So where are BLACKPINK’s writing credits

[RAMROD 109,377]

IDK about other K-Pop acts, but for YG Artists, they usually only able to write after certain years of tenure. Just like some BIGBANG members (mainly G-D) and CL.

 

[GGDisbetter 2,187]

YG has a history of removing blackpink's writting credits (eg. Stay and Solo) 

[elijahfan 26,093]

All K-Pop groups are manufactured by the same writers and producers... The girls have never written a line in their lives.

What Gaga said wasn't misleading tho: she did ask them for their input and sent the song to their camp for it to be reviewed, and what they sent back is what ended up on the record. It just happens to be written by the same guy who writes all of their songs... Had they all been in the same room together, maybe things could have been different, but that's how K-Pop works.

[TWICE on hatius 4,746]

9 minutes ago, elijahfan said:

All K-Pop groups are manufactured by the same writers and producers... The girls have never written a line in their lives

Please, not this dumb ass sh!t again. There are many groups like GIDLE, TWICE, EXID, BIG BANG, BTS and a bunch of other groups write/produce their own music. Y'all need to stop generalizing the entire kpop industry especially you have only ever heard only 3 kpop songs in entire life.

[Bubblegum Bitch 18,934]

3 minutes ago, TWICE said:

especially you have only ever heard only 3 kpop songs in entire life.

Does Sour Candy and Kiss and Makeup count? 

[elijahfan 26,093]

7 minutes ago, TWICE said:

Please, not this dumb ass sh!t again. There are many groups like GIDLE, TWICE, EXID, BIG BANG, BTS and a bunch of other groups write/produce their own music. Y'all need to stop generalizing the entire kpop industry especially you have only ever heard only 3 kpop songs in entire life.

There are always exceptions to every situation, but you can't deny this is how the K-Pop industry works. It sure is true for BLACKPINK.

Also, don't make assumptions about people simply because they don't share your view of things. K-Pop is vastly problematic in its functioning whether you like it or not.

[Lighter 15,376]

6 minutes ago, elijahfan said:

There are always exceptions to every situation, but you can't deny this is how the K-Pop industry works. It sure is true for BLACKPINK.

Their contract is ending in months I hope they know the decisions to make now

[Guest]

1 hour ago, Brecht said:

There's an interview they did in the states where the guy is asking them about each song and how the process was, what did they mean by the lyrics, and they were like "yeah our producer did it and we sang it " to every song 

That was their interview on the Zach Sang Show. So awkward. haha

[TWICE on hatius 4,746]

38 minutes ago, elijahfan said:

There are always exceptions to every situation, but you can't deny this is how the K-Pop industry works. It sure is true for BLACKPINK.

Do you want me to list more kpop idols can write or produce their music so we can stop this "exception" excuse? I can. Here's a link: https://onehallyu.com/topic/41452-masterlist-of-songwritercomposer-k-pop-artists/

Both of blackpink's senior groups 2EN1 and BIGBANG both write their own music. 2EN1 rival, who is Girls Generation also writes their own music. 

Back to how kpop industry works? If you are willing to have a large platform like YG or SM, who have a reputation of consistent product's quality, there is a strict quality control. Also, Idols can always submit their work, which doesn't mean it is going to be approved or funded (similar to western ones). 

Smaller companies nowadays have created more opportunities for idols to write and produce their own songs since IT IS LESS COSTLY. 

[TWICE on hatius 4,746]

1 hour ago, elijahfan said:

K-Pop is vastly problematic in its functioning whether you like it or not.

So is western one. 

But Kpop should be a specific target for yall to criticize. 

[LOVEDRUG 10,649]

21 minutes ago, elijahfan said:

There are always exceptions to every situation, but you can't deny this is how the K-Pop industry works. It sure is true for BLACKPINK.

Also, don't make assumptions about people simply because they don't share your view of things. K-Pop is vastly problematic in its functioning whether you like it or not.

the exception is k-pop artists who DON'T write their own music, not the other way around. are you someone who has genuinely researched and looked into this, or someone who's been told that k-pop idols are robots and therefore believe it? blackpink have written songs, many times, but just have been prevented from recording and releasing them, it's sad, but it doesn't mean they don't write. the ratio of writing artists to non-writing artists is more or less the same as the western industry. stop generalizing about something you clearly have no idea about, when a vast majority of k-pop idols do write or produce their own work.

[LOVEDRUG 10,649]

7 minutes ago, TWICE said:

Do you want me to list more kpop idols can write or produce their music so we can stop this "exception" excuse? I can.

Both of blackpink's senior groups 2EN1 any BIGBANG both write their own music. 2EN1 rival, who is Girls Generation also writes their own music. 

Back to how kpop industry works? If you are willing to have a large platform like YG or SM, who have a reputation of consistent product's quality, there is a strict quality control. Also, Idols can always submit their work, which doesn't mean it is going to be approved. Smaller companies nowadays have created more opportunities for idols to write and produce their own songs since IT IS LESS COSTLY. 

even then, many sm and yg groups do produce their own music (just see exo, bigbang, 2ne1, nct). it's a blatant lie by western stans that they don't create their own music, and a vast majority in fact do make their own music. you're right about pretty much everything, i especially agree on the point about allowing idols from smaller companies to write themselves because it's cheaper. 

[A Fried Egg 8,834]

YG should let BP study songwriting from Lady Gaga. She’s one of the best. 

[elijahfan 26,093]

49 minutes ago, TWICE said:

Back to how kpop industry works? If you are willing to have a large platform like YG or SM, who have a reputation of consistent product's quality, there is a strict quality control.

[elijahfan 26,093]

45 minutes ago, Autumn said:

blackpink have written songs, many times, but just have been prevented from recording and releasing them