Where would 'Monster' have charted if released as 4th single?

[The Bling 12,253]

22 minutes ago, monketsharona said:

This thread proves even more that a lot of people here are not fans from the beginning 

Sorry to tell you this but all her singles at that time ended up top 10 very easily. 

Well I mean... as a standalone single I doubt it could have been Top 10. With a killer video, of course it would have But lbh she didn't flop because of flawless singles choices and MV

[GagaUnderYou 4,992]

Gaga during that time would have been top 5 

[monketsharona 81,657]

2 minutes ago, The Bling said:

Well I mean... as a standalone single I doubt it could have been Top 10. With a killer video, of course it would have But lbh she didn't flop because of flawless singles choices and MV

It's not disminish the quality of her music, or was top of the top

TFM won everything because it was quality not because it was popular

[sipthistea 21,099]

54 minutes ago, Enzo said:

I mean,why top 10

That's not even possible

Everything is possible 

And she was huge back then. The catchy song could have easily escalated to Top 10. With a solid promo and a MV, you have another Gaga hit. 

[The Bling 12,253]

1 minute ago, monketsharona said:

It's not disminish the quality of her music, or was top of the top

TFM won everything because it was quality not because it was popular

Of course TFM is flawless in every single aspect, but some songs were more radio friendly than others and she chose well. Monster sounds, to me, the most generic in the (album?), and didn't go that well with Gaga's avantgarde persona that everybody fell in love with

BUT

Monster is TFM's most streamed song on Youtube with ~11 million views so... Idk

Maybe could have been low Top 10

[TeenIdle 126,607]

She should've milked the era with 2 more singles. Monster and DITD

[TEANUS 15,088]

I feel like between 6/7

[BabylonHooker 4,305]

5 or 6, just like Alejandro  

[Phoebe Buffay 12,525]

2 hours ago, TeenIdle said:

She should've milked the era with 2 more singles. Monster and DITD

Ikr. I'm so angry that she cuts eras with 3/4 singles when she can (could) extend them with so many more (esp. TF, TFM, and AP). Like where are Starstruck, Monster, Dance in the Dark, I Like It Rough, Summerboy, MANiCURE, Sexxx Dreams, Gypsy??

OT: Today I feel like #7.

[PrinceOfTheStorm 5,904]

People voting #1... 

[SCHEISSEMONTRE 2,783]

Idk but, it wouldn’t in the top f

1 hour ago, PerfectCure said:

Alejandro was probably as big as Poker Face

Didn’t you remember the conserversy with the MV 

[SCHEISSEMONTRE 2,783]

15 minutes ago, EvilRegal said:

Ikr. I'm so angry the she cuts eras with 3/4 singles when she can (could) extend them with so many more (esp. TF, TFM, and AP). Like where's Starstruck, Monster, Dance in the Dark, I Like It Rough, Summerboy, MANiCURE, Sexxx Dreams, Gypsy??

Then the future tour Setlists would be a complete mess, by saying that we would have The JWT setlist 2.0 and with more singles the less newer songs are played on tour 

[Phoebe Buffay 12,525]

15 minutes ago, SCHEISSEMONTRE said:

Then the future tour Setlists would be a complete mess, by saying that we would have The JWT setlist 2.0 and with more singles the less newer songs are played on tour 

But she still can change and pick which past hits/singles she can perform on each tour instead of sticking to BR, JD, PF, BTW and Paparazzi.

[JohnWayne92 2,175]

I chose #2. I have always thought Monster was a BANGER. 

It would have gone up against California Gurls and Love The Way You Lie, in that time frame, so I don't think it would have hit #1 unfortunately =(

[moonsago 7,285]

1 hour ago, monketsharona said:

Please let's not :

In the US :

Just Dance : #1

Poker Face : #1

LoveGame : # 5

Paparazzi : #6

Bad Romance : #2

Telephone : #3

Alejandro: #5

People were going crazy for her  during TF / TFM and it wasn't going down at that time

People turned their back during BTW for a lot of reasons (Madonna ripoff accusation, BTW being very gay, Judas having some deeper religious scandals and so on)

I swear Judas ****ed her career tragectory so bad, I was thinking the other day what in the world was Troy and her team THINKING when they decided it should be a single. Like I don’t get it, of course for the controversy but how did they think it would end up well??? The Edge Of Glory would of went nr 1 if it was the second single. Then she should of done Marry the Night which I truly believe would of went top 5 and then You and I and maybe a fifth single like Hair or Scheibe though Hair would of been more fitting because it’s so relatable people would of loved it if pushed and promoted properly.