Songs Gaga didn't write on (or very minimally)

[OMonster 14,759]

Yeah, the Sour Candy writer's demo is evidence that Gaga had very little input into the origination of that song. She certainly optimised and refined it, but the core idea and lyrics didn't come from her. Feels like one of only a few songs in her discography that match that definition. 

 

[OMonster 14,759]

2 hours ago, River said:

Sine From Above was written by Axwell and Ryan Tedder for Elton John 6-7 years before Chromatica.

I don't think this is right. I believe they produced the instrumental but not the lyrics. 

Given Chromatica's entire theming was based around the 'sine', I think that concept must've come from Gaga. If it didn't, that's very interesting and indicative of just how hands-off she was in the whole process. It would really be something if she themed her album around a lyric she didn't originate. 

[Ladle Ghoulash 27,894]

8 minutes ago, River said:

prove it 

1:05 

 

[Ladle Ghoulash 27,894]

3 minutes ago, OMonster said:

Yeah, the Sour Candy writer's demo is evidence that Gaga had very little input into the origination of that song. She certainly optimised and refined it, but the core idea and lyrics didn't come from her. Feels like one of only a few songs in her discography that match that definition. 

 

Ngl explains why I dislike it so much 

[River 118,933]

3 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

1:05 

 

u proved my point exactly, I win

thanks 

[Ladle Ghoulash 27,894]

Just now, River said:

u proved my point exactly, I win

thanks 

U said she only wrote the BP parts and yet the chorus (which Gaga sings on the album version) is in this demo 

[River 118,933]

Just now, Ladle Ghoulash said:

U said she only wrote the BP parts and yet the chorus (which Gaga sings on the album version) is in this demo 

Exactly because gaga wrote it before this Madison Vodka whatever her name sang the demo so the girl from Blue Penis could know how to sing the song their wrote 

I can’t believe I need to explain that in 2025

This AI generation is hopeless 

[Ladle Ghoulash 27,894]

11 minutes ago, River said:

Exactly because gaga wrote it before this Madison Vodka whatever her name sang the demo so the girl from Blue Penis could know how to sing the song their wrote 

I can’t believe I need to explain that in 2025

This AI generation is hopeless 

Your brain needs to be studied 

[LG2008 5,682]

1 hour ago, Controversiaga said:

There could be more we do not know about, but I think the majority of them would be on Joanne and Chromatica as those are the albums that have the highest number of various songwriters credited…

…assuming there is no ghost writing involved anywhere

Considering how generous Gaga is with credits and has always been, I don't think there is any ghost writing in her projects, but I'm sure there's plenty of crediting when it probably shouldn't have happened  

Edited yesterday at 04:02 PM by LG2008

[River 118,933]

17 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

Your brain needs to be studied 

Do it then Ms. Meredith Ladle Gray 

[monketsharona 85,322]

3 hours ago, dracomalfoy said:

I’m curious about this one because I think it was Ryan who said the song wasn’t even called “Sine from Above”, it was just an Elton John demo sitting on his laptop, and it fits the Chromatica storyline so well, I always thought that she might’ve reused some melodies and the production but participated on the lyrics.

Yeah they said that this song drastically changed after Gaga took it

The only song Gaga jumped on is Come To Mama, the Father John Misty demo is quite exactly the same as the final Gaga version

[27monster27 13,990]

The May 2020 document leak revealed that she didn't write Brooklyn Nights, which is shocking because of how specific the lyrics are to her.

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 26,531]

1 hour ago, OMonster said:

I don't think this is right. I believe they produced the instrumental but not the lyrics. 

Given Chromatica's entire theming was based around the 'sine', I think that concept must've come from Gaga. If it didn't, that's very interesting and indicative of just how hands-off she was in the whole process. It would really be something if she themed her album around a lyric she didn't originate. 

Well, she didn’t name the album Chromatica herself, so it’s not too hard to imagine

[TheARTPOPball 836]

Come to Mama is one of my favorite gaga songs and this makes so much since after finding out father john Misty's involvement 

[OMonster 14,759]

35 minutes ago, AVeryGagaHolyDick said:

Well, she didn’t name the album Chromatica herself, so it’s not too hard to imagine

Oh wait yes, that was Bloodpop's idea wasn't it? I had forgotten that. Damn. So Chromatica as a theme and concept wasn't even Gaga's. Sad.