Leaderboard

Ed Sheeran: Would you like to collaborate? LG: Just some water, thank you

This thread was The mistake

#15 (-7) Die With A Smile - 3,361,283 #17 (RE) Bloody Mary - 3,099,134 *BIGGEST DAY EVER* #64 (+110) Abracadabra - 2,034,729 #96 (+69) The Dead Dance - 1,752,986 #119 (+31) Poker Face - 1,644,771 #163 (+22) Just Dance - 1,472,555

There seems to be a number of posts about various Gaga songs being a mistake so I thought I’d throw this one out there. Personally, I happen to quite like the Gaga and think she is somewhat talented so I’m going to go with her not being a mistake. What are your thoughts?

*threatens

The Dead Dance cross 100,000,000 streams Total : 100,148,311 7th song on MAYHEM crossed 100,000,000

I tried to listen to a few songs but never got into her... Don't know what people like about her music

I think saying the album is strictly dedicated to her deceased aunt is reductive. The album, imo, uses the way the loss of Joanne affected her family, her father, and her specifically to examine where Gaga was emotionally at that time in her life and also was a gateway for her to look at her life from a different angle (who would I be right now if I weren’t famous?). If we consider it strictly as being dedicated to her aunt, it’s pretty easy to see most of the album isn’t really directly about her, but rather about both the way the trauma effected Gaga individually, indirectly through her relationship with her father and the way that trauma shaped her future relationships, and the way Gaga as an adult is trying to reconcile and mend those feelings, experiences, and aspects of her life.

No. It’s a good song and a welcome addition to the album and era.

Borderline offensive to mention it in the same sentence as The Cure.

Exactly this, Joanne is essentially her “come of age” record when she finally stopped being a young woman and became an adult and started realising what she wanted to make sonically and how she wanted to write. It’s essentially the younger (albeit more stubborn) version of Mayhem. We have songs like Diamond Heart about the time she was basically in the seedy underbelly of NYC but at the core of the gogo dancing, the drug taking, the partying she was a good person. A-yo is a direct response to the hate she got for ARTPOP imo and how she’s saying “I can’t wait for you to eat your words”, Perfect Illusion, DIC and Million Reasons are about 3 stages of her relationship with Taylor “peak, breakdown and post revelation”. Songs like Come to Mama, Just Another Day and Angel Down are about Gaga’s personality at the age in which she wrote it about her world views and her longing for a simple life. Grigio Girls is obviously about her girlfriends rallying around each other and Sonja in particular. And of course Joanne is about her dad and what she felt like he would’ve said to her if he could see her one more time.

MAYHEM will eventually have 6 solo songs above 200M streams in the next year and a half: Abracadabra Disease The Dead Dance Garden of Eden HBDUWM Vanish into you what a smash album

How the fk is it the least streamed song I would truly expect it to be Teeth or Speechless (don't get me wrong I LOVE these songs but Teeth has mixed feelings from this fanbase and I would expect the GP to skip Speechless since it's a ballad).

Lady Gaga is no longer relevant. Ever since Born this way she's a flop. DO NOT dothedeaddance. Give her no A-P-P-L-A-U-S-E. She's over.

It’s actually a personal album and only the title track relates to Joanne. Joanne was the first song she wrote when Mark asked her what she had to write about; everything else is about her career and personal life and DIC is just about Taylor really. The album is dedicated to her, but the only song about her is the title track.

Pretty sure most people j*rk off even if silently in the other room from family ... so it really does fit.

Was Abracadabra a Mistake?

Idk what meaningful impact you guys expect or think people are expecting tho. I don’t think anyone expected BM or TDD to be number one or something especially because of competition from the older songs (Thriller, Monster Mash, etc.), but this year definitely cemented the impact Halloween has on her discography as a whole I think some of you mistake people’s wishful thinking as serious delusion or actual expectations. Can’t we just enjoy that our queen is THE Queen of Halloween and not argue about whether or not the boost is “as big as people thought” or if it proves people “right” or “wrong”. A 14 year old song charting top 20 on global Spotify because of a specific holiday is a huge, meaningful boost. You can quite literally look at BM’s streams increasing on Halloween year to year and see how it’s increasing popularity each Halloween snowballs into further impact the next year

Is this not a taylor swift site?

Don’t ever call her work and art a mistake. Have a nice day

And the answer is YES! Blade of Grass is so underrated and unfairly treated by this fanbase. After all these years of hearing Gaga sing about longing, heartbreak, and the search for real love, it feels like she’s finally found it. "I’ve been so lonely in this field, fighting a battle with no shield." That lyric hits me every time!!! It feels like she’s looking back on all the pain she’s carried over the years, but now there’s peace and a sense of comfort she once thought she’d never have. She doesn’t have to face life alone anymore. That’s why this song means so much to me. It gives me hope that love is still out there, no matter how long it takes. So whenever I hear another fan act negatively towards this song, it low-key irks me because of how sentimental it probably is to her. Like can we just be happy for once?!

NO! It came out the week I defended my PhD in Law 🥺 it helped me go through it. Hence it will always have a special place in my heart

Nope! I think it's fun! Might not've been the biggest Gaga song this halloween but still a great addition to her repertoire in my opinion.

