Anthony Fantano ranks 'The Dead Dance' as 'meh' on Weekly Track Roundup

[Cpeer 4,738]

Reading the comments here before listening to him I thought he bashed her or said it’s awful. 

He praised her vocals and said it’s a good song. We all know it’s not her best song ever or even best song on Mayhem

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 26,885]

15 hours ago, GAGASEXUAL said:

Is he wrong tho? 

Yes

[bpmMonkey 6,491]

who tf is Antony Fantano ?!  gurl bye 

[Gabi001 2,470]

14 hours ago, timdrake said:

idk who he is, but that's kinda my feeling too. chorus is catchy, but the rest doesn't do much for me

(and that's okay! not every Gaga song needs to be the best song ever to us)

Wdym the verses are eargasm 

[HeAteMyh3art 1,964]

1 hour ago, Cpeer said:

Reading the comments here before listening to him I thought he bashed her or said it’s awful. 

He praised her vocals and said it’s a good song. We all know it’s not her best song ever or even best song on Mayhem

This lol. The category he put it in is meh but pretty much only praised the song, only adding that there are much better tracks on MAYHEM

[MOT 3,243]

I think the song is fine, which is just another way of saying meh. If it was a great song it would have been on the album in the first place. The only time this guy gets vehement in his critique is when he's praising Gaga's vocals.

[palma 8,584]

But anyway, I'm tired of his opinions being a topic of conversation  

[Ivy 12,981]

Whatever I'm loving it, it's so discoey 

[angelduuh 541]

Can we stop posting things about him? He clearly doesn't likes Gaga and we shouldn't giving him any views. He's so full of himself. 

[ActualPatient 1,988]

7 hours ago, Gabi001 said:

Wdym the verses are eargasm 

the second verse is jaw-dropping!!! the first one was uhm...

[LadyxGaGa 2,582]

13 hours ago, LadyxGaGa said:

ngl i’m sure he is the only one who feels that way 

i stand corrected i rly thought everyone loved this song 

[tomsches 17,475]

People need to grow up. He‘s probably one of the most knowledgable people of the Internet when it comes to music. Sometimes I 100% disagree with him and he rips my favorite Albums apart like they‘re trash but I still appreciate his opinions and criticism. He‘s also right, there are superior Songs on Mayhem. 

[meltedplastic 494]

He is just some guy that makes videos hes not even a professional writer or critic like he is just some bald guy

[DancingInTheShadow 17]

On 9/8/2025 at 9:23 AM, SimonBaetens said:

8:05

He praises Gaga's vocal performance on the track, but says there are many superior tracks on Mayhem.

  THE DEAD DANCE ate idc

[Kayi 2,788]

It's his opinion. Tbh I don't love this song as much as the other Mayhem tracks... 

But the more I watch his videos, the more I realize that this guy struggle with his system of ratings. I mean, sometimes he have to rate problematic ppl's music and rate it low because of their personas. And sometimes he rate high overhated songs to seem edgy. 

Edited September 9 by Kayi