ASIB Reviews | RT: 90% | MC: 88

[GABEL 1,853]

the new negative review accused the movie of mansplaining by showing gaga is the only woman in the industry(in this movie)
what does it even mean????

[S0436 10,215]

Surely by next week most major reviews will be completed and RT can update BEFORE October.  People will look at RT and decide on booking cinema tickets in about 3 weeks time.

[monsterdino 31,991]

1 hour ago, GABEL said:

the new negative review accused the movie of mansplaining by showing gaga is the only woman in the industry(in this movie)
what does it even mean????

yet halsey presented her w the award  

[monsterdino 31,991]

RT score back at 91% for no apparent reason? as there are no new reviews added...idk whats happening, but we won

edit: nvm its still 88? mustve been a glitch or I saw wrong

[MonsterOfficial 11,079]

negative reviews can really pull down the ratings hard im-  

we need the empire review asap! 

[S0436 10,215]

Maybe they are doing her a service by uploading the negative reviews first 

[Versace 7,973]

Bring ha back to the 90's 

[Bradley 59,151]

8 hours ago, highlikegaga said:

sometimes i feel like they should've just made the movie and not call it ASIB remake and just go with it.

as a LM i'm grateful and thankful and love the franchise and everything related. but this way the critics would not bash it with their stupid "yet another remake" comments. but some critics will always find something to bash so i don't give a F.

i'm curious, did anyone compare it in any way to La La Land? 

Also, i need to stop clicking on effin Spoilers expecting funny remarks, because i just spoiled myself. 

If you're gonna make it your own, you need to change the entire storyline though.

[Bradley 59,151]

8 hours ago, Max Vandeburg said:

I think our biggest threat is Kendrick Lamar with Black Panther soundtrack. The movie is a huge phenomenon and Kendrick is a very strong name. I don't think ASIB will have an easy competition in any way.

Superhero movies rarely get nominated though, even in the music category. Has Marvel or DC ever gotten a nomination for Original Song before?

[Madam Margolyes 7,783]

7 minutes ago, Bradley said:

Superhero movies rarely get nominated though, even in the music category. Has Marvel or DC ever gotten a nomination for Original Song before? 

Nope, i guess. But superhero movies has never been nominated for best picture either, and here are people constantly talking about black panther's big chances of getting the nomination.

[Bradley 59,151]

1 minute ago, Madam Margolyes said:

Nope, i guess. But superhero movies has never been nominated for best picture either, and here are people constantly talking about black panther's big chances of getting the nomination.

I doubt it would happen.

The fact that they introduced Best Popular Film is even more evidence that they don't want to give Black Panther a Best Picture nomination, which they do not deserve.

[gag 22,449]

47 minutes ago, Bradley said:

Superhero movies rarely get nominated though, even in the music category. Has Marvel or DC ever gotten a nomination for Original Song before?

No, but a superhero movie has never gotten 88 on Metacritic before. What Black Panther does this award season would be unprecedented.

A lot of predictions are thinking that a lock for Best Song nom is All The Stars and IMO it sounds very likely. There’s always a pop song or two from a major movie in the category (Happy, Earned It, Can’t Stop The Feeling etc.).

[Bradley 59,151]

2 minutes ago, gag said:

No, but a superhero movie has never gotten 88 on Metacritic before. What Black Panther does this award season would be unprecedented.

A lot of predictions are thinking that a lock for Best Song nom is All The Stars and IMO it sounds very likely. There’s always a pop song or two from a major movie in the category (Happy, Earned It, Can’t Stop The Feeling etc.).

Except those are not superhero movies, and two of the examples you'd given are from animated films which are a favourite of the Oscars.

I don't see how All the Stars is a good complement towards the film though, it was just played in the background during a scene and the song sounds like a normal pop song that is being forcefully 'fitted' into the movie.

[SlayGagaloo 16,152]

On 9/5/2018 at 3:19 AM, S0436 said:

La la land is 92% on RT

And an average score of 8.7/10

While ASIB is already at 7.2/10

 

[gag 22,449]

Just now, Bradley said:

 Except those are not superhero movies, and two of the examples you'd given are from animated films which are a favourite of the Oscars.

Yeah that's why I said they're 'pop songs from a major movie'. Again, Black Panther's award run is unprecedented. There's going to be no examples of previous superhero songs being nominated because a superhero has never been THIS critically successful so far.

4 minutes ago, Bradley said:

I don't see how All the Stars is a good complement towards the film though, it was just played in the background during a scene and the song sounds like a normal pop song that is being forcefully 'fitted' into the movie.

It doesn't have to be a good compliment, Earned It wasn't vital to 50 Shades at all, but it peaked at #4 and it was made for a movie, so it was nominated. Meanwhile, All The Stars and Pray For Me both peaked at #7 and it's from a critically acclaimed movie... at least one Black Panther song is pretty much a lock.