Leaderboard

They are equally great, and those who think otherwise are... mistakes

The ghost & the garden have nothing on this, imo

Thank god, I was about to buy more variants.

Phew I was so worried...

"Global superstar" it could only mean Taylor

idk she was really in her own lane with BTW it really didnt sound like anything else in pop music. tfm and btw era all eyes were on her and edm pop was becoming the trend as gaga was like dropping 5 minute long 80s pop rock tracks lol, if anything ARTPOP needed to come out in 2012

Is CSTH considered one of the worst songs on the album?? It's one of the best songs, and I think the general consensus is that it's good. Its inclusion (+ KFL and TDD) is much needed for the album imo. I think all three songs help balance out the album's sounds even more.

https://x.com/gagadaily/status/1985146753155563906?s=46 I love her ranking of her Halloween costumes, cause I was thinking about it just yesterday and my top 2 is the exact same as hers.

I mean I guess I’m the minority because I love them both.

Congrats, no one is doing it like this song in 2025, already a hit and a classic on the same level as songs like "I Will Always Love You" and "My Heart Will Go On"

She only sees her fans as a bunch of f words I guess, if the only reason she'd think people don't like Trump is because he's homophobic Also has she ever advocated for gay rights? I remember her blocking her fans who asked her to pay hommage to the LGBT+ peopled killed in the Orlando gay club shooting

I hope she goes back to her Christian roots, it's a trendy thing to do right now.

*threatens

She’s tired? Please… she has no idea what tired looks like until she’s scrolled through another dozen “Was X a mistake?” threads on GGD.

omg please I need more of the concert I'm like 2-3 weeks after and I still can't get enough of it, the impact it did to my life right now is huge. I'm to the point that I might join the rest of the team in Miami this march I also won $150 coupon to use on ticket master from burger king so like I've been saving it for Gaga

I thought the chicken was lovely

so anyways what are you guys having for dinner?

ngl this image is lowkey iconic

A silly video/tiktok collab with Mariah herself would be everything... something like Mariah getting ready but Gaga steps in and says "Not yet". It would be fun and make the Queen of Halloween title ""official"" .

Pretty sure most people j*rk off even if silently in the other room from family ... so it really does fit.

i guess the mistakes continue

There’s more to a song than just its sound. Lyrics, melody, production elements etc. Just because they have the same sound doesn’t mean they have to be liked equally.

I’ve briefly seen and/or mentioned this a couple times in other threads, but I’m actually quite interested. If Perfect Celebrity is held in such high regard (plenty of people wish the whole album sounded like this) Then why is Can’t Stop The High so generally regarded as one of the worst songs on the album? I just think they have a very similar sound and so I find it interesting how they are received so differently.

"Oh hi baby" she wrote on the Instagram post

Firstly, when people talk about Latin America, they usually refer to Mexico, Brazil, Argentina, Chile, and Colombia. Central America is rarely mentioned. All of these countries have stadiums and sufficient infrastructure to host a Lady Gaga concert. Mexico held two concerts at the beginning of the year, and Brazil held one open to 2 million people, something that would be unfeasible in the US. A recent news report ranked Brazil as the second largest concert market in the world. In the last year alone, hundreds of international artists have come to perform in Brazil. Bruno Mars had his most profitable leg of his tour here. This is pure prejudice against Latin Americans. And I'm sorry, but if she thinks she's fulfilled her quota with Latin fans with two shows in Mexico and one in Brazil after more than 10 years, a fan base that is undoubtedly her most engaged, it's because she really treats Latin fans with contempt. And I say this because there is this general feeling among Latin little monsters.

There were rumors several months back saying the NFL contacted Gaga and were very insistent on wanting her for "a project". We know it wasn't the superbowl, so the only logical reason would by precisely the XMas Halftime show. I'm 1000% that they asked, and i bet she said yes, and se will do it. You can tell there is hunger in her eyes. And like you said, the timing would be fantastic for her AOTY chances because right in the middle of christmas is when the final voting takes place. Some voters might vote the first week, but a lot vote up until the very end on the first week of January, as they are spending time away during the holidays. This event would help capture those last key voters, as she would be top of mind by then. Plus, it is entirely possible to pull off. I bet the NFL would take care of all the production and logistics, and Gaga can easily finish locking down the performance if she rehearses on those 10 days she has off between the Australian dates and Christmas. And she;s straight off the Mayhem ball so all the choreo has been learned regardless. All they have to do is lock down the music arrangements and practice. IMO, She should follow exactly what Beyonce did last year and only perform songs from Mayhem. Include Abracadabra, Disease and Perfect Celebrity mandatorily as these are the songs she sent to compete. Then round out the show with some other well established songs like Garden of Eden, Vanish Into You and The Dead Dance to show case the rest of the album.

