Gaga likes tweet about MR video hate

[Evan Peters 10,738]

What's it like getting worked up over a music video? I have a life, so I don't have experience with the whole "im over a pop star because they made something I don't like" mentality 

[SilkSpectre0 547]

7 hours ago, Lona Delery said:

That's a stupid and bad comparison. It would work if we weren't stanning Gaga, but it does not make sense at all like this.
If you want to compare, then Gaga is our favorite TV shows but the latest season has parts that suck and we express our disappointment about it.

And, y'know, there are people who do not jump ship just because the last few months were subpar to the rest of Gaga's career, but that's maybe a hard concept to grasp.

I don't think people should jump ship I just think if you enjoyed past eras better why not just keep enjoying those. When you repeatedly speak negativity about the eras you dislike it seems like a waste of your time. Why spend so much time talking about what you dislike? People on here call themselves stans when they don't stan. They did in a past era and they have an idea of gaga in their head they Stan for but they seem pretty Anti what she is doing right now. And they're mad at gaga for not doing what they've been imagining

[SpookyKid 15,153]

1 hour ago, SEANGT said:

can everyone stop acting like they have a deep true loving connection with a person they've never met? It's cringey. You can admire her and respect her but sometimes the sentiment goes too far. 

When that person's music is the only thing you had at some point in your life you develop feelings

I love this woman with all my heart, and she doesn't deserve the hate she gets

criticism ≠ hating on her work without bringing some constructive criticism like a lot of members do

[Lona Delery 7,214]

4 minutes ago, SilkSpectre0 said:

I don't think people should jump ship I just think if you enjoyed past eras better why not just keep enjoying those. When you repeatedly speak negativity about the eras you dislike it seems like a waste of your time. Why spend so much time talking about what you dislike? People on here call themselves stans when they don't stan. They did in a past era and they have an idea of gaga in their head they Stan for but they seem pretty Anti what she is doing right now. And they're mad at gaga for not doing what they've been imagining

I don't get your point. So you can only be a stan if you lick Gaga's ass and eat everything? If she doesn't live up to our expectations, we are not stans?

While I agree that it's a waste of time to constantly open threads with hate - isn't it also a waste of time for the people who enjoy the era (or others who pretend to like it) to answer to those people or also open a thread for any negative one that pops up?

My problem, and I think that is also the one with a lot of people, is that Gaga took 3 years to release another album, an album which she began working on this year. In 2016.
If it was 2014 or early 2015 when Gaga released Joanne I'd be totally fine with it.

But that she took 3 years only to rush something few months prior the release date leaves it with a sour taste in my mouth. And now she is seemingly also rushing the videos. MR video is basically Apple commercial outtakes and PI music video outtakes, with some new shot footage. That's just pretty disappointing for someone who had such a good videography, and I'm not only talking about BR or Telephone. You & I was a great video, so was MTN or Poker Face, and eve TEOG is better than MR. 

[Gardevoir 9,822]

Girl explained what she meant by "true fans". You are allowed to not like everything she's ever done of course but have some fvcking respect to her as an artist and human being. Instead, some of you are acting like bunch of crybabies, calling her over, and simply HATING everything of hers that you don't like. There is a thing that is called constructive criticism, but I guess some of you just know nothing about it. Grow up.

[Nono 3,576]

19 hours ago, Karandr said:

I find this kind of stuff really cloying and insincere. These people all use the same buzzwords that Gaga uses, they write in her voice and it's this never-ending echo chamber. It's a very transparent attempt to curry favour with a celebrity by validating every last thing she does. 

Exactly the same thing I was thinking

same buzzwords written in her own voice

only to lick her ass, and to be self called "true fan"

MESS 

[SpookyKid 15,153]

24 minutes ago, Lona Delery said:

My problem, and I think that is also the one with a lot of people, is that Gaga took 3 years to release another album, an album which she began working on this year. In 2016.
If it was 2014 or early 2015 when Gaga released Joanne I'd be totally fine with it.

