Gaga Songs: Hits? YES or NO

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 25,819]

3 minutes ago, Fernster7 said:

Lmao no it did not sold 5M WW. I edited my post because I made a mistake. TEOG outsold Judas total sales with just its sales outside the US. 

It did. You invented 6M right before though. 

You're repeating me about the Judas/TEOG sales since a while as you're trying to prove me wrong without knowing what you're talking about. That's kind of ennoying.

[Fernster7 7,923]

14 minutes ago, kevindjibouti said:

It did. You invented 6M right before though. 

You're repeating me about the Judas/TEOG sales since a while as you're trying to prove me wrong without knowing what you're talking about. That's kind of ennoying.

Just look it up, you are the one that does not know what you're talking about. And if you're still in denial there's a list with certification on Wikipedia for both songs.

And I know they are probably inflated sales but it applies to both songs. Let's say TEOG sold only 4.5M where 3M comes from the US. It still sold the same as Judas did outside of the US.

http://classic.atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=175622

[bloody g 31,746]

I stopped reading at Bad Kids: Yes 

[Gagz 2,579]

Just Dance : YES

LoveGame : YES

Paparazzi : YES

Poker Face : YES

Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) : NO

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich : YES

The Fame : YES

Money Honey : YES

Starstruck : YES

Boys Boys Boys : YES

Again Again : NO

Paper Gangsta : NO

Brown Eyes : NO

I Like It Rough : NO

Summerboy : NO

Disco Heaven : NO

Vanity : NO

Retro Dance Freak : NO

Bad Romance : YES

Alejandro : YES

Monster : YES

Speechless : YES

Dance In The Dark : YES

Telephone : YES

So Happy I Could Die : NO

Teeth : NO

Marry The Night : NO

Born This Way : YES

Government Hooker : YES

Judas : YES

Americano : YES

Hair : YES

Scheiße : NO

Bloody Mary : NO

Black Jesus † Amen Fashion : NO

Bad Kids : YES

Fashion Of His Love : NO

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) : NO

Heavy Metal Lover : YES

Electric Chapel : NO

The Queen : NO

Yoü And I : YES

The Edge of Glory : YES

Aura : NO

Venus : YES

G.U.Y. : YES

Sexxx Dreams : YES

Jewels N' Drugs : YES

MANiCURE : YES

Do What U Want : YES

ARTPOP : NO

Swine : NO

Donatella : NO

Fashion! : NO

Mary Jane Holland : NO

Dope : NO

Gypsy : YES

Applause : YES

Diamond Heart : YES

A-YO : YES

Joanne : NO

John Wayne : NO

Dancin' In Circles : YES

Perfect Illusion : YES

Million Reasons : YES

Sinner's Prayer : NO

Come To Mama : NO

Hey Girl : NO

Angel Down : NO

Grigio Girls : NO

Just Another Day : NO

 

[RonnieGagz 4,300]

TF: Starstruck and Summerboy, maybe Boys Boys Boys

TFM: Monster and DITD, SHICD maybe

BTW: HML, Bloody Mary, Hair and Scheiße

AP: Sexxx Dreams, Gypsy, Aura, MANiCURE and Venus, MJH as promo and Fashion! if it was the demo

Joanne: DIC, JW, Joanne and DH, A-yo just maybe because I can't see it being a hit out of the USA and Angel Down maybe

 

[Vergil 2,296]

MANiCURE: no G.U.Y.: no Gypsy: never Diamond Heart: YAS

Spoiler

Truth hurts 

 

[merlot 5,772]

2 hours ago, kevindjibouti said:

 

Perfect Illusion : NO

Grigio Girls : YES

Just Another Day : YES

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

one word: MESS 

[Red Velvet 10,988]

6 hours ago, kevindjibouti said:

Just Dance : YES

LoveGame : YES

Paparazzi : YES

Poker Face : YES

Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) : YES

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich : YES

The Fame : YES

Money Honey : YES

Starstruck : YES

Boys Boys Boys : YES

Again Again : NO

Paper Gangsta : NO

Brown Eyes : NO

I Like It Rough : YES

Summerboy : YES

Disco Heaven : NO

Vanity : NO

Retro Dance Freak : NO

Bad Romance : YES

Alejandro : YES

Monster : YES

Speechless : YES

Dance In The Dark : YES

Telephone : YES

So Happy I Could Die : NO

Teeth : NO

Marry The Night :YES

Born This Way : YES

Government Hooker : YES

Judas : YES

Americano : YES

Hair : YES

Scheiße : YES

Bloody Mary : YES

Black Jesus † Amen Fashion : NO

Bad Kids : NO

Fashion Of His Love : NO

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) : NO

Heavy Metal Lover : YES

Electric Chapel : NO

The Queen : NO

Yoü And I : YES

The Edge of Glory : YES

Aura : YES

Venus : YES

G.U.Y. : YES

Sexxx Dreams : YES

Jewels N' Drugs : NO

MANiCURE : YES

Do What U Want : YES

ARTPOP : YES (then why is it included on GUY MV?)