Thankgod. I was loosing sleep over this

I really love the one before Killah.

Ngl I feel like before the reissue a lot of fans used to **** on CSTH + KFL because they had heard them like once and it was inconvenient for them to listen to them so they just wrote them off, but once the tracks became easier to stream a lot of the liddos immediately changed their tune

kinda giving this

I hate to say it Katy, but I think you’re making a big mistake

I have yet to hear the song. Is it good? Should I give it a stream or two?

Come to the Netherlands again. Or I will travel. But first I need to survive the slayage this Sunday AMSTERDAM, LETS GO!

LET'S GO!

The lack of taste or musical literacy here is truly remarkable…CSTH is arguably thematically and sonically more “Mayhem” than at least 4 tracks on the standard edition AND has the NIN/glam rock/dance theatricality influence that fans have been begging for since 2011…what’s not clicking It’s about having a TIME in the club…it’s about losing it at the afters during a comedown…it’s about an indulgent ecstasy fueled fantasy…in what world does its lyrics sound unfinished or like a P!nk song

Switify Daily Global D1 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 30,987,370 D2 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 18,104,619 (-12,882,751) D3 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 14,929,887 (-3,174,732) D4 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 17,150,536 (+2,220,649) D5 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 16,867,825 (-282,711) D6 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 15,879,187 (-988,638) D7 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 14,976,713 (-902,474) D8 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 15,307,123 (+330,410) D9 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 13,234,766 (-2,072,357) D10 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 11,013,003 (-2,221,763) D11 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 12,211,026 (+1,198,023) D12 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 12,009,464 (-201,562) D13 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 11,544,618 (-464,846) D14 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 11,072,262 (-472,356) D15 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 10,949,364 (-122,898) D16 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 9,944,270 (-1,005,094) D17 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,538,160 (-1,406,110) D18 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 9,537,701 (+999,541) D19 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 9,354,448 (-183,253) D20 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 9,160,764 (-193,684) D21 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,987,846 (-172,918) D22 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 9,211,282 (+223,436) D23 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,579,803 (-631,479) D24 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 7,468,512 (-1,111,291) D25 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,275,765 (+807,253) D26 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,321,003 (+45,238) D27 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,268,469 (-52,534) D28 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,177,679 (-90,790) D29 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,427,861 (+250,182) D30 #2 The FALL of Ophelia - 7,423,491 (-1,004,370) D32 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 6,696,169 (-727,322) (-727,322) (-727,322) (-727,322) IT's A 6, I REPEAT IT's A 6

The CTSH slander….I am absolutely appalled. I love that song so much and I was under the impression everyone loved it too. Such a fun metal moment with early 2000’s influence, it’s fresh but still quintessential Gaga.

Are you sure that's not a mistake?

I love Oobracadoobra Pay the tool to the angools drawing coorcles in the cloods Keep your moond on the doostance when the devool turns aroond

...and i really want PC to be a single. I dont care if it wont chart, it just needs to have a music video and more performances, other than the sandbox with skeletons.

I feel like if CSTH is performed live, people will appreciate it more.

Whew! I was afraid there wouldn’t be any boring & overused Joanne jokes in this thread!

It’s actually a personal album and only the title track relates to Joanne. Joanne was the first song she wrote when Mark asked her what she had to write about; everything else is about her career and personal life and DIC is just about Taylor really. The album is dedicated to her, but the only song about her is the title track.

help how do i delete someone else's post, im so uncomfortable lmao

It should’ve been in the film and would easily get an Oscar nod

I understand why it’s on Harlequin. Thematically and with its placement it really works, BUT god damn does it fit like a GLOVEEEE on Mayhem after The Beast. Seriously, if you haven’t heard it in that context, do yourself the favor.

I love seeing the trend I started. Feels like Gaga thoughts is alive again! About this one, yes, it definitely WAS a mistake. BOG should have been on harlequin. It would fit in better with the rest of Harlequin quality-wise. And if Happy Mistake was on Mayhem it would receive more attention, which it deserves. It also fits the theme of the album better than BOG.