What do y'all think was ARTPOP tracklist in gagas vision before her label

[regina tuturor 2]

And what demos

[Chesescake 4,291]

Maybe it's something super cool, maybe it's avant-garde, live changing even.

But this version is what we got in the end.
Aaaaand as much as I want a fresh spin for the album, it's looks like we will never get anything new.

So I'll probably just keep munching on those fan remixes, better than the original anyway.

Edited October 14 by Chesescake

[gagzus 28,078]

I think this is in the wrong section babe you want Gaga Thoughts and the Question tag.

But, we do know Brooklyn Nights was competing for Mary Jane Holland’s place, and Partynauseous was either going to be a single for ARTPOP or Kendrick Lamar. 

Then of course we has Ratchet and Red Flame, Temple, Onion Girl, Tinnitus and probably Hallelujah (although I’m sure that was either actually a Temple demo or a demo for Zedd’s second album originally.)

 

[regina tuturor 2]

40 minutes ago, gagzus said:

I think this is in the wrong section babe you want Gaga Thoughts and the Question tag.

But, we do know Brooklyn Nights was competing for Mary Jane Holland’s place, and Partynauseous was either going to be a single for ARTPOP or Kendrick Lamar. 

Then of course we has Ratchet and Red Flame, Temple, Onion Girl, Tinnitus and probably Hallelujah (although I’m sure that was either actually a Temple demo or a demo for Zedd’s second album originally.)

 

Yea sorry i am new on this site idk how it worksa😭😭😭😭

[regina tuturor 2]

54 minutes ago, Chesescake said:

Maybe it's something super cool, maybe it's avant-garde, live changing even.

But this version is what we got in the end.
Aaaaand as much as I want a fresh spin for the album, it's looks like we will never get anything new.

So I'll probably just keep munching on those fan remixes, better than the original anyway.

Yeaa

[River 130,215]

It's pretty much this + Brooklyn Night.. most of the demos never really became something and they are just instrumentals.

[TimotheeChalamet 7,210]

I think the only two tracks that would be different would be Tea (she presented it herself by saying it was on ARTPOP) and Brooklyn Nights. Partynauseous was rejected and made fun of by Kendrick Lamar's team

Edited October 14 by TimotheeChalamet

[MadArchitect 1,571]

according to Gaga, that's her vision, which was everchanging as the creative process was going on, the label intervenes after she presents it to them to handle the roll out, marketing and distribution. So if you didn't like the tracklisting, that's Gaga to blame lol

Edited October 14 by MadArchitect

[gagzus 28,078]

37 minutes ago, regina tuturor said:

Yea sorry i am new on this site idk how it worksa😭😭😭😭

That’s ok no big deal diva! Just so you know for next time  

[gagzus 28,078]

27 minutes ago, TimotheeChalamet said:

I think the only two tracks that would be different would be Tea (she presented it herself by saying it was on ARTPOP) and Brooklyn Nights. Partynauseous was rejected and made fun of by Kendrick Lamar's team

The crazy thing I always find ridiculous is how HORRID rap fans are towards Gaga’a version of BDKMV online. I think it’s honestly just down to homophobia because they say she sounds bad and the album version sounds better when the “singer” on the album version is barely singing and it’s TERRIBLY mixed with Kendrick trying to sing it too.

Based on how she praised her collaborators for J&D for not being homophobic, and how badly Kendrick’s teams have spoken about Gaga’s voice and sound, plus the fact they’ve never seen, spoken to nor acknowledged each other ever again—it’s pretty obvious homophobia played massively into it not happening. Same for how Kanye’s team infamously wanted her to be “more sexy and less gay” for their joint tour.

Edited October 14 by gagzus

[regina tuturor 2]

I asked bc i heard ARTPOP almost had 25 songs(idk if its real) and that she had this image for ARTPOP of decay of the blonde and disney princess yea

[CYCLOPS 6,575]

Honestly I don't think the vision was ever that clear. She was high out of her mind and depressed the whole time and was going for this art kid highbrow schtick that didn't land because she wasn't in control of her output (also because of external cause as we know). I still love the album. But I don't think it would have been that much different even if the era went as planned

[gagzus 28,078]

19 minutes ago, regina tuturor said:

I asked bc i heard ARTPOP almost had 25 songs(idk if its real) and that she had this image for ARTPOP of decay of the blonde and disney princess yea

She did mention those themes over the time she started making it.

[regina tuturor 2]

3 minutes ago, gagzus said:

She did mention those themes over the time she started making it.

Ohh okayy thank uu

[regina tuturor 2]

5 minutes ago, CYCLOPS said:

Honestly I don't think the vision was ever that clear. She was high out of her mind and depressed the whole time and was going for this art kid highbrow schtick that didn't land because she wasn't in control of her output (also because of external cause as we know). I still love the album. But I don't think it would have been that much different even if the era went as planned

Yea true