CEREMONY || A Star Is Born

[alextruper17 8,908]

12 minutes ago, Animal Claws said:

12. Why Did You Do That?

Overall Score: 7.800

Highest Score: 11 @DiamondKing @Kween @Candy Gaga

Lowest Score: 0 @Blue Madonna @hausofcy

COMMENTS

@Gypsygaga1- Cute bop

@FfFfFfFF - The instrumental is way too simple (I honestly doubt uses more than 5 or so stems) which is detrimental because the melody is weak to being with. The lyrics show no effort and overall the crafting of the song seems like lacks effort. Also, way too modern sounding. Therefore it serves its placement in the context of the storyline but if we are talking about song quality on itself it's easily the worst song on the soundtrack

@Creyk - More of this on LG6 please

@AndiGaga - Trashy but in a perfect way TO ME!

@PinkPopOne word – BOP. Catchy, addictive and cool instrumentation.

@ChrisGaga - Soo underrated!! Don't know why people keep on hating on this BOP!!! <3 

@doppelganger- No!

@Ryusei - Bop. Why do you look so good in those jeans is iconic. Diane did that.

@IrishMonster- (catchy but a bit repetitive to say the least)

@Enzo- funny but we all know why it was made, maybe Diane snapped

@Davian - A bop!! The bass is fire. This song won’t leave my mind once I’ve heard it

@DiamondKing - This song is pop perfection and doesn't deserve all the hate it gets.

@Craven Moorecox - definition of a bop

@MANiCURE 6 - One of my favs.

@Ally Campana - We love a$$

@MonsterMom - It is what it is

@Candy Gaga - Yes this is my 11 And I don't  mind LG6 being like this. A fantastic Dance Pop bop.

@Phaye Monster - appreciate it for what it is: a bop

Finally

[Davian 44,859]

1 minute ago, Candy Gaga said:

Is That Alright

I would literally get a mental breakdown

[Candy Gaga 5,374]

Just now, Davian said:

I would literally get a mental breakdown

IKR there are like at least 5 songs to go first

[Ryusei 60,643]

If it's Is that alright? I'll -

[Davian 44,859]

I love La Vie En Rose but this is a good placement for it

[Davian 44,859]

Just now, Candy Gaga said:

IKR there are like at least 5 songs to go first

Actually about 9 songs but I understood your point

[Candy Gaga 5,374]

Music To My Eyes,  I Don't Know What Love Is and Before I Cry are here and WDYDT out 

[Davian 44,859]

Inb4 it’s Music in my Eyes aka not a shocker

[Ryusei 60,643]

Just now, Candy Gaga said:

Music To My Eyes,  I Don't Know What Love Is and Before I Cry arr here and WDYDT out 

I dont know what love is is out. 

[Davian 44,859]

Just now, Candy Gaga said:

Music To My Eyes,  I Don't Know What Love Is and Before I Cry arr here and WDYDT out 

I Don’t Know What Love Is went before WDYDT tho

[Enzo 37,977]

I'm about to report some accounts seriously 

 

[hausofcy 20,079]

13 minutes ago, Davian said:

Disappointed in y’all @Blue Madonna @hausofcy

Disappointed in the fact that someone actually thought it was a good idea to include this song in the soundtrack. A stain in ha discography. 

[Candy Gaga 5,374]

Just now, Ryusei said:

I dont know what love is is out. 

 

Just now, Davian said:

I Don’t Know What Love Is went before WDYDT tho

Ow yeah right right my brain is probably dead from my diet but it's out I guess 

[Ryusei 60,643]

1 minute ago, Candy Gaga said:

Music To My Eyes,  I Don't Know What Love Is and Before I Cry are here and WDYDT out 

 

Just now, Enzo said:

I'm about to report some accounts seriously 

 

some accounts?  

[Animal Claws 18,618]

10. I'll Never Love Again

Overall Score: 7.934

Highest Score: 11 @doppelganger @Antonio @Joesuda

Lowest Score: 0 @Creyk

COMMENTS

@Gypsygaga1I love the parts where she sounds a bit like Whitney, she absolutely bodies this song and I get the feels everytime it comes on

@FfFfFfFF - I love the parts where she sounds a bit like Whitney, she absolutely bodies this song and I get the feels everytime it comes on

@Creyk - I can't tell everyone how happy I was when shallow came and CANNIBALIZED this stupid song's success. Oh yeah, they thought this was going to be the big hit of the movie? Please. It totally sucks. Not even in the top 10 on the album.

@PinkPop - The last half of the track honestly brings me to tears, it gives me goosebumps and takes me back to the film’s tragedy every time.

@ChrisGaga- Honestly, who didn't start crying when this song appeared in the movie?!

@doppelganger - One of her best songs, lyrically and performance-wise. Who cares if she sounded like Whitney! 

@Enzo- the superior version, I'm going to cry again

@Davian- Amazing from start to finish. I was speechless when I first heard this during the movie. I cried my eyes out and couldn’t believe what I was hearing. A night to remember.

@Ryusei- Wish I could give a second 11 for this tbh, amazing vocals, amazing lyrics, so moving and an amazing climax and ending for the movie. She did THAT!

@fede ARTPOP - Great song but way too similar to Whitney style, still beautiful. 

@Glamourpuss- It's such an emotional song. I can't even listen to it without tearing up. 

@OpenHeartedMonster- I used to cry every time I heard this song or watched the music video because Gaga can so good deliver the emotions behind the protagonist if that makes sense. 

@Ally Campana The I Will Always Love You of our generation. The moment where A Star was Born. RIP Sonja

@LVbuttondown - (LOVE but not my fav)

@MonsterMom - Gorgeous vocals, raw emotion. Love the power she brings to the song 

@Candy Gaga- One of the greatest songs of her career . On the level of I Will Always Love You

@Phaye Monster - the film version makes me cry harder