Snippets Til It Happens To You performance at Billboard Women In Music

[NewYorkCity 10,536]

7 hours ago, Say it Right said:

Most of you critics of vocals don't even know what notes she's hitting or how hard it is to keep a belting note sustained and go up without failing through melisma.

But do you, keep nip ticking at all of her vocals performances while stanning also for mediocre 'singers'.

This so much.

[Swando 300]

I love how when someone like Sia or Rihanna's voice cracks (which they do ALL, the freaking time). It get's praised to heaven. But when it happens to Gaga, it is seen as bad xd

I get that it has something to do with how your voice is.

 TIHTY is very emotional for Gaga, not to mention. Very hard to sing.

And how many times has she performed it live now? Twice? 

[teenagechrist 2,853]

She just ****ed up one note and it doesn't even sound bad. It actually sounds emotional, and I love that.

[MelbHawker 6,583]

I do love how all of a sudden everyone 'defending' the voice crack is an actual expert at being a vocalist, like slay me with your knowledge gurls

 

[Didymus 34,379]

Just now, MelbHawker said:

I do love how all of a sudden everyone 'defending' the voice crack is an actual expert at being a vocalist, like slay me with your knowledge gurls

Cackling. True.

I defended it (kinda, I just said it didn't matter because she hit the highest note well) without doing that, so I don't consider myself addressed, correct me if I'm wrong

[MelbHawker 6,583]

41 minutes ago, Didymus said:

Cackling. True.

I defended it (kinda, I just said it didn't matter because she hit the highest note well) without doing that, so I don't consider myself addressed, correct me if I'm wrong

You were one of the gurls who slayed me with ha brains. I read your post & I was like



 

[atemybrain 2,077]

9 hours ago, AmericanHSlave said:

how is her every performance her best?

I meant to put one of her best.

[Head Empty 25,122]

Gaga is an amazing vocalist but if any of you are looking for "flawless" vocals I'm afraid you're at the wrong adress . I've loved Gaga's singing from the start but she's also notorious for being rough around the edges - sometimes more visibly than others. I don't think anyone can deny this, so I'm kinda baffled why it's suddenly such a big deal .

[Swan Heart 7,382]

Damn, it's just one note, guys, calm down... 

[Didymus 34,379]

11 minutes ago, Growlithe said:

Gaga is an amazing vocalist but if any of you are looking for "flawless" vocals I'm afraid you're at the wrong adress . I've loved Gaga's singing from the start but she's also notorious for being rough around the edges - sometimes more visibly than others. I don't think anyone can deny this, so I'm kinda baffled why it's suddenly such a big deal .

- because many people can't stand TIHTY('s vocals) to begin with
- because this was her night so she needed to outshine everyone else in every way
- because some fans seem to believe that "the GP" will analyze her vocals as much as we do here and conclude that she's a horrible artist (particularly hilarious), endangering her opportunity to make a bigger comeback than Adele in 2016

[MelbHawker 6,583]

1 hour ago, Didymus said:

endangering her opportunity to make a bigger comeback than Adele in 2016

Didy pls gurl, no-one's going to make a bigger comeback than Adele.

[Didymus 34,379]

1 minute ago, MelbHawker said:

Didy pls gurl, no-one's going to make a bigger comeback than Adele.

Burning my stan card.

[RockySayTalk 504]

I think she did mess up the note but what's more impressive is that she caught it and went up higher 

But yeah, will wait to see how it is in HD

[andy232000 11,430]

5 hours ago, Swando said:

I love how when someone like Sia or Rihanna's voice cracks (which they do ALL, the freaking time). It get's praised to heaven. But when it happens to Gaga, it is seen as bad xd

I get that it has something to do with how your voice is.

 TIHTY is very emotional for Gaga, not to mention. Very hard to sing.

And how many times has she performed it live now? Twice? 

they crack it on purpose and they do it right. gaga was just a slip. and its ok. 

[Swando 300]

2 hours ago, andy232000 said:

they crack it on purpose and they do it right. gaga was just a slip. and its ok. 

Wait...how do you know that their voices crack on purpose? And when does someone know it's the right way or wrong way? 

Is it when you do it all the time? Is that when it's the "right" way? 

 

I agree it didn't Sound good. But neither does it Sound good when Sia or Rihanna's voices does it. Yet they get praised for it.