Grade every Gaga album

[lairofhk 895]

The Fame: 8/10
The Fame Monster: 9/10 
Born This Way: 8/10
ARTPOP: 6/10
Joanne: 6/10

 

[Pink Tape 410]

the fame: 7,5

the fame monster: 8,5

born this way: 9

ARTPOP: 9

joanne: 6

[Benji 20,113]

The Fame:  7

The Fame Monster:  8

Born This Way:  9

ARTPOP:  5

Joanne:   7

[Jed Mayo 377]

1 hour ago, maxblac said:

And I'm asking what drove you to make those decisions. You don't have to answer, I'm just asking.

Because unlike the rest of this community, I'm not afraid to say that BTW wasn't the best album 

[FentyGa 14,340]

1 minute ago, Jed Mayo said:

Because unlike the rest of this community, I'm not afraid to say that BTW wasn't the best album 

 We're not afraid, we're just right  Also, nobody's saying BTW is the best album, but for sure better than TF 

[Jed Mayo 377]

Just now, maxblac said:

 We're not afraid, we're just right  Also, nobody's saying BTW is the best album, but for sure better than TF 

With its meaning, yes. Visually and sonically, no.

[FentyGa 14,340]

Just now, Jed Mayo said:

With its meaning, yes. Visually and sonically, no.

 Because This:

Looks better than this:

And this:

Sounds better than this:

 

[Esteban 2,295]

TF: 7

TFM: 8

BTW: 10

ARTPOP: 6

JOANNE: 5,5

[What About Us 1,499]

The Fame - 7.5

TFM - 9

BTW - 8.5

ARTPOP - 8

Joanne - 9.5

[ATRL 14]

The Fame - 8

The Fame Monster - 9

Born This Way - 10

ARTPOP - 8

Joanne - 5

[RocketNumberNine 610]

Born This Way : 10
The Fame Monster : 9
The Fame : 8 
Joanne ; 8 
ARTPOP ; 6

[ToGa 42]

TF: 7

TFM: 9

BTW: 10

AP: 7

Joanne: 8

[Brian Ryan 1,468]

The Fame C+
The Fame Monster B+
Born This Way A+
ARTPOP A-
Joanne A-

[buttsicle 6,484]

The Fame: 8

The Fame Monster: 9.5

Born This Way: 10

ARTPOP: 11 

Joanne: 9

 

[Jed Mayo 377]

4 hours ago, maxblac said:

 Because This:

Looks better than this:

And this:

Sounds better than this:

 

Wow I mean if I were to compare the two I'd pick the best from both tbh.. Money Honey is one of the weakest from The Fame, and Marry The Night is one of the strongest from BTW. Once you find a proper comparison, feel free to quote me again. Once again though, the aesthetics from both will come down to personal taste, which is why my ratings will be different from yours. But I think we established this already if I'm correct.