Is Gaga on Madonna & Britney’s level in terms of Pop Royalty/ Legend?

[TropicOfCANCER 6,292]

18 minutes ago, Smother Em Eh said:

Her stans sure like to boast about how she’s some Pop Legend. I personally don’t think she’s on Madonna or Gaga’s level AT ALL and I don’t think she’s as legendary as people think she is. She certainly has some bops though and cemented her place in pop culture. 

this. britney has a legacy, but only bc she's part and parcel to the general 90s pop movement, which was a collective moment in pop culture. she didn't really stand the test of time. only her stans truly believe she's a legend. 

[Rio 5,088]

2 minutes ago, shame said:

I've always been curious to know what MJ would have thought about Gaga's career had he still been alive. What did he say exactly about her before he died?

Can't remember. Just remember it being something that was on the cards, that he was heavily eyeing her to open the This Is It tour back in 2009. I might have to do a little research, I read that years ago. Tbh, to be admired by and eyed up by the King of Pop and to piss off the Queen of Pop so early in your career, you've gotta have something special and legend-like about you 🤣💗

[Brecht 7]

1 minute ago, TropicOfCANCER said:

not madonna, but sorry...she's far exceeded britney. britney's career was really only 1999-2003, and then a brief (hype-based) comeback in 2009-2011. 

I agree with this. Gaga is an academy award, multi-grammy award winner. Britney is an icon on her own, But Gaga has passed her. And she's not on Madonna's tier yet.

[Rio 5,088]

1 minute ago, TropicOfCANCER said:

this. britney has a legacy, but only bc she's part and parcel to the general 90s pop movement, which was a collective moment in pop culture. she didn't really stand the test of time. only her stans truly believe she's a legend. 

She has a the ultimate pop princess aura. Gaga has an aura and pop cultural stature akin to Madonna's, the ultimate alpha-female. There's just something about Britney that didn't... sustain, I dunno, her legacy will always stand tall though.

[RenegAde 19,127]

Britney career has had  more lows than highs and even her highest of highs was never as high as gaga 

[Animal Claws 18,665]

4 minutes ago, TropicOfCANCER said:

not madonna, but sorry...she's far exceeded britney. britney's career was really only 1999-2003, and then a brief (hype-based) comeback in 2009-2011. 

It's funny how you try to bash Britney in every thread 

Just accept that she's a legend and life goes on.

[Xardas 1,581]

19 minutes ago, Eggs said:

Gaga is at or has surpassed Britney's status as a pop culture icon. She can never reach Madonna's cultural significance however. 

I don't think so... She is much more talented than Madonna, more versatile, muuuch moooore critically acclaimed. We need to wait 10 more years to see, however, I believe than she is going to reach MJ's level. And she is in a much more difficult possition than Madonna was, to become a legend

[Rio 5,088]

7 minutes ago, shame said:

I've always been curious to know what MJ would have thought about Gaga's career had he still been alive. What did he say exactly about her before he died?

http://www.mtv.com/news/1629123/michael-jackson-wanted-to-collaborate-with-lady-gaga/

[Blastertoyo 22,728]

7 minutes ago, TropicOfCANCER said:

not madonna, but sorry...she's far exceeded britney. britney's career was really only 1999-2003, and then a brief (hype-based) comeback in 2009-2011. 

2007 is the most infamous year in Britney’s career what are u talking about 

[PartySick 159,824]

25 minutes ago, Dulo Peep said:

I loooooove Britney but, honest question, is she on the same level as Madonna and Gaga? pls dont hate me, she just seem so out of it, no sales, no nothing, ive been checking up on her obsessively lately and impact is nowhere to be found and it really surprises me because i am shook at some of her work, like Toxic, Gimme More, Scream n Shout

(I'm sure someone has answered )

Britney is a legacy artist imo. I personally like her later stuff like FF, BJ, and Glory but as far as the gp is concerned, she disappeared in 2007  she's still an icon and the first modern "pop princess". When you're used as a measuring stick for other artists, you know you've cemented your place in history.

OT: the only artist that comes close to competing with Gaga imo is MJ

If you look at the public's perspective though, Madonna is way bigger. She's probably on par with Britney, Beyonce, Rihanna, Adele, and others like them though.

[Rbr 421]

In my opinion, Gaga is for sure one of the biggest Pop acts of all time, as long as Britney,  but she is on her way to become a legend for many aspects that go beyond music.

Madonna is one of the most representative artists of history. Of any kind. I don’t see any other Pop artists, besides Cher and Michael Jackson, that may be compared to her in terms of legacy until now.

[PartySick 159,824]

7 minutes ago, Rio said:

Can't remember. Just remember it being something that was on the cards, that he was heavily eyeing her to open the This Is It tour back in 2009. I might have to do a little research, I read that years ago. Tbh, to be admired by and eyed up by the King of Pop and to piss off the Queen of Pop so early in your career, you've gotta have something special and legend-like about you 🤣💗

Gaga was going to perform a song called "Pictures" to open This Is It supposedly.

MJ did say that Poker Face was "written by a genius" though  I wish he could have been to see her continue to grow but he definitely knew she was a future icon.

[vyniildisk 12,689]

2 minutes ago, PartySick said:

OT: the only artist that comes close to competing with Gaga imo is MJ

 

And Dua, dont forget Dua

[Rio 5,088]

4 minutes ago, Xardas said:

I don't think so... She is much more talented than Madonna, more versatile, muuuch moooore critically acclaimed. We need to wait 10 more years to see, however, I believe than she is going to reach MJ's level. And she is in a much more difficult possition than Madonna was, to become a legend

Not too sure on the critically acclaimed part. Her albums aren't exactly marvels on metacritic, nor does she have a Ray of Light. Agree to everything else pretty much. But Madonna is mega talented too. But Gaga ticks more boxes I guess. She can act and sing 5x better at least

[PartySick 159,824]

Just now, Dulo Peep said:

And Dua, dont forget Dua

I literally wouldn't even know she existed if I wasn't on this site