Where would 'Monster' have charted if released as 4th single?

[monketsharona 81,608]

4 minutes ago, moonsago said:

I swear Judas ****ed her career tragectory so bad, I was thinking the other day what in the world was Troy and her team THINKING when they decided it should be a single. Like I don’t get it, of course for the controversy but how did they think it would end up well??? The Edge Of Glory would of went nr 1 if it was the second single. Then she should of done Marry the Night which I truly believe would of went top 5 and then You and I and maybe a fifth single like Hair or Scheibe though Hair would of been more fitting because it’s so relatable people would of loved it if pushed and promoted properly. 

And still she had BTW going #1, Judas #10, TEOG #3 and You and I #6

She was still very solid from TF to BTW (Applause if we go further).

Now, well, she need a Super Bowl to get a US top 10... Let's hope her next album will go back to the roots. 

[TeenIdle 126,607]

1 hour ago, monketsharona said:

And still she had BTW going #1, Judas #10, TEOG #3 and You and I #6

She was still very solid from TF to BTW (Applause if we go further).

Now, well, she need a Super Bowl to get a US top 10... Let's hope her next album will go back to the roots. 

To be fair she needs to release singles in order for them to become hits  She's released 2 real singles post-ARTPOP. DIC had enormous potential

Edit: I forgot The Cure, so that should be a sign that it wasn't treated as a single.

[ryanripley 86,575]

lol at people doubting top 10

anything she put out would have hit top 5 at that time

she was UNstoppable

[Arcanum 5,159]

She had to beat KP California Gurls which was the lead single so def not #1. Maybe #2 but I would say #3 cause at the time music was shifting from synth/dance to more electro sounds.

[Twitter 14]

#3