Billboard writers rank Madonna's albums, MDNA ranks last

[destructivelove 523]

American life should be higher.  Also confessions should def be number 1 or 2 imo

[destructivelove 523]

""Future Lovers," "Jump" and "Let It Will Be" keep the album sounding fresh and immediate nearly 10 years after its release."

I love how they listed 3 of my least favorite tracks on the album hahah

Let it will be sounds fresh every single time I play it.  Also "sorry"!

[blacklistedd 599]

Let it will be sounds fresh every single time I play it.

I think its boring.

Forbidden Love is definitely within my top 3 madonna songs.

[destructivelove 523]

I can't at some of ya'll saying you've never listened to American life.  Nothing fails is like one of her best songs of the 2000's 

[Feline 567]

American Life should be top3, messy list.

[Slade 2,591]

The first two are spot on I would swap Confessions and Madonna and put True Blue at #5 and you've got the perfect Top 5!

[ByeBye49 161]

American Life ranked so low. Their opinion is irrelevant

​^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

[craig 680]

Billboard's list captures conventional opinion pretty well. I bet it's mostly young gays born after 1990 who'd rate AL, HC, and MDNA high on her discography. The sleep inducing Bedtime Stories should be lower too.

[craig 680]

​I feel that way about True Blue actually. I think its 90% cheap 80s pop b/s that hasn't stood the test of time. 

​Anyone dissing Madonna's first album, LAV, or TB need to realize - Madonna's claim to be Queen of Pop is based 80% on the success of that "cheap", "dated", or "cheesy" 80's dance-pop (plus great videos, self-promotion, and maybe half a dozen hits 1998-2008).

[Better Day 5,766]

My List -

Rebel Heart

Erotica

Ray Of Light

True Blue

Confessions

Bedtime Stories

Like A Prayer

Madonna

MDNA

Celebration

Like A Virgin

Hard Candy

American Life (Autotuned mess)

Music (Absolute mess of an album)

 

[Versace 7,410]

1-Like A Prayer

2-True Blue

3-Like A Virgin

4-Confessions On The Dance floor

5-Ray Of Light

6-Madonna

7-Rebel Heart

8-Erotica

9-Music

10-MDNA

11-Bedtime Stories

12-Hard Candy

13-American Life

 

No one lecture me for my opinion , if its a wrong opinion then screw it, its not like I live to please your righteous mind.

[JEANBO 364]

American Life ranked so low. Their opinion is irrelevant

​

[blacklistedd 599]

​Anyone dissing Madonna's first album, LAV, or TB need to realize - Madonna's claim to be Queen of Pop is based 80% on the success of that "cheap", "dated", or "cheesy" 80's dance-pop (plus great videos, self-promotion, and maybe half a dozen hits 1998-2008).

​I don't diss Madonna or Like a Virgin, I like both of those albums. I just think True Blue sucks and its one of her albums that is always regarded as her best and I disagree. No realizations needed here.

My list (best to worst):

1. Ray of Light

2. Confessions On a Dance Floor

3. Like A Prayer

4. Like A Virgin

5. Madonna

6. Erotica

7. Music

8. Bedtime Stories

9. True Blue

10. Rebel Heart

11. Hard Candy

12. American Life

13. MDNA

[mr.peter 3,515]

 

Music (Absolute mess of an album)

 

​

[Guest]

American Life remains one of her best albums.