pain one way or another... Either the economy stalls from too many ppl retiring and our standard of living drops, or we have to accept an unreasonable number of young people yearly to compensate and the unbearable housing costs also affect our standard of living Canadians stubborn stance on keeping retirement the standard 65 is costing us more pain than the pain if just working 2 or 3 extra years USA, UK, Germany, Italy, Portugal... Countless other first world nations have either raised or are making plans to do so... We need to as well That man Trudeau is a joke. People like him are the reason why Liberals aren’t being taken seriously anymore. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
The13thNote 1,390 Posted June 7, 2019 Share Posted June 7, 2019 13 hours ago, Economy said: My suburb city (Brampton) also climbed up the ranks fast We were pretty irrelevant 20 years ago now we are the 8th biggest city in Canada and 3rd biggest city in the Toronto area I know the feeling of growing pains When I moved here 14 years ago it was a peaceful medium sized city now when I leave the gym at 8:30 pm I can no longer make a left on the road and it's supposed to be past rush hour Yah its crazy. I know the annoyances traffic can make. In 2009 what was once a cute little gayborhood/arts district called the Short North has become as urbanized and congested as Manhattan. All the yuppie white new money moving in and taking over the old storefronts with stereotypical shopping and high rise basic lofts being built everywhere. Its completely shifted the artistic young and gay crowds to different neighborhoods in a matter of under 5 years. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Economy 52,854 Posted June 7, 2019 Author Share Posted June 7, 2019 31 minutes ago, Whispering said: Decades ago, someone in a position like yours would have worked their manual labor job until they died. They wouldn’t have had an option to take online courses as they worked or even be a “personal trainer”. People didn’t waste time going to gyms, they worked hard at their jobs and around their home. You might feel different after you’ve worked for fifty years at your job you don’t even want to be at now. You might be ready for a few years to relax, do hobbies, visit family, travel, etc. Wanting to have a few years at the end of your life isn’t any more being a spoiled baby than people looking for their job that they are “passionate” over. Generations ago, people weren’t so concerned over being “happy” at work. Ur totally missing my point here This is not a discussion about what we want or what's nice to have This is a discussion about what's necessary And it's a problem that in society these days when something is necessary but unpleasant ppl would rather pretend it doesn't have to be dealt with That fact that u want to enjoy more hobbies for longer doesn't change the reality of the situation at all one bit The only other solution is to significantly increase CPP deduction premiums or decrease payouts to retirees... Both will negatively impact the economy and both will impact people's lives as well either in their working years or when they retire I don't know why ppl think something is unpleasant somehow makes it ok to act like the problem doesn't exist and doesn't have to be dealt with Birth rates have literally ranked so much and life expectancy risen so much since the 65 retirement age was set.... What in anyone's right mind makes them think it's not an issue to just leave it the same? It's not sustainable Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Economy 52,854 Posted June 7, 2019 Author Share Posted June 7, 2019 31 minutes ago, Alii said: That man Trudeau is a joke. People like him are the reason why Liberals aren’t being taken seriously anymore. So u agree with me on retirement? If so I'd literally be the first person on GGD to acknowledge this issue and that it has to be dealt with My issue with Liberals (although I don't like very right winged capitalism either but in talking about attitudes here not policies) is that when something is unpleasant they never want to deal with it Ppl are always ok with fixing issues as long as they aren't the ones to have to make sacrifices Everyone wants budget problems to be fixed as long as it's not their taxes that go up or the services they use that get cut but it's fine if it's someone else's We can't fix problems with this kind of mentality And the retirement age reform thing is such an obvious need that if people can't even acknowledge that because it "sucks to have to work longer and have time taken away from hobbies" as a reason to not deal with it.... Than I don't even know what to say anymore Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Whispering 18,865 Posted June 7, 2019 Share Posted June 7, 2019 11 minutes ago, Economy said: Ur totally missing my point here This is not a discussion about what we want or what's nice to have This is a discussion about what's necessary And it's a problem that in society these days when something is necessary but unpleasant ppl would rather pretend it doesn't have to be dealt with That fact that u want to enjoy more hobbies for longer doesn't change the reality of the situation at all one bit The only other solution is to significantly increase CPP deduction premiums or decrease payouts to retirees... Both will negatively impact the economy and both will impact