Ronk 14,761 Posted Saturday at 12:57 PM Share Posted Saturday at 12:57 PM On 6/16/2025 at 2:30 PM, PartySick said: Tl;dr - This should have been Abracadabra That would have been perfect. I live outside the space time continuum. 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
banjosnap 282 Posted Saturday at 01:06 PM Share Posted Saturday at 01:06 PM DWAS is a collaboration. Someone had to be working on it first for it to exist. This is a fact with all songs. Bad Romance existed before Gaga was on it - as an instrumental concept - but we don't discredit it's achievements and call it a RedOne song or a half achievement. Celine Dion wrote exactly zero songs in her entire life. Are we saying "my heart will go on" isn't a successful song & shouldn't be on her albums? The talk around DWAS is typical of the stratospheric standard people hold Gaga to that they do not hold any other artist to. She must write, sing, perform, choreograph, produce, play the instruments & birth the concept... because? OH! Almost forgot, she must also heavily promote & have extreme chart success and critical acclaim all at the same time. You people are on a different planet. 2 2 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lucas 26,311 Posted Saturday at 01:18 PM Share Posted Saturday at 01:18 PM On 6/16/2025 at 8:27 PM, nezumi said: America is trash nowadays, BB is trash nowadays, do we really care about this? I don't we care if it's good for us, we don't care if it's bad for us Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
JustTea 5,796 Posted Saturday at 01:43 PM Share Posted Saturday at 01:43 PM (edited) 37 minutes ago, banjosnap said: DWAS is a collaboration. Someone had to be working on it first for it to exist. This is a fact with all songs. Bad Romance existed before Gaga was on it - as an instrumental concept - but we don't discredit it's achievements and call it a RedOne song or a half achievement. Celine Dion wrote exactly zero songs in her entire life. Are we saying "my heart will go on" isn't a successful song & shouldn't be on her albums? The talk around DWAS is typical of the stratospheric standard people hold Gaga to that they do not hold any other artist to. She must write, sing, perform, choreograph, produce, play the instruments & birth the concept... because? OH! Almost forgot, she must also heavily promote & have extreme chart success and critical acclaim all at the same time. You people are on a different planet. Well said, exactly! I guess Sour Candy isn't a Gaga song either because she didn't invent it and only sings 50% of the song and only wrote some of her own parts... Edited Saturday at 01:43 PM by JustTea Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
banjosnap 282 Posted Saturday at 02:00 PM Share Posted Saturday at 02:00 PM 11 minutes ago, JustTea said: Well said, exactly! I guess Sour Candy isn't a Gaga song either because she didn't invent it and only sings 50% of the song and only wrote some of her own parts... You know what else? Perfect illusion, Always remember us this way, til it happens to you & Sine from above also were conceived without Gaga involved at their inception. Are we now saying ARUTW is a Hillary Lindsey song (not duff & lohan)?? No. Is perfect illusion a Kevin Parker single? No. These people that are biased against collab ballads (despite them being Gaga's most successful genre) and just want kick pow clap scoot booty slam rah rah lala moo bops have no concept of how anything works. 3 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
whyl 139 Posted Saturday at 11:29 PM Share Posted Saturday at 11:29 PM The way when I listened the song first time I thought this song was sketchy and generic as ever been and of course it is breaking records . It is tough to be artist nowadays Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Featured Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.