The Joanne Era Ended Tonight, But Did Gaga, too?

[DoremonLove 8,147]

11 minutes ago, Decodekid said:

remember when Gaga said that ARTPOP was the end of the beginning of her career, actually Joanne feels like it is. Your post makes sense.

Literally bcoz she lost grammy her career is ending  whaat is this mess im reading here she lost during BTW she was ignored during ARTPOP. This thread is making me sad more then her losing.

[hijadeputa 3,935]

1 minute ago, ELEMENTALITY said:

She also used to say music is the most important thing to her and got a tattoo about it on her arm.

Then when AHS came along she started saying "Actually I wanted to be an actress first but music just kind of happened."

 

So.....yes.....she doesn't always ring consistent. That could change. And it might have already. 

Also.....you think LG6 will be her peak? I'm not gonna argue that. You never know. Could be. But I wouldn't be so sure of that until you know....you actually hear it. 

there you have it. we wont know until we hear it. it is up to gaga if she wants world domination again, or maybe not domination but to still be in the game, am I right or not? 

[ryanripley 86,575]

1 minute ago, ELEMENTALITY said:

She also used to say music is the most important thing to her and got a tattoo about it on her arm.

Then when AHS came along she started saying "Actually I wanted to be an actress first but music just kind of happened."

 

So.....yes.....she doesn't always ring consistent. That could change. And it might have already. 

Also.....you think LG6 will be her peak? I'm not gonna argue that. You never know. Could be. But I wouldn't be so sure of that until you know....you actually hear it. 

Okay maybe close to Britney. But Britney is still getting radio play 20 years into her career. Not massive, but they still debut her music. Whats sad is Gaga is only 9 years in and PI was getting the same play as Britney's "Make Me".

 

Madonna though is not arguable. I don't care what anyone says. No...Gaga might be technically more talented than Madonna....but Gaga has not come close to doing half of what Madonna did. What Madonna did was outrageous. Madonna had the insanity and crassness for her time of five meatdresses, five vessels, and 18 SXSW puke stunts. And she was pushing gay equality at a time when AIDS was considered vermin and pushing sexual freedom like no other female had done before. Erotica takes massive dumps on albums like Lemonade, Bangerz, or Born This Way in terms of the envelopes it was pushing. I'm sorry. Gaga has to have songs on the radio in 2050 if we want to start that comparison again.

I obviously love Gaga more, btw....but no....Gaga has not achieved the rolodex of influence Madonna has. (Which is why its so shocking that Gaga is like....morphing (on purpose btw) into this middle aged person so early in her career). She is in the beginning of her thirties....not checking out her 401k and overdrafting her Library Card.  I know she is not trying to appeal to tweens anymore but I always thought her music was meant to appeal to everyone...now it's like she's purposefully appealing upwards which is.....weird. And not in a good way. 

Did you read the OP? I never said anything about her winning/not winning. I had this opinion right after I saw her J/MR performance. 

you're making this ridiculous statement cus you "sensed an aura" over someone you haven't met like please

study her actions instead of going off of randon feelings, she's a pop star and will have a record out soon

[PrincessPeach 298]

The Fame lost Album of the Year,  Gaga made The Fame Monster

The Fame Monster lost Album of the Year, Gaga made Born This Way

Born This Way lost Album of the Year, Gaga made ARTPOP
ARTPOP wasn't nominated, Gaga made Joanne

Till It Happens To You lost the Oscar, Gaga is starring in A Star Is Born

 

What makes you think just because Joanne didn't win a Grammy she's gonna just "drop" her music career?

[Mister Gaga 22,898]

Omg you are literally elaborating this whole conspiracy based on a sad vibe you felt from her

#MyFansThinkEverythingIsCryptic

[ELEMENTALITY 1,298]

14 minutes ago, Dayman said:

Well now I'm 100% positive you are trolling. Because plenty of people have talked about the song "Do That" and made multiple threads on here. I even went as far and drew out what her outfit was from the day of filming, I can even post a screenshot of my ticket from the filming if you really are serious though.

 

EDIT: Here are the skecthes of the outfits. The jacket was gold satiny looking, the inside was clear red vinyl. The bra was covered in crystals. There was lots of grinding with her male dancer.

 https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C_7hcwoV0AAgw_h.jpg

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C_7hcwoVoAANPn1.jpg

Here's some lyrics too from the note I made after getting my phone unlocked following the filming.

[First Verse]
Why do you look so good in those jeans?
Why'd you come around me with an ass like that?
You're Making all my thoughts obscene,
This is not, not like me!
[???] *more here I think
Why do you do that? TO ME!
[Chorus]
Why do you do that, do that, do that, do that, do that to me?
Why do you do that, do that, do that, do that, do that to me?
Why do you do that, do that, do that, do that, do that to me?
Why do you do that x2
[Second Verse]
[???] *something here
Boy why do have to look so fine?
When I look at you I wish that I were blind.
[???] *more here
How do you do that? TO ME!
[Chorus]
How do you do that, do that, do that, do that, do that to me?
How do you do that, do that, do that, do that, do that to me?
How do you do that, do that, do that, do that, do that to me?
How do you do that x2
[Bridge] I forgot the lyrics completely
[Chorus]
How do you do that, do that, do that, do that, do that to me?
How do you do that, do that, do that, do that, do that to me?
How do you do that, do that, do that, do that, do that to me?
How do you do that x2

Song was around 160bpm as well.

