911 or Free Woman ??

[Roxanne 591]

911 in every way 

[JustJames 993]

Honestly, neither has a shot at getting enough airplay to make moves on the Hot 100; Free Woman already had premium playlisting support near album release and still failed to gain traction, so the next “single” should be a song that can grab enough attention digitally to boost its streams in the short-term, while also having a trickling impact on album streams and finally, retaining some of that boost indefinitely (see: John Wayne having the highest non-single recurrent streams off Joanne still). That seems to be 911, which will at least give the era a unique, thematically appropriate track supported by visuals and promo. An MV with Chromatica II > 911 and live performances will get enough buzz to boost it to ~500k/day IMO.

I really wish Replay was considered since it’s a more sophisticated take on the issues 911 addresses; the lyrics are deeper, fuller, and the chorus hits harder. It’d be great if she could release Replay as a promo single shortly after and do performances of both as Mental Health Awareness Month / World Mental Health Day (October) approach. 

[Twitter 14]

Neither. 

[Chromatican 4,046]

911 please, Free Woman demo version would've been a great lead or single, but the album version is far too generic for me to want as a single. 911 is fresh and a 911 visual would undoubtedly be more inspired.

[GenericPhag 143]

If the GP thought that SL and ROM were generic, they won't even bother listening to FW. 911 is riskier but ultimately better as a single and as a song 

[jajagaga1896 89]

So months ago I would have said "Free Woman," thought it would be a great Gaga single and perfect for radio and the current times. Always loved 911 more, but did not feel it would be perceived well by the GP for a single. After the VMAS, I am ready for 911 as a single and I actually think it could do quite good and be a little bit of an experimental single for Gaga.

[Daylight Jokers 14,958]

Enigma

[Chromatica Island 8,517]

7 hours ago, Biggest Bitch said:

911 is the only correct answer 

Fixed it!

[Chromatica Island 8,517]

911 obviously! Free Woman is good too!

[Jollibee 3,179]

I love both. But I would go for 911 but if they did not tweaked FW that much, I'd go for FW. I really love the FW sample.

[pop ate my heart 2,865]

911 third single

Free Woman promo single

both with a mv 

MANIFESTING

[pop ate my heart 2,865]

6 hours ago, JustJames said:

Honestly, neither has a shot at getting enough airplay to make moves on the Hot 100; Free Woman already had premium playlisting support near album release and still failed to gain traction, so the next “single” should be a song that can grab enough attention digitally to boost its streams in the short-term, while also having a trickling impact on album streams and finally, retaining some of that boost indefinitely (see: John Wayne having the highest non-single recurrent streams off Joanne still). That seems to be 911, which will at least give the era a unique, thematically appropriate track supported by visuals and promo. An MV with Chromatica II > 911 and live performances will get enough buzz to boost it to ~500k/day IMO.

I really wish Replay was considered since it’s a more sophisticated take on the issues 911 addresses; the lyrics are deeper, fuller, and the chorus hits harder. It’d be great if she could release Replay as a promo single shortly after and do performances of both as Mental Health Awareness Month / World Mental Health Day (October) approach. 

omg who cares about sales after the numbers she did with sl, rom and the entire album  music not the bling yall

[PartySick 160,876]

I see the bias. You capitalized Free Woman but not 911

Anyway, I'm team Free Woman  I literally can't get that song out of my head. It's my ringtone, the demo is my alarm, and it's in my morning Spotify playlist

[pop ate my heart 2,865]

2 minutes ago, PartySick said:

I see the bias. You capitalized Free Woman but not 911

how can you capitalize numbers lmao you trollin

[Chromatica Island 8,517]

6 hours ago, JustJames said:

Honestly, neither has a shot at getting enough airplay to make moves on the Hot 100; Free Woman already had premium playlisting support near album release and still failed to gain traction, so the next “single” should be a song that can grab enough attention digitally to boost its streams in the short-term, while also having a trickling impact on album streams and finally, retaining some of that boost indefinitely (see: John Wayne having the highest non-single recurrent streams off Joanne still). That seems to be 911, which will at least give the era a unique, thematically appropriate track supported by visuals and promo. An MV with Chromatica II > 911 and live performances will get enough buzz to boost it to ~500k/day IMO.

I really wish Replay was considered since it’s a more sophisticated take on the issues 911 addresses; the lyrics are deeper, fuller, and the chorus hits harder. It’d be great if she could release Replay as a promo single shortly after and do performances of both as Mental Health Awareness Month / World Mental Health Day (October) approach. 

You're a chartster aren't you?