The Fame Monster lost?

[Massive Monster 2,213]

Do you remember Arcade Fire's 2011 album of the year grammy award winning album? 

It won against The Fame Monster. A new sounding creative synth pop giant stadium filling cultural phenomenon and arguably what cemented Gaga as an icon/legend, most influential person and most talked about person at the time. It wasn't just the crazy outfits, it was the music and performances. They were comparing her status to Madonna after only 3 years for crying out loud. That album and its songs are classics. 

My point is: yes we might be mad that Chromatica didn't get a nomination in AOTY and feel like she's being "snubbed" in the "major" categories, but... 

The Fame Monster lost 

America Exblain 

My real point is... don't worry girl. Chromatica is loved, successful and will be talked about for a while. It's Gaga. (Look how ARTPOP trended several times on Twitter not a long time ago way passed its release years before) 

And hopefully there's more to come in this era (prays for SFA and Replay as singles)

Voila 

[777777777777777777 18,871]

Mariah was so many times robbed she only got 5 Grammys but is a legend 

[LaLa 12,560]

13 minutes ago, Massive Monster said:

Do you remember Arcade Fire's 2011 album of the year grammy award winning album? 

It's actually one of my favourite albums, I love it so much 

I was truly truly conflicted that night

[sexy 2,297]

The Suburbs is a dope album, i wish TFM had won, but if any of those nominated albums was gonna beat it, I'm glad it was The Suburbs (and not Teenage Dream or Recovery lol)

[Massive Monster 2,213]

I probably need to listen to The Suburbs entirely. I know a few Arcade Fire songs.

I hope I don't sound like someone who only listens to Gaga, or "mainstream" and "pop" music 

But I think it's still interesting that TFM lost when we now see the longetivity. 

It really puts things into perspective.

[Regina George 52,525]

[KNJ 4,051]

On 11/24/2020 at 5:44 PM, Massive Monster said:

I probably need to listen to The Suburbs entirely. I know a few Arcade Fire songs.

I hope I don't sound like someone who only listens to Gaga, or "mainstream" and "pop" music 

But I think it's still interesting that TFM lost when we now see the longetivity. 

It really puts things into perspective.

Yeah this was a shocker. Not because they aren't good but it's just another in the history of wtf Grammys?! moments. The question is: if all these albums were voted into that category, what exactly was the criteria that gave Arcade the edge? As an NYT put it, the Grammys like "old-sounding youngs", critical acclaim or popularity be damned. Wasn't it the next year Beck won over Kanye and even Beck was like what? 

Edit:

@Massive Monster sorry, the bold words got spellchecked wrong 

Edited November 25, 2020 by KNJ

[Blastertoyo 19,110]

this video explains my feelings perfectly 

[Anderson123 12,228]

And she still won 3 Grammys that night. One for Pop Vocal Album and 2 for Bad Romance which is pretty huge in my opinion. I'm glad it lost to Arcade Fire and not Katy Perry.

[KNJ 4,051]

On 11/24/2020 at 6:06 PM, Blastertoyo said:

this video explains my feelings perfectly 

Exactly! What is it that they want to reward? Cuz Arcade lost both of their genre album and genre performance noms (both snatched up by The Black Keys). There HAS to be a flaw(s) in the process if an album  can lose best album, best recording in their genre and all technical awards; but somehow still be crowned the best album released in ALL of music in that ENTIRE year?  

The same problem with the Oscars: how the ever loving hell is Greenbook the height of excellence in all of cinema in 2018?!? 

Edited November 26, 2020 by KNJ

[GagaSine 3,537]

I love Arcade Fire so i’m not mad lol

but ppl need to understand award shows do not follow a scientific method, ‘best’ has a general definition and awards are not handed out on merit alone. There is a lot of other factors.

it’s like the judging on drag race, the queen that wins/loses is not necessarily the best/worst. Things like attitude, personality, history, societal implications, trends, etc are all considered, and not the same way all the time

Once you understand this awards also feel less important/meaningful.

Edited November 26, 2020 by GagaSine

[Agunimon 8,638]

Sorry, but The Suburbs was a solid body of work and her losing to it has me unbothered.

[Quartz 10,715]

I mean, she got snubbed so many times that it doesn't make sense in hindsight. It's just the norm. Grammy voters are not forward-thinking enough, and even 10 years in, they still underestimate Gaga. Lmao, losing the major Grammy for Shallow was one of the biggest blunders. It's still effing charting and will continue to do so for years to come. 

[Justin Drew Bieber 12,876]

The Fame Monster WAS the album of the year, better music too, it was a movement 

[Justin Drew Bieber 12,876]

6 minutes ago, Quartz said:

I mean, she got snubbed so many times that it doesn't make sense in hindsight. It's just the norm. Grammy voters are not forward-thinking enough, and even 10 years in, they still underestimate Gaga. Lmao, losing the major Grammy for Shallow was one of the biggest blunders. It's still effing charting and will continue to do so for years to come. 

I thought they were gonna make up for that by letting ARUTW get the SOTY Grammy earlier this year but they just used her for ratings