people's lives as well either in their working years or when they retire I don't know why ppl think something is unpleasant somehow makes it ok to act like the problem doesn't exist and doesn't have to be dealt with Birth rates have literally ranked so much and life expectancy risen so much since the 65 retirement age was set.... What in anyone's right mind makes them think it's not an issue to just leave it the same? It's not sustainable No, you are missing my point. People’s attitudes towards work and retirement have drastically changed over the generations. Your attitude towards your work and even your opportunities in the work world reflect those shifts we see in the last decades. That doesn’t mean people are “spoiled babies” for wanting to enjoy a healthy retirement no more than you are a “spoiled baby” for not being satisfied with your steady job. Maybe if we had more people working steady jobs, instead of being personal trainers... Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Alii 2,039 Posted June 7, 2019 Share Posted June 7, 2019 5 minutes ago, Economy said: So u agree with me on retirement? If so I'd literally be the first person on GGD to acknowledge this issue and that it has to be dealt with My issue with Liberals (although I don't like very right winged capitalism either but in talking about attitudes here not policies) is that when something is unpleasant they never want to deal with it Ppl are always ok with fixing issues as long as they aren't the ones to have to make sacrifices Everyone wants budget problems to be fixed as long as it's not their taxes that go up or the services they use that get cut but it's fine if it's someone else's We can't fix problems with this kind of mentality And the retirement age reform thing is such an obvious need that if people can't even acknowledge that because it "sucks to have to work longer and have time taken away from hobbies" as a reason to not deal with it.... Than I don't even know what to say anymore I’ll have to research about the average retirement age. 65 seems pretty old to be working. I heard that many countries have raised it before. But right wing supporters were claiming that Sweden did it to deal with the influx of refugees. Since they raised it around the refugee crisis. And I agree with what you said about Liberals. They prefer to lie to themselves than facing the truth. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Economy 52,854 Posted June 7, 2019 Author Share Posted June 7, 2019 Just now, Whispering said: No, you are missing my point. People’s attitudes towards work and retirement have drastically changed over the generations. Your attitude towards your work and even your opportunities in the work world reflect those shifts we see in the last decades. That doesn’t mean people are “spoiled babies” for wanting to enjoy a healthy retirement no more than you are a “spoiled baby” for not being satisfied with your steady job. Maybe if we had more people working steady jobs, instead of being personal trainers... I've been working the same job for 8 years consistently for low pay despite horrible working conditions Most ppl would of jumped around different jobs by now but I've stuck it out almost a decade. Im no spoiled baby And I get that attitudes have changed But what in trying to point out to u is that that doesn't change anything what's so ever Does the desire to enjoy our lives at the end justify doing nothing? And let the system continue unsustainably? Ur logic is EXACTLY the same as someone who can't afford their current lifestyle and puts it on credit and uses the rationale that they deserve to enjoy their lives Yeah maybe they deserve it but unfortunately that doesn't change the reality The system wasn't designed to accomodate so many retirees like this and it's a sustainability issue We can't do nothing just because we don't want to or we shouldn't have to work longer.... Like that literally doesn't change the reality of the situation What exactly do u propose we do? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
thewho 928 Posted June 7, 2019 Share Posted June 7, 2019 I'll pass on Toronto Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
thewho 928 Posted June 7, 2019 Share Posted June 7, 2019 3 minutes ago, Economy said: I've been working the same job for 8 years consistently for low pay despite horrible working conditions Most ppl would of jumped around different jobs by now but I've stuck it out almost a decade. Im no spoiled baby And I get that attitudes have changed But what in trying to point out to u is that that doesn't change anything what's so ever Does the desire to enjoy our lives at the end justify doing nothing? And let the system continue unsustainably? Ur logic is EXACTLY the same as someone who can't afford their current lifestyle and puts it on credit and uses the rationale that they deserve to enjoy their lives Yeah maybe they deserve it but unfortunately that doesn't change the reality The system wasn't designed to accomodate so many retirees like this and it's a sustainability issue We can't do nothing just because we don't want to or we shouldn't have to work longer.... Like that literally doesn't change the reality of the situation What exactly do u propose we do? Well said Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Economy 52,854 Posted June 7, 2019 Author Share Posted June 7, 2019 2 minutes ago, StrangeClerk said: Well said Like this isn't me being heartless it's me being realistic. U can't kick down the can of problems down the road forever just because dealing with it will be unpleasant Besides there's ways to minimize the suffering... For example, blue collar jobs that involve high physical labor could be exempted from the increase.... There's other jobs like teachers for example that can retire early so we could certainly do the same for jobs that are tougher to work at old ages in. High physical jobs are a smaller percentage of jobs now a days than ever before so making an exeption for them shouldn't come with a big cost Also we'd need to put a minimum number of years for jobs that are exempted from the increase so ppl don't seek to change jobs to a physical one when they are 64 just so they can retire right after cuz some ppl would so do that Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
thewho 928 Posted June 7, 2019 Share Posted June 7, 2019 2 minutes ago, Economy said: Like this isn't me being heartless it's me being realistic. U can't kick down the can of problems down the road forever just because dealing with it will be unpleasant Besides there's ways to minimize the suffering... For example, blue collar jobs that involve high physical labor could be exempted from the increase.... There's other jobs like teachers for example that can retire early so we could certainly do the same for jobs that are tougher to work at old ages in. High physical jobs are a smaller percentage of jobs now a days than ever before so making an exeption for them shouldn't come with a big cost Also we'd need to put a minimum number of years for jobs that are exempted from the increase so ppl don't seek to change jobs to a physical one when they are 64 just so they can retire right after cuz some ppl would so do that WAIT A SECOND. Teachers retire early in Canada? Are you serious? The USA education system is so f*cked up I know several teachers well into their 60s and 70s unable to retire because of the low salary, shitty benefits, and overall very crap morale. I literally left the teaching profession because it got THAT bad. I'm an engineer now so it worked out, but unfortunately had to leave a big chunk of my life behind. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Economy 52,854 Posted June 7, 2019 Author Share Posted June 7, 2019 7 minutes ago, StrangeClerk said: WAIT A SECOND. Teachers retire early in Canada? Are you serious? The USA education system is so f*cked up I know several teachers well into their 60s and 70s unable to retire because of the low salary, shitty benefits, and overall very crap morale. I literally left the teaching profession because it got THAT bad. I'm an engineer now so it worked out, but unfortunately had to leave a big chunk of my life behind. They can retire early if they've worked at least 30 years. At least in my Province (Ontario) It's also higher pay than in the US too. Close to $50,000 a year (depends on the board too and years experience some teachers make less) not bad considering u get summers off Being a teacher is a good job here. Good health benefits too in addition to supplemented retirement Edit: doctors get payed less here than in the US tho Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
thewho 928 Posted June 7, 2019 Share Posted June 7, 2019 11 minutes ago, Economy said: They can retire early if they've worked at least 30 years. At least in my Province (Ontario) It's also higher pay than in the US too. Close to $50,000 a year (depends on the board too and years experience some teachers make less) not bad considering u get summers off Being a teacher is a good job here. Good health benefits too in addition to supplemented retirement Edit: doctors get payed less here than in the US tho Wow. My heart literally shattered into a billion pieces lol Well I'm happy for teachers in Canada Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Economy 52,854 Posted June 7, 2019 Author Share Posted June 7, 2019 1 minute ago, StrangeClerk said: Wow. My heart literally shattered into a billion pieces lol Well I'm happy for teachers in Canada Yeah my uncle is a teacher. He hates it and tried other stuff but always goes back cuz it's good pay and benefits relative to hours worked They are gonna be on a wage freeze essentially (1% annaul) raise only tho for at least 3 years cuz of Ontarios budget problems Still better than my 0% annual raise for the last 3 years Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
thewho 928 Posted June 7, 2019 Share Posted June 7, 2019 5 minutes ago, Economy said: Yeah my uncle is a teacher. He hates it and tried other stuff but always goes back cuz it's good pay and benefits relative to hours worked Mines the opposite. I had to go back to bartending because I never made enough as a teacher. My first year I only made $30,000, and only took home $15,000 from taxes and other bullshit. As an engineer now, I make almost 10x that, which I am grateful for but it depresses me how much I had to struggle because of the mistreatment and neglect towards teachers. As a result I vowed to start a scholarship program for students and teachers alike, and programs to help fight anti-education legislation, promote school funding, and provide necessary equipment to teachers around the US Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Featured Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.