Swine : NO

Donatella : NO

Fashion! : NO

Mary Jane Holland : YES

Dope : YES

Gypsy : YES

Applause : YES

Diamond Heart : YES

A-YO : YES

Joanne : YES

John Wayne : YES

Dancin' In Circles : YES

Perfect Illusion : YES

Million Reasons : YES

Sinner's Prayer : Yes

Come To Mama : YES

Hey Girl : YES

Angel Down : NO

Grigio Girls : YES

Just Another Day : YES

 

 

Fixed.

[holy scheisse 22,286]

4 hours ago, kevindjibouti said:

Judas is a hit though. Monster is too loud for radio I think

Not uh Judas flopped 

[lilmunzter 54]

All of them YES because there's never a moment that Gaga is dull while expressing herself inside the music she gives us 👌🔊 

[Red Velvet 10,988]

5 hours ago, kevindjibouti said:

It sold more because it was a hit in the US. But everybody knows and remembers Judas whereas no one knows TEOG outside of the US 

Girls from Philippines,Korea,Taiwan and Australia (in short,my friends) says hi.

[TheJackMonster 1,857]

You wouldn't put yes on MR if it wasn't a single 

[huttont 5,348]

Just Dance : YES

LoveGame : YES

Paparazzi : YES

Poker Face : YES

Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) : YES

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich : NO

The Fame : YES

Money Honey : NO

Starstruck : YES

Boys Boys Boys : NO

Again Again : NO

Paper Gangsta : NO

Brown Eyes : NO

I Like It Rough : NO

Summerboy : YES

Disco Heaven : NO

Vanity : NO

Retro Dance Freak : NO

Bad Romance : YES

Alejandro : YES

Monster : YES

Speechless : YES

Dance In The Dark : YES

Telephone : YES

So Happy I Could Die : NO

Teeth : NO

Marry The Night : YES

Born This Way : YES

Government Hooker : NO

Judas : YES

Americano : NO

Hair : YES

Scheiße : YES

Bloody Mary : NO --> unless it had an October Halloween themed release with a really creepy MV

Black Jesus † Amen Fashion : NO

Bad Kids : YES

Fashion Of His Love : YES

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) : NO

Heavy Metal Lover : NO

Electric Chapel : NO

The Queen : NO

Yoü And I : YES

The Edge of Glory : YES

Aura : YES

Venus : YES

G.U.Y. : YES

Sexxx Dreams : YES

Jewels N' Drugs : NO

MANiCURE : YES

Do What U Want : YES

ARTPOP : NO

Swine : NO

Donatella : NO

Fashion! : NO

Mary Jane Holland : YES

Dope : YES

Gypsy : YES

Applause : YES

Diamond Heart : YES

A-YO : YES

Joanne : YES

John Wayne : YES

Dancin' In Circles : YES

Perfect Illusion : YES

Million Reasons : YES

Sinner's Prayer : NO

Come To Mama : YES

Hey Girl : NO

Angel Down : NO

Grigio Girls : YES

Just Another Day : NO

[The Fame Joanne 5,985]

14 hours ago, kevindjibouti said:

It sold more because it was a hit in the US. But everybody knows and remembers Judas whereas no one knows TEOG outside of the US 

What? 

TEOG was a top 5 hit in many parts of the world, whereas Judas didn't even enter the top 10s of some big music markets 

[TEANUS 15,286]

All the singles that underperformed but Judas could've been bigger with better promo. Do What U Want, G.U.Y., and Perfect Illusion all had great potential but we know what happened in each situation.

The Fame

1. Just Dance - April 2008

2. Poker Face - September 2008

3. Starstruck - March 2009 (Easily would've been another #1 riding off the succes of JD and PF, plus it's almost platinum with no promo)

4. LoveGame - June 2009

5. Paparazzi - August 2009

The Fame Monster

1. Bad Romance - November 2009

2. Telephone - February 2010

3. Alejandro - May 2010

4. Monster - August 2010

Born This Way

1. Born This Way - Feburary 2011

2. Hair - May 2011

3. You and I (US)/ Marry The Night (WW) - August 2011

4. The Edge of Glory - November 2011

5. Scheibe - February 2012

ARTPOP 

1. Applause - August 2013

2. Gypsy - November 2013

3. Do What U Want - February 2014

4. G.U.Y. - May 2014

5. MANiCURE - August 2014

Joanne

1. Perfect Illusion - August 2016

2. Million Reasons - November 2016

3. John Wayne - April 2017

4. Dancin In Circles - July 2017

5. Joanne - October 2017