Jessie J EXPOSED

[Chic 20,830]

aka you don't understand soul. it's an amazing piece of music. it's not britney-like so you dislike it

What the absolute ****? There's a difference between soul and oversinging. I'm a fan of artists like Haley Reinhart, Amy Winehouse, etc. who do soul music right. This is not soulful, it is way overdone. Some parts are okay, but it is practically unlistenable. Don't opt for ad hominem attacks when you can't dispute your opinion correctly, it's pathetic. I prefer talking to people who can rationally discuss topics. Who even said I like Britney-esque music? My top five favorite artists are completely different from Britney.

[Kanye West 1,676]

What the absolute ****? There's a difference between soul and oversinging. I'm a fan of artists like Haley Reinhart, Amy Winehouse, etc. who do soul music right. This is not soulful, it is way overdone. Some parts are okay, but it is practically unlistenable. Don't opt for ad hominem attacks when you can't dispute your opinion correctly, it's pathetic. I prefer talking to people who can rationally discuss topics. Who even said I like Britney-esque music? My top five favorite artists are completely different from Britney.

This type of singing is an ART. Artists like aretha franklin have done similar. it does not deserve to be attacked. it is wonderful. you dislike it, that's fine. don't insult it.

[Chic 20,830]

This type of singing is an ART. Artists like aretha franklin have done similar. it does not deserve to be attacked. it is wonderful. you dislike it, that's fine. don't insult it.

I didn't insult it, I critiqued it with specific reasons to back up my opinion. The difference between Jessie J on this song and Aretha Franklin is that Jessie is overdoing it way too consistently. It would be more respectably soulful if the whole song wasn't just her belting it out. By all means, call it technically impressive that she manages to do this, but it's really not that soul. It is not "above" critique. Artists like Amy do it right.

The fact you think the song is above "insulting" when you just condescendingly implied I have an inferior music taste is incredible.

[Kanye West 1,676]

I didn't insult it, I critiqued it with specific reasons to back up my opinion. The difference between Jessie J on this song and Aretha Franklin is that Jessie is overdoing it way too consistently. It would be more respectably soulful if the whole song wasn't just her belting it out. By all means, call it technically impressive that she manages to do this, but it's really not that soul. It is not "above" critique. Artists like Amy do it right.

The fact you think the song is above "insulting" when you just condescendingly implied I have an inferior music taste is incredible.

I never said you have inferior music taste. I said that you like different types of music. people that like britney don't like soul 9/10 of the time.

and no. Songs that are entirely belting it out are not automatically bad. listen to the real SNL performance. it sounds amazing with all the instruments. it is an art. it's soul. it's jazz. you don't like heavy belting songs, that's fine, but it doesn't deserve to be insulted.

[KyliesChild 16,907]

I never said you have inferior music taste. I said that you like different types of music. people that like britney don't like soul 9/10 of the time.

and no. Songs that are entirely belting it out are not automatically bad. listen to the real SNL performance. it sounds amazing with all the instruments. it is an art. it's soul. it's jazz. you don't like heavy belting songs, that's fine, but it doesn't deserve to be insulted.

opinion

[uh-pin-yuh n] 
Spell Syllables

Synonyms 
Examples 
Word Origin 

noun
1.
a belief or judgment that rests on groundsinsufficient to produce complete certainty.
2.
a personal view, attitude, or appraisal.
3.
the formal expression of a professionaljudgment:
to ask for a second medical opinion.
4.
Law. the formal statement by a judge orcourt of the reasoning and the principles oflaw used in reaching a decision of a case.
5.
a judgment or estimate of a person or thingwith respect to character, merit, etc.:
to forfeit someone's good opinion.
6.
a favorable estimate; esteem:
I haven't much of an opinion of him.

This is over singing and this is not art, nor soul. Listen to soul music and you would know how tragic that performance is.

[Kanye West 1,676]

This is over singing and this is not art, nor soul. Listen to soul music and you would know how tragic that performance is.

i know how tragic your opinion is.

[Chic 20,830]

I never said you have inferior music taste. I said that you like different types of music. people that like britney don't like soul 9/10 of the time.

and no. Songs that are entirely belting it out are not automatically bad. listen to the real SNL performance. it sounds amazing with all the instruments. it is an art. it's soul. it's jazz. you don't like heavy belting songs, that's fine, but it doesn't deserve to be insulted.

You implied a lot of things with the comment you made.

For the hundredth time, I did not insult it. At most, I said it was bad technique, but that has a basis and I provided a reason for it. We obviously have very different opinions on what "soul" is, but I'll just say that simply because Jessie J is capable of having a soulful voice does not mean this "belting out" is considered soul. I'm not hearing the conveyance of any thought or emotion in her singing whatsoever, therefore I don't consider it soul. "I Will Always Love You" by Whitney is a beautiful song filled with soul, and that is art. "Hurt" by Christina Aguilera is soulful, and she's the original queen of oversinging. Jessie J is certainly capable of being soulful, but she doesn't hit the mark on this song. This simply isn't soul, in my opinion.

[KyliesChild 16,907]

i know how tragic your opinion is.

Well, seeing your other recent posts in this thread I find my tragic taste to be tragic, as well by your standards.  G'day.

[Kanye West 1,676]

You implied a lot of things with the comment you made.

For the hundredth time, I did not insult it. At most, I said it was bad technique, but that has a basis and I provided a reason for it. We obviously have very different opinion on what "soul" is, but I'll just say that simply because Jessie J is capable of having a soulful voice does not mean this "belting out" is considered soul. I'm not hearing the conveyance of any thought or emotion in her singing whatsoever, therefore I don't consider it soul. "I Will Always Love You" by Whitney is a beautiful song filled with soul, and that is art. "Hurt" by Christina Aguilera is soulful, and she's the original queen of oversinging. Jessie J is certainly capable of being soulful, but she doesn't hit the mark on this song. This simply isn't soul, in my opinion.

how is it bad technique? she sang it perfectly with no struggle or straining. jessie j's technique was near perfect.

The kind of soul in this song is about confidence. the song itself is about making a strong comeback with no compromises which is why it's such a belter. it's not pointless belting. the song has meaning. it's definitely soul, but not the soft type of soul.

[Red 94,544]

I am curious to know the opinion on Cheek to Cheek from the people criticising her for over-singing 

[Kanye West 1,676]

I am curious to know the opinion on Cheek to Cheek from the people criticising her for over-singing 

Cheek to Cheek is a soft type of jazz. There is belting but there's no high energy big numbers like Mamma Knows Best.