Gypsy should've had a key change

[PartySick 159,407]

10 hours ago, derpmonster said:

I was joking

Me too

10 hours ago, derpmonster said:

I knew it was artRAVE but don't forget the spirit of Joanne was in ha throughout

What if Joanne is the avant garde queen we worship and Gaga is just a vessel?  Egg-ga

[shelby loved 381]

On 12/8/2019 at 5:27 PM, ProjectJoanne said:

Why? 

the use of the word gypsy is racist otherwise i love the song

[seashellplay 512]

On 12/8/2019 at 5:09 PM, Phlop said:

I agree. Idk how that went under their nose

It was planned, but Gaga wanted G.U.Y.

[DC 25,164]

1 hour ago, 666 said:

the use of the word gypsy is racist otherwise i love the song

Oh boy, @derpmonster we need you 

[Phlop 4,773]

12 minutes ago, seashellplay said:

It was planned, but Gaga wanted G.U.Y.

The only time I would’ve wanted her to pick a single was for Venus (which would’ve flopped but the video would’ve been amazing). Gypsy was easily a top 10 single.

 

[seashellplay 512]

An ideal single schedule (imo) would follow (Though in reality this would only function if her hip was diagnosed earlier, and Interscope was more lenient and wasn't so strict in terms of money): 

Applause: May 2013, Friday release to potentially reach #1 

Venus & Sexxx Dreams (Promotional Singles): June 2013, With beautiful lyric videos by 'Mr. Gabriel Marquez' (Brilliant artist who has worked with Marina before)

DWUW (Lacking R.Kelly): August 2013, Likely to reach approximately #7-8 (With a music video, of course.)

Gypsy: October 2013, Friday release, #7 (Generic music-video with her travelling across the globe or something, general public cry a river over these sorts of things) 

G.U.Y.: February 2014, Friday Valentines release, reaching ~#50-60, I understand why Gaga wanted this as a single, plus the ARTPOP Film: G.U.Y. was probably one of the only triumphs during this era (Other than Applause)

Aura: June 2014, Release during Gemini season, this song would likely do horrible on the charts, with it being such a strange EDM track, but this is an 'ideal' single cycle, and Gaga evidently wanted some form of separate release for Aura with an accompanying visual - Though the era would conclude in controversy with the 'Burqa' references. 

 

[not a french fry 1,565]

I love this song, it sucks that Gypsy is a slur though, she should re release it and call it “wandering man” or something 

[DC 25,164]

1 hour ago, onion gurl said:

I love this song, it sucks that Gypsy is a slur though, she should re release it and call it “wandering man” or something 

@derpmonster, we need you again!

[27monster27 12,957]

On 12/8/2019 at 5:02 PM, Bloody Matt said:

Should’ve been a single tbh.

This would have fit in perfectly with Hey Brother, Stay the Night, Counting Stars, Best Day of My Life, etc.

[Midnightrush891 727]

It’s perfect as it is, but you’re entitled to your opinion. 

[derpmonster 22,412]

1 hour ago, ProjectJoanne said:

@derpmonster, we need you again!

@ProjectJoanne sis you're mistaken if you think I'm walking into this mess

Jk well here's my opinion: yes, gypsy is a slur but that's not the common meaning of the word anymore and she obviously didn't mean it that way. She thought it meant "nomad". Let's leave it at that and honestly that's what many people today think it means. Luckily it didn't become a huge controversy then so let's not make it one now. I don't claim to speak for anyone else but I'm basically the ethnic sibling of the Romani against whom it was used as a slur and I don't think it's really that big of an issue (I'm Indian - the gypsies were people who left India to travel from place to place and eventually settled mostly in Romania. Many moved again).

[Flippy 12,624]

Ugh yes

I won't lie, I think I'm more of a fan of the Demo though

[GAYHEMikey 7,901]

Gosh that’s awesomeness 

[GAYHEMikey 7,901]

2 hours ago, seashellplay said:

An ideal single schedule (imo) would follow (Though in reality this would only function if her hip was diagnosed earlier, and Interscope was more lenient and wasn't so strict in terms of money): 

Applause: May 2013, Friday release to potentially reach #1 

Venus & Sexxx Dreams (Promotional Singles): June 2013, With beautiful lyric videos by 'Mr. Gabriel Marquez' (Brilliant artist who has worked with Marina before)

DWUW (Lacking R.Kelly): August 2013, Likely to reach approximately #7-8 (With a music video, of course.)

Gypsy: October 2013, Friday release, #7 (Generic music-video with her travelling across the globe or something, general public cry a river over these sorts of things) 

G.U.Y.: February 2014, Friday Valentines release, reaching ~#50-60, I understand why Gaga wanted this as a single, plus the ARTPOP Film: G.U.Y. was probably one of the only triumphs during this era (Other than Applause)

Aura: June 2014, Release during Gemini season, this song would likely do horrible on the charts, with it being such a strange EDM track, but this is an 'ideal' single cycle, and Gaga evidently wanted some form of separate release for Aura with an accompanying visual - Though the era would conclude in controversy with the 'Burqa' references. 

 

Please join her team 

[GAYHEMikey 7,901]

On 12/8/2019 at 10:58 PM, fkaaura said:

the REAL conversation we should be having is that Gypsy needs to replace Shallow as the Enigma closer and should've been it since day one..

Ur so right. Enigma started with such bangers and should end with a banger. I think they made it with shallow because of the commercial success.