Heavy Metal Lover vs. Garden Of Eden

[Blackout19 13,291]

which song do you like more? 

[Guille 1,573]

I love HML, it is a Born This Way highlight for me, but Garden of Eden is just pop perfection

[gagzus 16,529]

HML is good but definitely feels like it was the last song made for the album production and “catchiness” wise.

Garden of Eden feels better produced, better written and has an actual chorus so I’m gonna say GOE 

Also controversial opinion, with the exceptions of Scheiße and GH. Mayhem absolutely devours BTW in general.

[calmar 22,594]

HML all the way. Sorry. I'm not a huge GOE fan.

[dynamite 62,217]

I prefer listening to GoE

HML is great and pretty unique but it feels more like an interlude

[RudraCNG 15,382]

To think GoE used to be a skip for me during my first few listens and now is one of my favorites.

I prefer GoE ofc.

[River 120,629]

Come on and hit me come on

[Ivy 13,157]

HML is my favorite Gaga song, so that one 

[Bronco 15,190]

Ngl I used to skip GoE until I saw it live.

So HML is superior for me

[GAGASEXUAL 3,880]

HML wins

[Sneaky Oliver 22,514]

Wow that’s hard, I think I’m biased necause HML reminds me of my teenage self feeling himself and feeling so wild 

While GOE has a special place in my heart because that’s the song I first saw Gaga like a few meters away from me when she performed the outro/break at the end of the runway in Copacabana 

I think I’m going to vote for HML because the lyrics are superior, my only issue with GOE is that I wish it had more interesting lyrics on the verses 

Edited November 6, 2025 by Sneaky Oliver

[TAIPEI 2,848]

[Robert 322]

Heavy metal lover. I love Garden of Eden, but I think it’s more “basic”

[Gorehound 4,877]

Heavy Metal Lover is my all time favourite Gaga song. Always has been always will be. There'll never be anything else like it sadly. I know it has a couple of minor flaws but there's just something so f*cking good about that song. It's so dirty, grungy, psychedelic and trippy, and that chorus is just pure sex to me. I wish she'd explored that style more. Garden Of Eden is still a sick ass song tho, but doesn't come close to HML.

Edited November 7, 2025 by Gorehound

[palma 8,616]

HML is a song that no one could execute but Gaga and it’s bible to me but GoE is a pop masterpiece and they don’t make it like that anymore.