Your favorite album of all time?

[Anderson123 39,924]

6 minutes ago, LittleMonster20 said:

I do remember that this album was kind of a comeback album from her after Try This (which is her only album that kind of underperformed, sad because it’s a great album as well), but I think the instant success of Funhouse (the lead So What going #1) kind of overshadowed I’m Not Dead. Even though it immediately did better than Try This, it took until U+Ur Hand was released as a single and Who Knew to be re-released as one for this era to really take off.

Anyways, I agree The One That Got Away should have been a single.

I Have Seen The Rain is also such a beautiful and emotional album closer.

It’s very weird to see Try This as an album that underperformed because she made it forced by her record label as a way to say “you want me to write 10 songs? Here you go” to just move on from it and ended up winning a Grammy. 

[LittleMonster20 9,900]

7 hours ago, Anderson123 said:

It’s very weird to see Try This as an album that underperformed because she made it forced by her record label as a way to say “you want me to write 10 songs? Here you go” to just move on from it and ended up winning a Grammy. 

Yes, and also because it’s P!nk’s most rock-influenced and punk-influenced album, which is generally considered to be her signature sound.

To be fair, I’m also deliberately claiming it underperformed instead of straight up flopped, because it generally still did well especially overseas. But it didn’t live up to the huge success of M!ssundaztood overall. I also read a theory that because all the singles were soundtracks for movies and shows around that time (Trouble was in countless commercials, God Is A DJ went on Mean Girls, Feel Good Time for Charlie’s Angels) people felt she ‘sold out’. That combined with the unpleasant way her label pressured her to make this album and the fact that this was also the era in which she broke her partnership with Linda Perry, who played a huge part in M!ssundaztood.

[Anderson123 39,924]

5 hours ago, LittleMonster20 said:

My personal list:

1. Chromatica - Lady Gaga   
2. Goodbye Lullaby - Avril Lavigne    
3. Rainbow - Kesha    
4. I’m Not Dead - P!nk    
5. Life Support - Madison Beer

TASTE, I love this album so much too. I feel like this is definitely her best album, but I barely see anyone talking about it. What’s your fav songs? Mine are Long Way To Happy, I’m Not Dead and Runaway.

Goodbye Lullaby is so underrated. It's my 3rd favorite Avril album after Under My Skin and Let Go. Perfect from start to finish.

I'm Not Dead is also a killer P!nk album, nice to see it getting love here.

8 hours ago, River said:

I think there's something very special with this one, it's something that will never be replicated, I know that it's not a pop masterpiece, but every song in this album brings a mix of emotions, some kind of freedom, fun, carefree, feelings

 

Rolling Stones Magazine gave i 1.5 stars at that time

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-album-reviews/spice-249730/

f*ck u Christina Kelly

I love this one so much but Spice Up Your Life as a lead single was everything to me and listen to that way more than Wannabe. All of the Spice tracks are great and still listen to them. Say You'll Be There, 2 Become One, Mama, Who Do You Think You Are, Something Kinda Funny are all

The Spice Girls and Aqua albums bring me so much joy.

[RochesterJoannster 3,601]

Joanne by Gaga and Goodbye Lullaby by Avril are my two favorites 

[BeyonkaAte 649]

Probably The Fame Monster

or Born This Way

i can't overstate just how much these two albums defined my life, not just growing up, but over the past 15 years.

[clementine 290]

Pls recommend your favorites to listen with headphones I just got some AirPod max and I want to experience some stuff 

[SlaeUrAnus 16,092]

10 hours ago, River said:

I think there's something very special with this one, it's something that will never be replicated, I know that it's not a pop masterpiece, but every song in this album brings a mix of emotions, some kind of freedom, fun, carefree, feelings

 

Rolling Stones Magazine gave i 1.5 stars at that time

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-album-reviews/spice-249730/

f*ck u Christina Kelly

You would have taste…

If you said Spiceworld instead 

[River 120,593]

1 hour ago, SlaeUrAnus said:

You would have taste…

If you said Spiceworld instead 

[Bronco 15,157]

3 hours ago, Anderson123 said:

I'm Not Dead is also a killer P!nk album, nice to see it getting love here.

I'll die on this hill. 

I'm Not Dead is the mark of a true P!nk fan vs a casual listener tbh.

It's the perfect distillation of everything that makes up "P!nk". Humour, politics, rock & pop blending together, powerful ballads & deep reflective tracks mixed with stupid just for fun tracks.

[Super 1,074]

if it wasnt for these two masterpieces i would probably never be making music
so

[Ouranos 884]

2 hours ago, SlaeUrAnus said:

You would have taste…

If you said Spiceworld instead 

Spice world doesn’t have if you can’t dance tho 

[Ouranos 884]

Gaga Born this way

non Gaga I’d probably say jagged little pill I’ve bought it so many times

[LauraPalmer 1,772]

True Romance - Charli XCX

Born This Way

Norman F***ing Rockwell - Lana Del Rey

Station to Station - David Bowie

Night Time, My Time - Sky Ferreira

[Nite 5,772]

Born This Way

The Strokes - Is This It

Phoenix - Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix

[River 120,593]

1 hour ago, Bronco said:

I'll die on this hill. 

I'm Not Dead is the mark of a true P!nk fan vs a casual listener tbh.

It's the perfect distillation of everything that makes up "P!nk". Humour, politics, rock & pop blending together, powerful ballads & deep reflective tracks mixed with stupid just for fun tracks.

Fingers, Cause I Can, I'm Not dead, Leave Me Alone (I'm Lonely). this album is so goood