You guys LOVED ARTPOP before it "flopped" [Receipts]

[SlaeUrAnus 15,958]

I have always disliked some of the tunes on ARTPOP.

I was here for iTunes version of MANiCURE and IWBWY, but she changed those.

Donatella,  Fashion! And JnD make my ears bleed.

I can only listen to Gypsy, DWUW, Mary Jane Holland and G.U.Y.

The rest are...Meh. I stick to my word.

[Alfonso 1,547]

I will always love ARTPOP. Too bad for those who don't.

 

[lodylody 1,746]

What a silly thread. None of this critiques the actual album as a whole. Get the discussion thread when it leaked. That'd be a receipt. This is irrelevant.

[HighwayGuy 1,498]

I loved ARTPOP when it came out too because it was fresh and catchy 

But I hardly listen to it anymore, it just doesn't have much longevity imo 

[Ladey Gagz 2,512]

Not you generalizing all of GGD with some posts of a different website :rip:

[HANZ 4,380]

it's because the SXwinfest versions of the songs were the slayage meanwhile the studio versions were like 3 times worse, I can't believe what she did to MANiCURE, I wanna be with you, swine and aura and maybe ARTPOP and s-xx dreams, well everything was ruined in the studio version, lol

[gagaisitalian 3,573]

I loved ARTPOP before and after we knew sales. One of my fave pieces of Gaga's work.

[elijahfan 26,111]

Fans always overreact when new stuff gets released, and then they get an actual opinion with the benefit of hindsight. It has always been that way.

The "flop" comments have definitely stained everyone's perspective of the era. But you know, there are a lot of records that are considered bad by the press that I love very much. When's the music is good to you, you just forget the rest, idk. There are also a lot of critically praised records that leave me unimpressed.

[Anomaly 159]

A lot of that sounds like it was during the Swinefest or before the album was actually released. ARTPOP is a good album, though I still think that some songs could be produced a bit better and that there could have been some better choices made. But I still jam out to a good portion of the songs on the album. I dunno why it's cool to bash the album now.

[Psychedelic 1,098]

I love the music in ARTPOP, I just don't like how messy everything went!

[nikola 4,342]

this only show how much some peopel on here folow charts and saels.....

[blacklistedd 599]

It was split honestly. There were fans that were kind of already preconditioning themselves to hate it or think it was lacking. And amidst swinefest and hearing the album and stuff they were kind of like acting disappointed or supposedly "cancelling" their pre-orders. It was annoying.

[blacklistedd 599]

A lot of that sounds like it was during the Swinefest or before the album was actually released. ARTPOP is a good album, though I still think that some songs could be produced a bit better and that there could have been some better choices made. But I still jam out to a good portion of the songs on the album. I dunno why it's cool to bash the album now.

​I don't think its that its produced poorly or anything, but there were little production choices made in the end that I didn't necessarily agree with. Like with ARTPOP (the song) they made the hee-hees barely audible when I thought that was one of the highlights of the track live. The vocals on the Aura demo sounded better than the album version imo. Little stuff like that.

[jasperhallo 219]

Its her best album imo

[ryhanna 3,507]

I think opinions from when we first heard new music is kind of irrelevant to how we feel about it now. When we first hear things we are often blinded by the "new" factor. It's amazing because it's new and we're excited.