The Cure vs. Hold My Hand

[Ladle Ghoulash 27,037]

1 hour ago, FfFfFfFF said:

What if it's the reverse? I remember how hated The Cure was in 2017.

Honestly, much more likely. 

[PMM 3,274]

now that's a hard question...

both sucks

the cure is so ally scrapped song codded and it's so bad 
hold my hand on the other hand.... it's a shallow wanna be song it's so bad 

i voted HMH because it's not a reject, and i like instrumental more

i think overall i listened to them less then 10 times ..... 

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 26,252]

The Cure has a GREAT melody even though the production is basic, so The Cure

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 26,252]

Just now, PMM said:

now that's a hard question...

both sucks

the cure is so ally scrapped song codded and it's so bad 
hold my hand on the other hand.... it's a shallow wanna be song it's so bad 

i voted HMH because it's not a reject, and i like instrumental more

i think overall i listened to them less then 10 times ..... 

The Cure wasn’t a reject, AND it was actually released so

[PMM 3,274]

3 minutes ago, The Z said:

The Cure wasn’t a reject, AND it was actually released so

was it on the album? no! was it in the movie? no! that's not a Gaga song it's Ally's 

Even Love Me Left was on the album and that's also a reject song

the only good part about he cure is 3:29 mark

[Guest]

I dislike them both. I can count on one hand the amount of times I have listened to them. 

[Rivington St 510]

HMH piano's version 

[TheBadRomancer 1,025]

This was hard because the bridge of Hold My Hand is one I deeply love, but overall I think The Cure. That song has always felt to me like an upgraded version of "Greatest", which was what I needed when I was younger. 

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 26,252]

2 hours ago, PMM said:

was it on the album? no! was it in the movie? no! that's not a Gaga song it's Ally's 

Even Love Me Left was on the album and that's also a reject song

the only good part about he cure is 3:29 mark

That’s not true though, The Cure was never supposed to be part of ASIB. She recorded it and Heal Me for her own catalog, and then they decided to add Heal Me to the film and release The Cure as a stand-alone single

[PMM 3,274]

16 minutes ago, The Z said:

That’s not true though, The Cure was never supposed to be part of ASIB. She recorded it and Heal Me for her own catalog, and then they decided to add Heal Me to the film and release The Cure as a stand-alone single

you are wrong

they were recording those pop songs for Ally but then decided that The Cure was the worst and agreed to releases it as Gaga song. That's why it's a **** song 

[Zombiecat 17,058]

I have to choose HMH because after seeing it live i actually really like it... I do like the cure also but meh, bias is real  

[djBuffoon 12,129]

Neither of them are great. “The Cure” is pretty well-written, it’s sweet and catchy, but the production feels like it’s missing some integral pieces. 
“Hold My Hand” is gorgeously produced and has a beautiful, soaring melody but the lyrics leave something to be desired at times.

[bpmMonkey 6,190]

I do like hold my ham, its one of my bicep workout tracks.
Both of them are kinda cringy, and I have a nostalgia soft spot for the cure as well, but hmh takes it, after seeing her perform it so cute during TCB 

[Controversiaga 11,701]

Meh 

the cure by a landslide but neither are in my top 10 Gaga songs of all time , that’s for sure 

[Defmix100 6,450]

1 hour ago, PMM said:

you are wrong

they were recording those pop songs for Ally but then decided that The Cure was the worst and agreed to releases it as Gaga song. That's why it's a **** song 

I thought the co-writer of Heal Me said she had no idea it was going to be used for ASIB, so it was originally for Gaga herself then was used in the movie later