That sounds ****ing terrible.

[Dayman 6,174]

1 minute ago, ELEMENTALITY said:

That sounds ****ing terrible.

It sounds great though. You're going to tell me  "P-P-P-P-POKER FACE, P-P-P-P-POKER FACE" "Ale-Alejandro Ale-Alejandro" "Oh there ain't no other way baby I was born this way." "Baby let's get high, John Wayne" Are great lyrics when written down and not sung? But go ahead, pass judgment on it before even giving it a chance to experience it yourself. Not my problem.

[ELEMENTALITY 1,298]

6 minutes ago, PrincessPeach said:

The Fame lost Album of the Year,  Gaga made The Fame Monster

The Fame Monster lost Album of the Year, Gaga made Born This Way

Born This Way lost Album of the Year, Gaga made ARTPOP
ARTPOP wasn't nominated, Gaga made Joanne

Till It Happens To You lost the Oscar, Gaga is starring in A Star Is Born

 

What makes you think just because Joanne didn't win a Grammy she's gonna just "drop" her music career?

I never said that. I never said anything about Gaga losing or winning the award. I would have the same feeling if she had won.

It was the aura/vibe/whatever you wanna call it....just seemed very kind of like "I know this is gonna be my last time here for a while y'all...it was fun".

7 minutes ago, Mister Gaga said:

Omg you are literally elaborating this whole conspiracy based on a sad vibe you felt from her

#MyFansThinkEverythingIsCryptic

That's not what cryptic even means. I wasn't reading into anything specific. It's more just a gut feeling I have. I've paid attention to her for six eras now and I know how she reacts. I know my Gaga...and she totally just acted very peculiar tonight in a way that felt like she knew she was done. Like DONE. Tired. Over it. Even her voice was off a little. 

[TheBadRomancer 1,009]

Ah, here's one of the inevitable threads for the event. Will it play out like all the exact same threads that get posted at every public appearance?

 

Probably. 

[PopBitch 1,218]

Bowie never won a musical Grammy ever until Blackstar, and he was dead. I doubt he ever would have attended, even if alive, since he was ignored all those years.  And he's revered, and he had ups and downs in his career.   Music was in his soul and he kept going, except for that gap when he had his heart attack in his mid to late fifties.

 

  Don't get all doom and gloom.

[ELEMENTALITY 1,298]

3 minutes ago, Dayman said:

It sounds great though. You're going to tell me  "P-P-P-P-POKER FACE, P-P-P-P-POKER FACE" "Ale-Alejandro Ale-Alejandro" "Oh there ain't no other way baby I was born this way." "Baby let's get high, John Wayne" Are great lyrics when written down and not sung? But go ahead, pass judgment on it before even giving it a chance to experience it yourself. Not my problem.

Yeah because Poker Face and Alejandro immediately make me ask questions and seem like interesting concepts for a pop record.

"Why do you do that to me?" is obvious, boring, and....sounds like something that's been said in every Chainsmokers song I've heard.

But tell me...was the beat good? Did it sound like radio friendly? Or was it....very "movie sountracky". ya feel?

[Rifek 51,753]

BTW, Joanne era didn't end tonight cuz we still have one more month of the Joanne World Tour 

[ELEMENTALITY 1,298]

1 minute ago, PopBitch said:

Bowie never won a musical Grammy ever until Blackstar, and he was dead. I doubt he ever would have attended, even if alive, since he was ignored all those years.  And he's revered, and he had ups and downs in his career.   Music was in his soul and he kept going, except for that gap when he had his heart attack in his mid to late fifties.

 

  Don't get all doom and gloom.

For the fifteenth time in this thread....I never said this had anything to do with her winning or losing a Grammy. I said it had to do with her performance, her vibe, and her aura. I could just read her face and it seemed like she was done for a while. I feel like if she would have won she would have said legit "goodbye" somehow in her speech tbh

[Mister Gaga 22,898]

3 minutes ago, ELEMENTALITY said:

That's not what cryptic even means. I wasn't reading into anything specific. It's more just a gut feeling I have. I've paid attention to her for six eras now and I know how she reacts. I know my Gaga...and she totally just acted very peculiar tonight in a way that felt like she knew she was done. Like DONE. Tired. Over it. Even her voice was off a little. 

Time will tell sis. Let's see how done and tired she is.

ASIB is coming, LG6, Vegas...

[ELEMENTALITY 1,298]

Just now, Rifek said:

BTW, Joanne era didn't end tonight cuz we still have one more month of the Joanne World Tour 

did you read the OP at all? The first line? HELLLO