Grade every Gaga album

[Oriane 21,118]

The Fame : 6
The Fame Monster : 7
Born This Way : 10
ARTPOP : 9
Cheek to Cheek : 8
Joanne : 8

[display name 4,360]

TF: 8

TFM: 9

BTW: 10

AP: 7

J: 10

[VforVendetta 2,024]

The Fame: 7/10

The Fame Monster: 9/10

Born This Way: 9.5/10

ARTPOP: 8/10

Joanne: 9.5/10

For pop music standarts of course.

[XXXXX 4,775]

The Fame: 6

The Fame Monster: 10

Born This Way: 1000000

ARTPOP: 9

Cheek 2 Cheek: 8

Joanne: 10+

[TheJackMonster 1,857]

THE FAME: 6

THE FAME MONSTER: 8

BORN THIS WAY: 9

ARTPOP: 8

JOANNE: 7

[Swan Heart 7,382]

Trying to be as unbiased as possible.

The Fame - 8+ 

A fantastic debut album - Some great pop songwriting. But It definitely is the Gaga album that aged the worst for me, mainly because of songs like LoveGame and Starsruck. Despite that, songs that hold a throwback feeling to them (Brown Eyes, Again Again) still stand wonderfully charming and refreshing. Another great thing for me was the Gaga persona, which was at it's deepest and most exciting around that time. It really makes me miss the whole era. Paparazzi is a highlight.

The Fame Monster - 9+

A perfect follow up to The Fame - not one song I dislike. The only thing that stopped me from giving it a 10 was the fact that, as an EP, it was way too short to make the statement it could have made with a few more songs in it. But the songs themselves are still strong enough to stand on its own and make this EP the jewel of Gaga's discography so far. The pop masterpiece Bad Romance and wonderful power-ballad Speechless are the highlights for me on this one.

Born This Way - 7-

What bugs me here is the production of the album and that it doesn't entirely compliment all the songs. Quite a few weaker tunes as well but then there's some great songs like The Edge of Glory, Scheisse, Heavy Metal Lover and You & I which make the whole thing really really enjoyable.

ARTPOP - 7+

What hurts the most is the immense potential that this whole era had. People crushed the whole thing, and it rubbed off. When it comes to the album itself - A few weaker moments here and there but nothing to worry over. The title track is a highlight for me and one of my favorite Gaga songs ever. Sexxx Dreams, Do What U Want and Applause are also standing out.

Joanne - 8+

Such a great album. Just some great mother****ing music right here. What bugs me a bit is that Gaga doesn't always go there with the sound. We see Gaga ditching the electronic music for a bit and trying to go on the country, singer-songwriter, americana road but the pop flavor of her previous work still creeps out whete it isn't really needed. It's where Gaga fully commits to the sound that the greatness of this album truly shows - songs like Joanne, Hey Girl, Come To Mama and Sinner's Prayer sound incredibly fresh within her discography, and manage to show Gaga's true colours and potential to be an absolute chameleon and a musical powerhouse.

[GAGASEXUAL 3,790]

TF: 8

TFM: 10

BTW: 10

ARTPOP: 10

C2C: 9

JOANNE: 7

[911 16,707]

TF: 7

TFM: 8

BTW: 7

ARTPOP: 11

JOANNE: 10

[Guest]

TF: 10

TFM: 10

BTW: 10

ARTPOP: 10

JOANNE: 10

[PeachJug 3,083]

The Fame: 10/10
The Fame Monster: 10/10 
Born This Way: 10/10
ARTPOP: 10/10
Joanne: 10/10

 

[15jocart 2,305]

The Fame: 7

The Fame Monster: 8

Born This Way: 8.5

ARTPOP: 7

Joanne: 8

[Joannes Baby 29]

The Fame: 9

The Fame Monster: 10

Born This Way: 10

ARTPOP: 8,5

Joanne: 9

[StarryNight 10,106]

The Fame: 10
The Fame Monster: 9
Born This Way: 10
ARTPOP: 9
Joanne: 9

[Arizona Sky 10,913]

The Fame: 7

The Fame Monster: 10

Born This Way: 9

ARTPOP: 7

Joanne: 9

[God Control 2,181]

The Fame 8/10 (Very good album, with few fillers and skippable tracks)

The Fame Monster 10/10 (her best work. On point, perfectly executed)

Born This Way 9/10 (Great album, most tracks are amazing)

ARTPOP 7/10 (Good album, but lacks theme and proper management) 

Joanne 3/10 (for the only three songs that I actually liked)