Jump to content

Lady Gaga CD Collection Thread - Pt. 3


drinkmytears
 Share

Featured Posts

gagafrontrow
4 hours ago, LORD GAGA said:

plus the 'words' CD as far as I remember is it not just a self made cd as well with the title written on the CD by Gaga in sharpie? that one I believe there to only be one of and it was sold at auction years ago there's a photo of Rob Leone holding all of the demo CD's. 

For somebody with such authority, you surprisingly make two mistakes. The disc of the Words EP was not shown in the Leone auction, only the front cover. And the auction was closed before anything was sold. Leone returned everything to Gaga for an undisclosed amount as reported widely.

www.gagafrontrow.com
Link to post
Share on other sites

LORD GAGA
2 hours ago, Alphonse said:

 

There is an unnecessary and unhelpful personal tone to these comments, which may invalidate anything said in itself.

That said, it is to be noted that gagafrontrow states clearly which items on his site are bootlegs, so he is not pretending otherwise and instead makes it clear which are official and which not, or even when there is doubt.

Claiming to know more because you've been collecting longer (a doubtful claim) is not helpful either. The first time Red and Blue became public was March 2009, well into Gaga' career. 

Everybody knows Red and Blue is not a factory release, so what's the point?

And should your copy of Red and Blue be authentic, gagafrontrow will be mighty happy because he has the same one. Yet upon closer comparison of that copy with the Leone auction copy and the original leak on March 10, 2009, he sadly concluded there were differences. But again, should he be proven wrong, he will be ever so very happy.

It being unnecessary and the tone is something construed and assumed by yourself, I assure you there is no 'tone' from my end and it certainly doesn't detract from any point made. A doubtful claim? you may doubt all you like... it's accurate Mathieu, referring to yourself in third person is a bit odd and the fact its not a factory release is the entire point... how can you of all people possibly know what is real and what is not having never owned a genuine one, and make sweeping statements about others when you haven't any idea haven't never had it? Mine did not come from the same source as yours or Kevins.

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

LORD GAGA
3 hours ago, Alphonse said:

Why don't you just say that your copy is authentic, post images so we can compare, etc. Why the personal attack when all we as fans are interested in is helping one another.

I am GagaMania... its on my site. Feel free to compare it, I have no problem with that.

3 hours ago, Alphonse said:

For somebody with such authority, you surprisingly make two mistakes. The disc of the Words EP was not shown in the Leone auction, only the front cover. And the auction was closed before anything was sold. Leone returned everything to Gaga for an undisclosed amount as reported widely.

I never claimed to have 'such authority' your tone throughout would suggest you are under the impression you have some though... lol as for the words CD I have no idea all I know is one of the discs definitely was demos and the cd had sharpie hand writing on it... I know Gaga bought them back, my assumption is the words cd was probably written in sharpie like the couple of others included in the auction, I should have made that clear. I am not here to fight with you or argue over something that honestly none of us can 100% confirm correct/false but I'm also not here to allow sweeping statements to be made about my collection either.

Using the LMAO 'reaction'... you sure you weren't looking at your own replies? Someone your age should know better than to be so juvenile.

Edited by LORD GAGA
Link to post
Share on other sites

gagafrontrow
1 hour ago, LORD GAGA said:

It being unnecessary and the tone is something construed and assumed by yourself, I assure you there is no 'tone' from my end and it certainly doesn't detract from any point made. A doubtful claim? you may doubt all you like... it's accurate Mathieu, referring to yourself in third person is a bit odd and the fact its not a factory release is the entire point... how can you of all people possibly know what is real and what is not having never owned a genuine one, and make sweeping statements about others when you haven't any idea haven't never had it? Mine did not come from the same source as yours or Kevins.

No, I'm just the cat really.

You chose to attack gagafrontrow, not doing anything to solve the issue on fake cds.

Authenticity of the CD can be judged from the two copies we know are legit: the leak in 2009 and the Leone copy. How do you even know where the gfr copies came from? Besides none of them are listed because they were judged not authentic.

So tell us how/where did you get your copy and post scans that can be compared to the 2009 leaked images. That might solve things quickly.

www.gagafrontrow.com
Link to post
Share on other sites

LORD GAGA
25 minutes ago, Alphonse said:

No, I'm just the cat really.

You chose to attack gagafrontrow, not doing anything to solve the issue on fake cds.

Authenticity of the CD can be judged from the two copies we know are legit: the leak in 2009 and the Leone copy. How do you even know where the gfr copies came from? Besides none of them are listed because they were judged not authentic.

