Unpopular Gaga Opinions (The Re-Up: Pt. 2 - the Revenge) [Piano Version]

[Ladle Ghoulash 18,767]

1 minute ago, Heygirl22 said:

Also Free Woman is underrated 

when I saw it live at the chromatica ball I was moved to tears 😭 the gold robe and the vocals !!!! Queen!!!

Great song, lackluster production on the album (loved it live at the CBT)

[A Fried Egg 8,256]

I know this is an unpopular opinion thread, but that day when we voted Scheiße best Gaga song of all time was the best thing ever. It was the first time I felt hope for our fanbase. Well done gays and girls.  
 

6 minutes ago, Heygirl22 said:

Also Free Woman is underrated 

when I saw it live at the chromatica ball I was moved to tears 😭 the gold robe and the vocals !!!! Queen!!!

Agreed. Free Woman is overslandered. 

Edited December 25, 2024 by LeafBug

[Poltergeist 3,566]

21 minutes ago, PartySick said:

Plural?

Damn true, I always forget it just transitions into the bridge 

[PartySick 151,782]

11 minutes ago, Plastic Flower said:

Scrapping the Swinefest bridge for Sexxx Dreams was the better choice.

"We were in the swimming pool, I was naked, boy so were you, and I wrote this song while we made love" kinda goes hard though lbr

[itsmeluka 954]

Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) is a cringe song and i almost hate it

i tried my best to like it for 15 years but it’s always a skip

[PartySick 151,782]

1 minute ago, Poltergeist said:

Damn true, I always forget it just transitions into the bridge 

For the longest time I've wanted to make a "Chromatica version" of MJH and chop it up like Alice but the lyrics would literally be...

Lady of the Dame
Won't be a slave to the blonde
Or the culture of the popular

'Cause I love love
'Cause I love love
You better than
You better than
My darkest sin

Russian hookers and cheap gin

I think that I could be fine
If I could be Mary Jane Holland tonight (x2)

I know that mom and dad think I'm a mess
But it's alright because I am rich as piss

I think that I could be fine
If I could be Mary Jane Holland tonight (x4)

And cut out all the neat blade synth sounds and guitars, clean up the bass, and replace the epic drums with some stock snares...Alice is not a complete song and Bloodpop isn't a good producer...two hills I'll die on as well  

[itsmeluka 954]

Americano doesn’t fit the album concept

It should be used as Puss in boots movie soundtrack only (as it is) it would be even better if it was released for the movie exclusively, it would be much bigger hit 

[PartySick 151,782]

2 minutes ago, itsmeluka said:

Americano doesn’t fit the album concept

It should be used as Puss in boots movie soundtrack only (as it is) it would be even better if it was released for the movie exclusively, it would be much bigger hit 

I actually disagree with this one

BTW is a pretty political album so the song about unfair laws (directly referring to the anti-same sex marriage laws of its time and nodding to the unfair immigration laws of the US) fit perfectly.

[itsmeluka 954]

1 minute ago, PartySick said:

I actually disagree with this one

BTW is a pretty political album so the song about unfair laws (directly referring to the anti-same sex marriage laws of its time and nodding to the unfair immigration laws of the US) fit perfectly.

sonically it doesn't fit

[Kaevin95 152]

Hair is one of her best songs, pretty much i am like 1% that states this 

[Jessica Germ 1,797]

Uhm Chromatica deserved more singles? Better handled singles? Idk 

[MDevacelli 1,526]

Venus production and mixing are terrible, it really shows Gaga inexperience in music production at the time. 

Edited December 25, 2024 by MDevacelli

[Plastic Flower 4,261]

1 hour ago, PartySick said:

"We were in the swimming pool, I was naked, boy so were you, and I wrote this song while we made love" kinda goes hard though lbr

I mean, yes it does, but imo it just didn’t fit the song that much. But that’s just me 

[JoeCool 305]

Hold My Hand is my least favorite Gaga song and could possibly be in my top 10 all time of least favorite songs I disliked it so much.

 

It didn't help I didn't like that Top Gun movie either 

Edited December 25, 2024 by JoeCool

[27monster27 12,300]

The Kendrick Lamar collabs falling through is one of her biggest missed opportunities. A missed way to bring back GP favor in a lower risk way because she was a featured artist, and these would've put her in the light of a new audience.