UNVEILING THE TRUTH: Gaga's obsessive hater behind that Liza story

[rinasawachanta 3,483]

2 hours ago, Diamond Blood said:

This is 2 peices of 'evidence'

The first one is not shady in the slightest the second one is an opinion

Claiming this person is a staunch Lady Gaga hater hell bent on her downfall is a baseless claim lol 

Can someone explain to me why there are so many bittersweet comments on this site about the person we should all unanimously idolize? It's so typical of GagaDaily... Anyway.

[MOT 3,605]

7 minutes ago, elijahfan said:

With everything that's going on in the world, and in the US in particular, you really think this story is that big of a deal and that regular people will / should actually care about it?

Also, I believe this quote says more about Liza, or whoever her ghostwriter is, than it does about Gaga, and anyone with two functioning brain cells and a bit of honesty can see right through that. The overall panic and search for excuses I'm seeing in this thread really is uncalled for.

It's not about searching for excuses, not on my part anyway, and I'm under no illusions about Gaga by the way. I think she's a great artist, but that great art doesn't come from sugar and spice and all things nice, nor does her ability to survive and thrive in a very tough industry.

I am interested in how this is going to play out. I am interested in seeing how much publicity the book gets when it's published in March and what, if anything, Gaga does about it.

[SidewalkUnicorn 276]

44 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

Ngl, it’s really not a big deal and it honestly just reads like the editorialization of a bitter old f*g. Y’all need to stop catastrophizing lol 

With all due respect to Liza, very few people under 70 are going to care to read her memoir let alone obsess over one story in it. I’m a bit of a Studio 54/Warhol obsessive myself and I don’t even know if I’d be interested. I’m sure Gaga isn’t the only celeb in it with low key shade thrown at them. 
 

I hope LG didn’t actually do anything to disrespect Liza, but throwing other people under the bus to look like a hero doesn’t really fit with her overall personality in both public and almost every account from fans and random encounters.

Finally it is totally possible like others said Liza wanted to appear more dignified/capable then she did and let off general blame steam as a result. My 90 year old uncle thinks he can come down the stairs by himself. He can’t. If it were up to him he’d still be trying to drive. Liza has been in and out of a wheelchair iirc for years. Maybe it just wasn’t working out with the director’s chair and she was embarrassed. The writer may have chosen to stress the incident if he doesn’t care for Gaga. Who knows?

[TEETHTEETH 1,806]

2 hours ago, bim said:

When will people understand that all art is inspired and all art is subjective? Thank the lord this newer wave of pop stars and artists are trying to be a community and support each other. Edith Piaf was inspired by others. Madonna was inspired by others. Michael Jackson was inspired by others. We could play this game all day. With music. With film and television. With books. With paintings. Nothing is truly 100% original. 

Using writing Liza’s memoir to air out your salty opinions of Gaga is WILDLY more trashy than Gaga admitting to being inspired by/embodying those who came before her. 

To create art, firstly an artist becomes inspired. 
 

anyone criticizing this has simply never created. 

[nATAH 56,934]

1 hour ago, MOT said:

Nah, I think it IS a big deal. It's not some random person dissing Gaga on social media. It is Liza Minnelli's memoir, it is due to be published in March, and the bit about Gaga is pretty savage.

This book has been written by Michael Feinstein, not Liza. It is based on 10 years of stories and interviews as told to Feinstein. I agree with the OP. I think the savagery is likely to have emanated from Feinstein and not from Liza.

this is making absolutely no noise outside of this website or even stan twitter

nobody cares and this'll be old news by monday

[DopeEnigma 1,774]

2 hours ago, AVeryGagaHolyDick said:

They’re still VERY active, and they actually posted about the Liza story just two hours ago 

Imagine spending 15 years of your life running a Gaga-hate Instagram account with 1,200 followers despite Gaga not even knowing who you are 

Edit: look at this 

Wow, how sad their miserable lives must be, hope they find a hobby, bless em.

Edited February 21 by DopeEnigma

[rinasawachanta 3,483]

Apparently, this Feinstein is responsible for the new releases made with AI and Liza's vocals  #FreeLiza

[MOT 3,605]

48 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

In order for it to be defamatory it would both need to be 1.) untrue and 2.) excessively harmful to someone’s image. The parts that are “defamatory” (ie the shadiest) are totally subjective (“Gaga didn’t miss the opportunity to play the hero,” which is passive aggressive/eyeroll-y at best).
 

The most harmful insinuation you could infer would be that Gaga forced Liza into the wheelchair in order to make herself look benevolent, but nowhere is that correlation explicitly made, nor is her rationale for allegedly insisting Liza use the wheelchair mentioned, so absent that throughline being made explicit, there’d basically be no case to be made for defamation. Also I don’t really think most people would read the account presented in that uncharitable of a light, so the allegation of harm on Gaga’s part in a hypothetical defamation case would be weakened by that as well.

The exact quote is that Gaga 'didn't miss a beat to play the kindhearted hero for all the world to see'. I think that's saying that Gaga was pretending to be kindhearted when she was actually being cynical and self-serving. It's ok to think that, but I don't know if it's ok to publish it in a book. I await developments. Maybe there'll be none. Maybe the story will be dead in a couple of days and maybe the book won't make a splash when it comes out, but I remain interested.

[Ladle Ghoulash 52,702]

21 minutes ago, MOT said:

The exact quote is that Gaga 'didn't miss a beat to play the kindhearted hero for all the world to see'. I think that's saying that Gaga was pretending to be kindhearted when she was actually being cynical and self-serving. It's ok to think that, but I don't know if it's ok to publish it in a book. I await developments. Maybe there'll be none. Maybe the story will be dead in a couple of days and maybe the book won't make a splash when it comes out, but I remain interested.

Uncharitably characterizing someone else’s behavior isn’t even close to being defamatory. I anticipate that, if Gaga does anything, she’d likely just reach out to Liza and clarify her intentions. There is absolutely no way she pursues legal action over this and she would look insanely petty if she did.

[Jill 31,812]

6 hours ago, rinasawachanta said:

Can someone explain to me why there are so many bittersweet comments on this site about the person we should all unanimously idolize?

We used to be all over her until one day she said during an interview "Be bittersweet" and so we idolized her so much we started being bittersweet since that's what she wanted..

[Gaga Scholar 232]

From Liza's perspective, it probably really sucked to feel like she felt and THEN to read stories the next day about how sweet Gaga was to this old lady at the Oscars. It would definitely feel minimizing. I can see how that was hurtful. The last phase of life often is watching other people take over your life and your narrative...if we're lucky enough to age, we'll all be in Liza's shoes someday. Whomp, whomp. 

Edited February 24 by Gaga Scholar
I misspelled "lucky." Jeesh.

[iamnotladygaga 70]

Hes kind of just using her platform to spread that about gaga as if he said that everyone would be like it’s sad as Liza Minnelli herself might not have had much of a say in the memoir.

[iamnotladygaga 70]

On 2/22/2026 at 5:58 PM, Gaga Scholar said:

From Liza's perspective, it probably really sucked to feel like she felt and THEN to read stories the next day about how sweet Gaga was to this old lady at the Oscars. It would definitely feel minimizing. I can see how that was hurtful. The last phase of life often is watching other people take over your life and your narrative...if we're lukcy enough to age, we'll all be in Liza's shoes someday. Whomp, whomp. 

Thats a really good point.