8 songs over 1 million streams and BTW (album) got its best streaming day ever

I’m sure it’ll be a hit with the halloween boost

It is her 7th fastest song to pass 100M in 60 days surpassing Stupid Love, Disease and The Cure. https://x.com/LG_Views/status/1892545013457846322?ref_src=twsrc^tfw|twcamp^tweetembed|twterm^1892545013457846322|twgr^88e664a82ad1c5be2695a9d66c2adff300893459|twcon^s1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.gagadaily.com%2Findex.php%3Fapp%3Dcoremodule%3Dsystemcontroller%3Dembedurl%3Dhttps%3A%2F%2Fx.com%2Flg_views%2Fstatus%2F1892545013457846322%3Fs%3D46

Madame, they haven't got any pop music video since G.U.Y "Let them hear jazz"

I love seeing the trend I started. Feels like Gaga thoughts is alive again! About this one, yes, it definitely WAS a mistake. BOG should have been on harlequin. It would fit in better with the rest of Harlequin quality-wise. And if Happy Mistake was on Mayhem it would receive more attention, which it deserves. It also fits the theme of the album better than BOG.

Could be wrong but seems like she doesn't do the whole meeting fans at hotel thing anymore ??

it had no effect on my life because I have a full time job

Teeth is such a banger though and one of her most unique sounding songs

She will say ahe have changed barista

Like this

Y’all really need to stop caring about charts. You all have more fun not stressing over something that doesn’t have a real effect on your life.

Come on and grab that juicy a$$ with all your fingers, make it clap Jokes aside, its honestly such a good song

Yes, it's one of her worst singles - up there with Stupid Love and The Cure.

They are equally great, and those who think otherwise are... mistakes

https://music.apple.com 1. BM-247 01 INTERLUDE 00:38 2. BEAUTIFUL MADNESS 01:50 3. TRIGGER 02:58 4. GOT ANY? 00:09 5. MILK 03:32 6. FOCUS 00:36 7. WAKE UP 03:04 8. BALENCIAGA COVERED EYES 04:06 9. NOT CAPABLE 00:28 10. EGO 03:35 11. MASTERPIECE 00:10 12. SIGN IT 03:09 13. PRE 00:17 14. LOVESONGS 03:33 15. UTERUS AND UNIVERSE 03:07 Total length: 31:12

I have this whole theory about Joanne's narrative and how the album's overarching theme is trauma and trauma responses. DiC is about loneliness, hypersexuality (something a lot of SA'd people develop), and self indulgence. As others have said, the Joanne album is about Gaga, not Joanne.

Switify Daily Global D1 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 30,987,370 D2 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 18,104,619 (-12,882,751) D3 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 14,929,887 (-3,174,732) D4 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 17,150,536 (+2,220,649) D5 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 16,867,825 (-282,711) D6 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 15,879,187 (-988,638) D7 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 14,976,713 (-902,474) D8 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 15,307,123 (+330,410) D9 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 13,234,766 (-2,072,357) D10 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 11,013,003 (-2,221,763) D11 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 12,211,026 (+1,198,023) D12 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 12,009,464 (-201,562) D13 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 11,544,618 (-464,846) D14 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 11,072,262 (-472,356) D15 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 10,949,364 (-122,898) D16 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 9,944,270 (-1,005,094) D17 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,538,160 (-1,406,110) D18 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 9,537,701 (+999,541) D19 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 9,354,448 (-183,253) D20 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 9,160,764 (-193,684) D21 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,987,846 (-172,918) D22 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 9,211,282 (+223,436) D23 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,579,803 (-631,479) D24 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 7,468,512 (-1,111,291) D25 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,275,765 (+807,253) D26 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,321,003 (+45,238) D27 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,268,469 (-52,534) D28 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,177,679 (-90,790) D29 #1 The Fate of Ophelia - 8,427,861 (+250,182) D30 #2 The FALL of Ophelia - 7,423,491 (-1,004,370) (-1,004,370) (-1,004,370) (-1,004,370) NO.2 on the 30th day, WE DID IT HONEY BEE !!!

It should’ve been in the film and would easily get an Oscar nod

i tend to think it was supposed to be on it "my head is full of broken mirrors" and then the whole mayhem aesthetic literally being broken mirrors. ugh dont . now im mad

I understand why it’s on Harlequin. Thematically and with its placement it really works, BUT god damn does it fit like a GLOVEEEE on Mayhem after The Beast. Seriously, if you haven’t heard it in that context, do yourself the favor.

Abra becoming another Halloween classic is a nice feat

Abra above 2m today is probs really good for long term numbers. Everyone streaming and remembering how great the song is, will help it stabilize nicely. A reverse Rain On Me experience

Is it really? As a Teeth stan who thinks DITD is lowkey overrated, I'm elated. But I also find this hard to believe

In what world is a 14 year old song pulling 3.2M streams because of Halloween not a boost?

Blood Mary on Halloween throughout the years: 2021: ~60k 2022: 152.033 2023: 1.663.459 2024: 2.416.967 2025: 3.099.134

Spotify Daily Top Songs Global #15 (-7) Die With A Smile 3,361,283 (+94,778) #17 (RE) Bloody Mary 3,099,134 *NEW PEAK #64 (+110) Abracadabra 2,034,729 (+764,987) #96 (+69) The 6969 Dance 1,752,986 (+467,100) #119 (+31) Poker Face 1,644,771 (+292,789) #163 (+22) Just Dance 1,472,555 (+237,146) QUEEN of HALLOWEEN indeed