Jump to content
opinion

Madonna - Rebel Heart (Album) Bop or Flop?


Delusional

Rebel Heart   

64 members have voted

  1. 1. Bop or Flop?

    • Bop
      54
    • Flop
      10


Featured Posts

  • Replies 34
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Just now, Yxcvbnm said:

I'm a big fan of M, but MDNA was a disaster. A real flop. Of course, there are good tracks on it, Girl Gone Wild or Masterpiece, but... The rest is trash.

Rebel Heart is so so underrated. That album is very cool, well produced and the ballads are really beautiful. Everyone knows Bitch I'm Madonna.

Ghosttown, Messiah, Heartbreak City, Inside Out, Best Night, Devil Pray, Wash All Over Me, Living For Love, Holy Water, Veni Vidi Vici - BOP without a doubt. Highlights.

You right MDNA was a flop artistically(especially when you compare this album to her previous, but still good pop album tho), but not commercially, it's her best selling album from 10s.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Antonio
4 minutes ago, Antonio said:

Very bad album 

In comparison to her others that is... it has some cute songs but overall not my cup of tea:coffee:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Davian
5 minutes ago, Yxcvbnm said:

I'm a big fan of M, but MDNA was a disaster. A real flop. Of course, there are good tracks on it, Girl Gone Wild or Masterpiece, but... The rest is trash.

I personally love MDNA:poot: It has so much bops and is a great workout album. Not one of her best, but I prefer it over Debut and LAV for example.

What you want Lady Gaga🥂 What you want with Christina🥂
Link to post
Share on other sites

Blown Away

Half bop, half flop.

1. Living For Love - bop

2. Devil Pray - bop

3. Ghosttown - Her best song from the 10s

4. Unapologetic B - flop

5. Illuminati - flop

6. B I'm Madonna - flop

7. Hold Tight - bop

8. Joan Of Arc - bop

9. Iconic - flop

10. Heartbreak City - bop

11. Body Shop - flop

12. Holy Water - bop

13. Inside Out - bop

14. Wash All Over Me - bop

15. Best Night - bop

16. Veni Vidi Vici - flop

17. SEX - flop

18. Messiah - flop

19. Rebel Heart - bop

20. Autotune Baby - the pinnacle of flops

 

It seems the bop side wins narrowly 11-9 :party:

They shipped it, but it got shipped back
Link to post
Share on other sites

I could go for ever. Probably my favourite M album. Rebel Heart, Ven Vidi Vici, Inside Out, Living For Love, Unapologetic Bitch, Holy Water, Devil Pray, Hold Tight, Joan of Arc, HeartBreakCity. Not a big fan of Wash All Over Me and Body Shop - I tend to skip them

Link to post
Share on other sites

Butters Stotch

It has good songs, but also MANY fillers, it's unnecessarily long, she could've just kept 12 songs and I'm sure it would've been much better as an album:

1. Living for love

2. Devil pray

3. Ghosttwon

4. Unapologetic b*tch

5. Illuminati

6. Hold tight

7. Joan of Arc

8. Body shop

9. Holy water

10. Veni vidi vici

11. Messiah

12. Rebel heart

The fact that she decided to keep B*tch I'? Madonna and Iconic on the album makes me sick. Worst songs ever!!!!

FIND YOUR FREEDOM IN THE MUSIC
Link to post
Share on other sites

shoful

Rebel Heart is definitely a bop! It’s the album that got me interested in her and I really liked the album upon release. I wouldn’t consider it one of my top fav albums from her but it is definitely one that I go back to often if i wanna dance. 
 

I still think Madame X is her best album except for Erotica. These 2 are truly masterpieces 

"My name is Dita, I'll be your Mistress tonight..."
Link to post
Share on other sites

Butters Stotch
33 minutes ago, shoful said:

Rebel Heart is definitely a bop! It’s the album that got me interested in her and I really liked the album upon release. I wouldn’t consider it one of my top fav albums from her but it is definitely one that I go back to often if i wanna dance. 
 

I still think Madame X is her best album except for Erotica. These 2 are truly masterpieces 

I agree on Madame X being one of her best. It's lyrically what you would expect from a mature woman, and I don't say this in an offensive way, what I mean is that  after everything she's lived as the biggest female pop star in history, you would expect her to have lyrical power, that she would put out meaningful music, and Madame X really accomplishes that, unlike any of her albums since American Life. She had almost 20 years to experiment with sound and to make dance music and be as immature as she could. It was time to put out a meaningful album and I completely think she did.

FIND YOUR FREEDOM IN THE MUSIC
Link to post
Share on other sites

Rat Boy
1 hour ago, Aarghya said:

Many years from now Autotune Baby will be seen as a pop cultural phenomenon. Not everybody has refined musical taste and that is okay. Some people are just more intelligent and musically inclined than others. Xtina couldn't have said it better:

tumblr_o4engvzZph1ql5yr7o1_500.gif

"****ing rat" - @Dynamite
Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...