"Sine from above" was intented for Elton only 7 years ago

[KURUSHITOVSKA 20,451]

1 hour ago, Sneaky said:

"7 years ago"

Yeah, it shows

Like don't even @ me, it sounds dated no matter how you cut it lol. 

But dated doesn't automatically mean BAD either, so..

Dated but still one of Gaga's best songs ever PERIOD.

[ice bear 1]

13 minutes ago, bleed dior said:

Your avi is so cute.

uh... thanks

[bionic 48,186]

Elton should've been replaced. The song is 🔥 but is vocals are not great

[KURUSHITOVSKA 20,451]

1 minute ago, bionic said:

Elton should've been replaced. The song is 🔥 but is vocals are not great

His vocals are amazing. Isn't he like 70? What do you expect.

[Thonin Dyn 2,653]

1 hour ago, Guillaume Hamon said:

Rolling Stone magazine made a Chromatica review that features comments from Axwell, Ben rice, Bloodpop and more.  

Axwell himself explains that "Sine from above" was supposed to be an Elton and Axwell collab' so they worked on it 7 years ago but it never went the way they wanted it to be + he had a hard time joining Elton so it was never used.

That's when gaga decided to bring axwell on the album that he thought that she knew him well so he sent the track to gaga and bloodpop who loved it and that's how the unknown vintage track arrived on Chromatica.

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/lady-gaga-chromatica-1007057/

THANKS GOD ELTON WAS BUSY OR NOT FULLY PLEASED WITH THE SONG BACK THEN CAUSE IT'S ONE OF THE ALBUM GEMS IF NOT ITS BEST TRACK.  

So in order to have SFA on the album we had to get Axwell, there’s always a part of loosing in winning I guess

[bionic 48,186]

2 minutes ago, KURUSHITOVSKA said:

His vocals are amazing. Isn't he like 70? What do you expect.

I expect better vocals. He doesn't sound that mixed on his own recent albums

[GagaUnderYou 4,977]

I wouldn't say dated is the right word. It's more of bringing back a style of music. Chromatica is refreshing for me, not her best work but I appreciate it. 

Sine From Above is one of my favorites on the album, and I did not expect that AT ALL. 

[BleepBloop 10,316]

10 minutes ago, KURUSHITOVSKA said:

Dated but still one of Gaga's best songs ever PERIOD.

Exactly, we can have BOTH

[Alphaz 7,955]

Thank God for the rejection Elton and Axwell. 

This gem of song finally fell in Gaga's hands

[Guillaume Hamon 6,237]

1 hour ago, Teal Ambition said:

Did they remove this from the article? I dont see it

 

1 hour ago, Kermit the frog said:

Can someone post the full review here? I can't seem to find the rest of the text...

 

1 hour ago, PatrickMonster said:

sorry am I the only one who cant see this in the link he posted?

 

The article is only partially available when I read it on my laptop but fully available when I check it on my phone. Maybe it will help!  

I connect to GGD on my laptop so I can't copy paste the article here sadly.  

 

1 hour ago, PatrickMonster said:

or everybody just believed what the OP is saying?

You wouldn't have tens of people believing what I say without questioning me a bit more if there was no proof for it. And why would I make a story up? To get GGD attention? ^^ I love the site but I don't care if I have plenty of likes or none. I shared the info cause I was shook and that's it.  

[2School4Cool 6,397]

Honestly it’s my favorite song on the album along with Fun Tonight! I would have loved it if it came from Elton 7 years ago but I’m so glad it made its way to Chromatica because they sound stunning together and it’s one of Gaga’s best tracks to date. 

[Mr Oak 7,562]

Do they mean the instrumental  or  the whole "Sine" thing too?

[Guillaume Hamon 6,237]

39 minutes ago, NoahSuns said:

Do they mean the instrumental  or  the whole "Sine" thing too?

They don't give more details but since many other co-writers/producers were added after gaga took it, I guess it was just an instrumental that and her team built on or a finished song they reworked quite a lot.  

[ladygaga1984 175]

The song is a hot euro trash song that should have never have made the cut. I mean, it makes sense in an Elton’s album that no one cares about, but it’s just not good enough for a Gaga album. I really dislike the song. 

[Guest]

6 hours ago, moonsago said:

I love it but I still skip the end, its the one part I do not understand lol

I LOVE the drum and bass ending, it gives me strong "passing away and seeing your life flashing before your eyes" vibe