So tell us how/where did you get your copy and post scans that can be compared to the 2009 leaked images. That might solve things quickly.

The images of my copy is on my website, compare away. I didn’t attack anyone I simply stated facts, I’m not here to do anything about the ‘issue on fake CD’s’ I don’t buy them and would think most people would be clever enough not to as well. Well I imagine if yours and Kevin’s are from the same place then that’s how, but I have no idea where either of you got copies from, mine is not from any kind of online auction etc which based on what you’ve said is where yours was from, mine is just from a connection. There’s nothing to be solved, make your own judgement if you want to blindly accept that all copies except those two you mentioned aren’t real then you can do so but don’t state it as if it’s fact.

 

Have a good day.

Link to post
Share on other sites

LORD GAGA
20 hours ago, Hurem said:

I'm not like broke broke,  I just don't have $100 for stuff that's been put up online lately. :rip: 

And I don't even know what I really want 💀 

Ahh I see haha I misunderstood :rip:

Is there anything you've been after for a long time? 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hurem
8 minutes ago, LORD GAGA said:

Ahh I see haha I misunderstood :rip:

Is there anything you've been after for a long time? 

Hmm... I'd love to get all the vinyls since at the moment I've only got The Fame one. :rip: But I also have a soft spot for The Fame (Monster) singles and the dozens of releases that each single got. :flutter:

Link to post
Share on other sites

ChicaSkas
On 7/19/2018 at 5:43 AM, LORD GAGA said:

It doesn't come up for me whats the poster of? the only ones im currently looking to get is the giant promo ones used in cinemas for promo of 'A Star Is Born' but I feel like they'll be very rare if not impossible to get hold of. 

try the url in my signature on this post. its the perfect illusion street poster

Do YOU own the 4' by 6' Perfect Illusion promo Poster? Will pay you for it. Pic: http://i.imgur.com/UWuzumk
Link to post
Share on other sites

LORD GAGA
13 hours ago, ChicaSkas said:

try the url in my signature on this post. its the perfect illusion street poster

I can’t see the signature on mobile but I’ll have a look when I’m on my Mac 😊

 

Edit: Oh wow, I've never seen this before, it comes in 4 parts? If I ever see one on ebay etc I'll let you know.

Edited by LORD GAGA
Link to post
Share on other sites

StuckInMyMind

My collection up to now (I plan on resuming collecting soon)

The Fame

Just Dance (UK single) - Just Dance (7" vinyl) - Poker Face (UK single) - Poker Face (7" vinyl) - Poker Face (American Remixes) - Poker Face (Australian single) - Paparazzi (UK single) - Paparazzi (7" vinyl) - LoveGame (UK single) - LoveGame (7" vinyl) - LoveGame (German single) - Eh, Eh [Nothing Else I Can Say] (Australian single) - The Fame (UK edition)

The Fame Monster

Bad Romance (UK single) - Telephone (UK single) - Telephone (7" vinyl) - Alejandro (UK single) - The Fame Monster (2 disc EU) - The Fame Monster (American Gold Digipak) - The Fame Monster (Classic CD)

Born This Way

Born This Way (UK single) - Judas (UK single) - The Edge Of Glory (German single) - You & I (German single) - Marry The Night (German single) - Born This Way (UK standard release) - Born This Way (UK Deluxe)

ARTPOP

Applause (UK single) - ARTPOP (UK foil cover)

Joanne

Joanne (UK standard edition)

Fanmade CDs

Beautiful Dirty Rich (UK single) - Dance In The Dark (UK single) - Do What U Want (UK Single) - Perfect Illusion (UK single) - The Cure (UK single) - A Very Gaga Holiday (UK EP - in progress) 

I'm not sure if there's more, there probably is and I'll more than likely be working on more fanmade CDs over the next few weeks/months and I really want to start purchasing more rarities. If you'd like any pictures of my fanmade CDs, let me know and I'll post some :) 

Link to post
Share on other sites

StuckInMyMind

Does anybody have images of the HMV slipcase under and top? I don’t mean back and front, I literally mean the top and bottom spines :) 

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
RainingOnMe
On 8/1/2018 at 1:16 PM, GagaXCollection said:

Oh lol. This was supposed to be a private listing for someone that told me they were going to buy them but I guess it went to public instead. Anyone know how to fix this? :rip:

Anyway, I relisted this because it didn't sell. The Fame HMV slipcase in great condition for anyone interested:

https://www.ebay.com/itm/Lady-Gaga-The-Fame-HMV-Slipcase-Like-New-RARE-2009-Special-Edition-Interscope/153124352877

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share


×
×
  • Create New...