Peter Parker 16,365 Posted March 2 In my opinion her acting was better in Hotel than in ASIB, even though they’re both great. Which do you think had the better acting skills? 2 1 Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
ALGAYDO 14,888 Posted March 2 Sis HOW was her acting better in AHS?? 5 1 Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
Brainiac 8,964 Posted March 2 I mean the obvious answer is the one she was nominated for an OSCAR for. 6 Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
androiduser 4,649 Posted March 2 ASIB, it's much more subtle... and I think that the best parts of Gaga's acting in ASIB are not the crying/screaming/throwing things scenes, but the small subtle scenes in the first part of the movie that build and develop her character. 10 Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
modern ecstasy 6,532 Posted March 2 ASIB by far. That was such a great performance from her. 2 Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
NFRatwell 19,572 Posted March 2 ASIB was cohesive with her acting, something AHS didn’t have. You could actually see her develop as an actress with the countess, even though Ryan tried to make it seem intentional with character development. 1 Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
Peter Parker 16,365 Posted March 2 3 minutes ago, ALGAYDO said: Sis HOW was her acting better in AHS?? Her delivery felt more natural 2 1 Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
Guest MagneticMoon Posted March 2 ASIB. AHS she was in her comfort zone, and her acting in the movie was more raw and honest. Both performances are great, but ASIB was better. Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
NFRatwell 19,572 Posted March 2 2 minutes ago, Brainiac said: I mean the obvious answer is the one she was nominated for an OSCAR for. You can’t get nominated for an Oscar with a TV show lol 1 Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
Brainiac 8,964 Posted March 2 1 minute ago, NFRatwell said: You can’t get nominated for an Oscar with a TV show lol I'm aware. My point still stands. Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
NFRatwell 19,572 Posted March 2 Just now, Brainiac said: I'm aware. My point still stands. That’s not a point though, you can’t say she did better in a movie simply because it was the only one eligible for an award even though I agree ASIB was better. Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
TheSlash 11,276 Posted March 2 4 minutes ago, Brainiac said: I mean the obvious answer is the one she was nominated for an OSCAR for. The Golden Globe she received for her acting in AHS says hi . I think you really can't compare them. In AHS, she didn't have THAT much acting experience yet and the character was far from relatable. On the other hand, in ASIB, Gaga had much more experience and the character hit far closer to home for Gaga. An original mess since 1995 1 Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
gypsy101 4,080 Posted March 2 girl WHAT she is not good in AHS like...at all. she is so wooden and unlifelike 1 Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
Agunimon 11,007 Posted March 2 Her acting in American Horror Story was terrible. 4 1 Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
Rebel 459 Posted March 2 No shade but I couldn't take her seriously sometimes in AHS. Like I lived for the costumes and stuff but the acting served high school in some scenes. ASIB was actually impressive. 6 Share Link to post Share on other sites Facebook Twitter