 

She hasn't stop working since 2008. god forbid how does she dare take a year

And she didn't even take a year, she promoted c2c, did 2 seasons of AHS, won 1 grammy, performed at the oscars

 

[E24187 615]

It seems the letter is saying you're free to dislike, it's the level of respect you give that makes the difference. The meltdowns some of you were having were outright disrespectful. That's when your dislike of the video crossed the line.

I have no compulsion to ever watch the MR video again because I know she can do better. I pretty much stopped there. She'll either learn when views stall at 10 million or wallow further into denial. I never called her or her friends out of their names. 

At some point, the label will jump in which is probably for the best. She's either doesn't have the eye for catching visuals or doesn't care. Now you see why some artists don't get creative freedom. It's a business at the end of the day. If she TRULY wanted to be indieGa, we wouldn't even know Joanne existed except for YouTube uploads. 

[mister max 18,480]

20 hours ago, dannydevito said:

dont come with that true fan nonsense, the person who wrote this clearly said being a true fan doesnt mean you have to like everything, because "everyone has opinions". You complainin like he said true fans are the ones who love the MR video when he clearly didnt

stop creating drama where the isnt any

Omg this

The word twisting in this thread is INTENS

[Americano 31,061]

Nothing about this hints that she cares about video hate-- It's more about her changing as an artist and the challenges that poses. She's talked about it before 

[Furrrealzjuan 137]

😢 insert Marina and the Diamonds "I am not a robot" lyrics here: "

You've been acting awful tough lately
Smoking a lot of cigarettes lately
But inside, you're just a little baby
It's okay to say you've got a weak spot
You don't always have to be on top
Better to be hated 
Than lived loved loved for what your not 

You're vulnerable, you're vulnerable
You are not a robot
You're lovable, so lovable
But you're just troubled

Guess what? I'm not a robot, a robot
Guess what? I'm not a robot, a robot" 🤖

[Americano 31,061]

Also there's no drama here so cut it with the "when will she post again!!" nonsense. She probably was just like "This is nice. They understand my changes as a person" -Likes

[Karandr 150]

9 hours ago, SilkSpectre0 said:

I guess it makes very little sense to people why you would choose to wallow in negativity. Do you go online and write about every to show you don't like? Every song and  every film? Would you join a book club for a book you didn't like so you could vocalise how you didn't like it? Nah I'd guess you wouldn't waste any more of your life on it. 

 You're a happier person if you define yourself by what you LOVE and being prostuff not just antistuff. The  amount of people on here who define themselves by what they're not not enjoying is crazy. If you're fans of gagas 'potential' rather than what she's doing right now why not go enjoy something else for a while? Gaga is doing what she wants and when that combined with what you want again come spread some love for it. You have too much time on your hands if you have time to come to a forum to complain. 

Your pointed tone and personal attack were quite uncalled for. 

I participate in this forum, and have for years, because I'm a fan of Gaga's work and enjoy the opportunity to discuss it with other fans. That, to me, includes critically analysing her work - the good and the bad. I'm not dragging her, I'm not spreading hate/negativity/whatever other trite two-word combinations you can conjure up.

If this whole pathetic argument is about who Gaga's true fans are, I'd say they're the ones who respect her enough as an artist and adult to be frank and honest in their assessment of her work. I thought the Perfect Illusion video was great - simple in the right way, in that there was still enough creative flair and intrigue to make it have rewatch value. If you're trying to paint me as a one-note antifan, you'll have to try a bit harder, dear.

I don't need your patronising advice on what would make me a happier person, and the insinuation that I'm wasting my life is a bit rich considering we're both on this cult site. 

[monketsharona 80,327]

well I don't like the video and some things she does during Joanne era, so I'm a fake fan I guess 

[Furrrealzjuan 137]

Ugh, just read through everyone's post. 

I can't with the "kiss her ass" vs "lick her ass"