Gaga CONSTRUCTIVE Criticism Thread

[xoxo Craig 55,649]

I wish she'd communicate with us more often. And do some live concerts from her home

[Aphrodizy26 6]

56 minutes ago, Miss Dolly said:

ROM is a song about alcohol dependency. She is saying she would rather be dry (not drinking) however she is still drinking however thankful she is alive

Is it about alcohol dependency at face value? Because i always took it as a metaphor of rain. Taking control of the situations life throws at you. She’d rather not be in the rainfall, but she’s still alive and pushing through. Hence the daggers... 

Can’t Alcohol Dependency be what the song is about, just not so literally? 

[Aphrodizy26 6]

DELETECKFKFKG

[herassisfamous 1,405]

stop being so perfect bb they keep expecting more from u. ily so much try to be easy on urself. there are some bloodsuckers out there, they are not ur true audience 💕

[SCHEISSEMONTRE 2,783]

3 hours ago, adamsenigma said:

trap, r&b or modern day pop

I can see her doing another track like DWUW but not anything like JnD or mainstream trap stuff. modern day pop (most of the time) sounds generic and lifeless.

[Guest]

2 hours ago, alicefromabove said:

The queen of flopping miserably on the charts and hasnt had a hit single since.. the early 2010's? 

fixedt

2 hours ago, Thwack said:

Moore. 

omg yes id love a lady gaga x demi moore movie 

[zebrastripes 969]

A lot of songs on Chromatica really lacked that big punch we were all looking for. I think everyone has said what I would agree on, like really wish Gaga would do what she wanted without listening to fans / record labels and she explored versatility a little more again. Like how she constantly found a new voice + production + melodies, etc, if she kept on going like that, she'd still be constantly transforming. Keep experimenting no matter how old you are.

And another criticism: I'm noticing a pattern of her repeating history (and I remember reading she wanted to have Chromatica be like 90's dance) and it's becoming a bit predictable as to what she's doing.

And another criticism: It seems like the last-minute tweaking of everything and mixing has everything sounding like patterns she's done before (structure, melodies, etc).

[Animal Claws 18,665]

10 minutes ago, zebrastripes said:

A lot of songs on Chromatica really lacked that big punch we were all looking for. I think everyone has said what I would agree on, like really wish Gaga would do what she wanted without listening to fans / record labels and she explored versatility a little more again. Like how she constantly found a new voice + production + melodies, etc, if she kept on going like that, she'd still be constantly transforming. Keep experimenting no matter how old you are.

And another criticism: I'm noticing a pattern of her repeating history (and I remember reading she wanted to have Chromatica be like 90's dance) and it's becoming a bit predictable as to what she's doing.

And another criticism: It seems like the last-minute tweaking of everything and mixing has everything sounding like patterns she's done before (structure, melodies, etc).

She already did C2C, Joanne and ASIB in a row and everyone complained. 

Let her back to her roots for once.

[REALITY 76,308]

4 hours ago, Loeppke said:

Controversial opinion: from what I understand, Chromatica was limited to album time length (in the same way ARTPOP was limited to number of tracks), which is the reason why we received abridged versions of many songs. I would have rather seen a shorter tracklist if it meant some of the best songs would sound more fulfilled. It also sounds like we are going to get a sequel anyway, so if she wanted these songs out then all of the songs would have their chance at some point. But many of the songs sound cut short, and that's my main complaint after I've had weeks to listen to the album.

Where did you see that the album length was limited? This is the first time I'm hearing this info. 

[REALITY 76,308]

4 hours ago, monster said:

i would've rather gotten an 8 track album like TFM tbh

No you wouldn't

Y'all would get bored of it so much quicker than some of y'all got bored with Chromatica. 

[Guest]

4 minutes ago, M Monstre said:

No you wouldn't

Y'all would get bored of it so much quicker than some of y'all got bored with Chromatica. 

i literally listen to tfm every day

i havent even listened to chromatica in full yet  i've only listened to each song about a handful of times

[Ronk 14,762]

Take a break with no scheduled end date.  Take time to heal and enjoy life.  Don't think about what others want from you, but do what makes you happy.  Then, when the urge hits you to go back to creating and entertaining, you'll be doing it because that is what will make you happy at that time.

[REALITY 76,308]

99% of you guys don't know what "constructive criticism" is  

Most of these are just lists about what you personally want her to do with her career  

EDIT - Also, some of y'all are literally saying "Gaga needs to stop listening to her fans," and "Gaga needs to do x, y, and z" in the same post  Like what is it? Does she listen to y'all or not? 

[REALITY 76,308]

1 minute ago, monster said:

i literally listen to tfm every day

i havent even listened to chromatica in full yet  i've only listened to each song about a handful of times

But imagine the meltdowns this site would have if Gaga's next solo dance pop album after ARTPOP was only 8 tracks long  

I mean, I wouldn't necessarily be meltdowning over it, but you know some people here would've  And most of them probably would've already moved on from Chromatica within the first week if that were the case. 

[Guest]

Just now, M Monstre said:

But imagine the meltdowns this site would have if Gaga's next solo dance pop album after ARTPOP was only 8 tracks long  

I mean, I wouldn't necessarily be meltdowning over it, but you know some people here would've  And most of them probably would've already moved on from Chromatica within the first week if that were the case. 

quality over quantity darling

 

and oops