What do you make of the BBC’s review of the Birmingham show?

[mezzanine 476]

being honest, i can't really see anymore that gaga that used to say "i'm not that pop-star, i do pop/electro-opera shows", blah blah blah... but well then you can also remember another speeches about beauty, that MBT neons, and now EpioneGa striking back and forth so... 

[DoremonLove 8,147]

This same article was trashed b4 JWT got cancelled now ppl agree with it. How can ppl be so bitter is beyond me. Whatever gaga does will never be enuf for anyone looks like she truly deserves better then this. Im so sure if she starts doing what she did for TMB she will be trashed for doing same things. She can nveer win.

[TheQueenLG 2,469]

The JWT was wonderful. Shut up, BBC. No one was listening in the first place. 

[Enigma 7,182]

That’s exactly what I think was wrong with the Joanne era. It was supposed to be stripped down but we were craving some pop so she tried to incorporate hits in the mix but she couldn’t go artsy so she had to turn the era into a Greatest hits + bits of Joanne thing. It feels commercial and boring to me. Still loved the show but it didn’t feel Gaga. It felt more like a Beyoncé show.

[Darcklighter22 2,358]

3 minutes ago, ZacharyMark said:

Wasn't that what the speeches in MB and BTWB were?

for the most part but she would customise it allot more and you felt there was more emotion in what she was saying. Now at least with the JWT it comes across as very rehearsed except for when she was at the Piano

[Ella Taylor 231]

All of you should be ashamed, you're stuck in 2010! Learn how to accept change! 

I attended the Tour December 12th in Denver and I can tell you EVERYONE after the concert was completely floored by it, y'all are little brats expecting too much from Gaga complaining behind your screens! Sit down!

[DoremonLove 8,147]

2 minutes ago, FfFfFfFF said:

I guess they didn't listen to Dancin' In Circles.

Or the bloody marry part 

[7 others 562]

11 minutes ago, ZacharyMark said:

"a step back to the bygone days of Hot Gossip." What does that even mean?..

Why aren't they mentioning the "death" scene that beautifully transitioned into "Angel Down"? You can't win with people. Either Gaga is a psycho or she's too normal.. Gaga obviously doesn't have the same aesthetic this time around, but I think that keeping it would make her career way to static.. 

hot boilin tea

[TheQueenLG 2,469]

All of you were praising the JWT after you went to and actually experienced it... And now you're bashing it for no good reason. Like seriously. 

Gaga poured her heart and soul into her performance every night, and now she is in great pain. Can we just talk about that for a bit rather than bash her for being too commercial on her least commercial album to date. 

[Phoenix 17,395]

13 minutes ago, Ella Taylor said:

^^^^^^^^ Mentally ill monsters

rihported

 

 

[DoremonLove 8,147]

2 minutes ago, Ella Taylor said:

All of you should be ashamed, you're stuck in 2010! Learn how to accept change! 

I attended the Tour December 12th in Denver and I can tell you EVERYONE after the concert was completely floored by it, y'all are little brats expecting too much from Gaga complaining behind your screens! Sit down!

THIS 

2010 is gone Move on. 

[venusfly 17,885]

I actually like this review, this isn’t some random journalist who doesn’t know about her career judging the show from first glance; it’s from an honest fan who went to see Gaga’s usual unique approach to pop and saw just your run of the mill pop show, which the JWT is. It’s an amazing well put together show but it’s not Lady Gaga and most of us know that.

The show being standard does not mean she didn’t pour work into it, it doesn’t mean it’s not good or creative, I mean look at the stages and interludes and outfits they’re all amazing, it’s just not what we would have thought she would do in our heads before Joanne came out.

[mezzanine 476]

4 minutes ago, Ella Taylor said:

All of you should be ashamed, you're stuck in 2010! Learn how to accept change! 

I attended the Tour December 12th in Denver and I can tell you EVERYONE after the concert was completely floored by it, y'all are little brats expecting too much from Gaga complaining behind your screens! Sit down!

nicki girl....

 

sure we shall be ashamed of complaining about anything related to gaga....

 

I went to both barcelona dates honey, i know how it was like, and changes come, but not always for good, if you're not up about some discussions with gaga as the main topic, then i dont know what the f_ are you doing in a PUBLIC gaga forum 

[ryanripley 86,575]

ya'll either want crazyga or commercial success

she can't have both without joanne

[Sailor 3,321]

Yeah, that's right, unfortunately.

I don't necessarily want crazyga. I just want more creativity.