Jump to content
question

Unpopular opinions: Chromatica


Blackout19

Featured Posts

jorja

911 is overrated

1000 doves is underrated

babylon and free woman are way better than the demos

:lana:

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 75
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Spyro
1 minute ago, NFRockwell said:

Some of y’all are kinda forgetting this album is suppose to sound dated/“familiar” :selena: it sounds dated isn’t really a diss or unpopular opinion, it’s just true. 

Like kee Idk what little  monsters expected when it's been stated a thousand times it's being inspired of a genre 30 years ago :selena: 

Spyro the Dragon
Link to post
Share on other sites

Spyro
4 minutes ago, HybridAT said:

Way overrated. Louder for the people in the back

The album version fits the album vibe so much better than the loud, grating HL production. It's like she found the happiest corner in her mind and made a song out of it. It's stunning 👌

Perfect album closer IMO

TOOK THE WORDS OUT M Y MOUTH.  When I found out Bloodpop was pissed people were harassing him for the HL version, I found out this fanbase has NO TASTE. :selena: 

Bloodpop explained it beautifully why they chose that version..

Spyro the Dragon
Link to post
Share on other sites

NFRatwell
3 minutes ago, Spyro said:

Like kee Idk what little  monsters expected when it's been stated a thousand times it's being inspired of a genre 30 years ago :selena: 

Gaga: album is really 90s house influenced, we wanted to stick to that sound and add some EDM also

Monsters: did she just say she’s making a whole new genre that will rule the 20s! :poot:

Link to post
Share on other sites

DiamondAngel

1. Stupid Love is a great song

2. Sine From Above is great but I expected way more from a Gaga-Elton collab. 

3. 1000 Doves Piano would make a great single especially for the audience she got with MR/Shallow

4. The Haus Labs instrumental sounds amazing but I’m not sure if it would fit Babylon very well. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

BABYL0N

SL is the only skip

Chromatica I, II, III are highlights on the album something would be missed without them:lana:

Plastic Doll is treated unfairly by the fanbase :neyde:

Babylon is really a ****ing grower and now that I got into this one I think the HL version is not on this album for a reason 

Replay could have easlily been a Joanne track with a country arrangement, Idk It reminds me of Not Fair by Lily Allen at the beginning :laughga:

The bridge of Alice is everything 

Fun Tonight has a male background voice in the pre-chorus that reminded me of the male voice in the Bad Romance demo chorus

Link to post
Share on other sites

Chic

Chromatica II into 911 is a horrible transition, it sounds exactly like the intro to baby shark. Really. Listen to it. There's no enjoying it after hearing that

Enigma is the best song on the album

Link to post
Share on other sites

Enigma

Sine From Above is her most touching song off her main albums 

Stupid Love is amazing when you listen to it from the album 

Babylon stands out more the way it is than if it was the Haus Labs version

Replay could have been part of TFM and you’d all live for it

Sour Candy is a ****ing bop

Rain on Me is in her top 3/5 MVs

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Spyro
3 minutes ago, NFRockwell said:

Gaga: album is really 90s house influenced, we wanted to stick to that sound and add some EDM also

Monsters: did she just say she’s making a whole new genre that will rule the 20s! :poot:

43v7vx.jpg

 

Spyro the Dragon
Link to post
Share on other sites

ToxicHot
1 minute ago, JohnWayne said:

Replay could have easlily been a Joanne track with a country arrangement, Idk It reminds me of Not Fair by Lily Allen at the beginning :laughga:

Replay with a country arrangement :deadbanana: funny idea, but I can't see it lol

dOnT sAd ReAcT mE 2 bE sHaDy i WiLL RePoRt U!!1!
Link to post
Share on other sites

DirrtyPony

Replay is my only skip on the album.

Fun Tonight and Plastic Doll are underrated.

Babylon is one of Gaga's best songs, period.

Strung out for another taste
Link to post
Share on other sites

intotherosegarden

Haus Labs Babylon is not that good and would have felt tacked on as the closer. The album version fits the overall soundscape of Chromatica way better. If it is released I will definitely see it as a remix instead of an 'alternate version'.

A visual album/videos for all tracks would detract from its mystery and could feel forced or really run the aesthetic out. A short film on the other hand a'la Florence + the Machine's Oddyssey (not featuring all the album tracks and having a few done differently) could work.

Stupid Love's video should have had more of the Rain on Me/Album Art aesthetic. It doesmt fitnaith the album visually and feels a bit standalone. I was envisioning a heavily 90s Japan influenced album based off the video and its promo.

The symbols do not have meaning outside of the Stupid Love video. If they did we would have seen the white one utilized in Rain on Me and not have a totally new symbol that isn't shown anywhere else; even in the album.

Link to post
Share on other sites

CautiousLurker
29 minutes ago, Blackout19 said:

1. Rain On Me is the best song on the album and this is one of the best song from Gaga

2. Free Woman is a masterpiece

3. I don't like 911

4. Stupid Love worst song

 

No
No
:bradley:
Correct :enigma:

Men are naturally more dominating, aggressive, and logical thinking because we have balls.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Monster7
8 minutes ago, Enigma said:

Sine From Above is her most touching song off her main albums 

Stupid Love is amazing when you listen to it from the album 

Babylon stands out more the way it is than if it was the Haus Labs version

Replay could have been part of TFM and you’d all live for it

Sour Candy is a ****ing bop

Rain on Me is in her top 3/5 MVs

 

Facts right there:applause: I agree with every point

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...