Jump to content
question

Which 1D singer you think is doing basic work?


2020Covid19IsOurs

Basic 1D?  

59 members have voted

  1. 1. Who's serving basic music?



Featured Posts

2020Covid19IsOurs

Just judging on the music you've heard so far of their solo attempts, whose efforts you thought were lackluster/not upto your expectations? 

 

 

 

Ps: Don't vote for your fave without reading the post :poot:

Pps: Louis Tomlinson has a song out for those of you not in the know. Look it up:reductive:

Gaga x JeffHardy x BillMaher
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 32
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Irrelevant

Louis or Niall in terms of music. Is Liam even doing music? :oprah:

광야로 걸어가 알아 네 home ground
Link to post
Share on other sites

loathereality
6 minutes ago, Relevant said:

Louis or Niall in terms of music. Is Liam even doing music? 

he does but I think his debut will be on 19th

Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorcerer

Louis

So generic I can't even fathom

Can't judge Liam yet since he will just release his debut next week.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Blake

Niall. He's doing plain acoustic tracks about girls. Blah. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Harry

Hard to judge since Liam's song isn't out yet, although it sounds bad. I think Louis' song was really bad. I know it was a tribute to his mother but the style was a generic/obvious choice and his vocals and lyrics are not convincing at all.

I know most people will likely say Niall because his songs have been quite vanilla, but the latest one was more interesting than the first song and at least has a shred of something unique. That Louis single could've been done by anyone (and it feels like it has been done a million times already).

Harry's stuff is quality, he's influenced by stuff that's already been done in decades past but no popular stars are really doing it like that atm. Zayn's album was okay too.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Blake
Just now, Camore said:

Louis

So generic I can't even fathom

Can't judge Liam yet since he will just release his debut next week.

Lmao this is far better than the mess that's Niall's music. Louis is amazing. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Blake
Just now, Harry said:

Hard to judge since Liam's song isn't out yet, although it sounds bad. I think Louis' song was really bad. I know it was a tribute to his mother but the style was a generic/obvious choice and his vocals and lyrics not convincing at all.

I know most people will likely say Niall because his songs have been quite vanilla, but the latest one was more interesting than the first song and at least has a shred of something unique. That Louis single could've been done by anyone (and it feels like it has been done a million times already).

Harry's stuff is quality, he's influenced by stuff that's already been done but no popular stars are really doing it like that atm. Zayn's album was okay too.

Mmmmmm Louis' is better than Niall, sorry. :whitney: 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Bradley

I dk, they all seem fine to me.

Zayn is probably my favourite because he makes great upbeat tracks. Niall's music is great, at least I like Slow Hands and This Town.

Harry is okay for me though I admit he's not generic or basic in any way.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Harry
Just now, Blake said:

Mmmmmm Louis' is better than Niall, sorry. :whitney: 

Louis' was literally just a generic EDM DJ collab though. Fair enough if that's your thing but there's no personality in that whatsoever. I've heard that song made about a hundred times over in the past few years, it's so forgettable. Niall's first single was dull to me but the new one has at least a bit more of an edge to it. To be fair to Louis, it was just a collab single so maybe his actual solo work will be different.

It's kind of interesting that they've all taken completely different routes so far, though:

Harry - Rock/alternative
Zayn - R&B
Niall - Acoustic pop
Louis - Dance
Liam - Hip-hop

Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorcerer
5 minutes ago, Blake said:

Lmao this is far better than the mess that's Niall's music. Louis is amazing. 

Good luck on your opinion. Even though Niall is too cheesy, atleast This Town has some lyricism, and the production of Slow Hands is more interesting than Aoki's dated work in Just Hold On. A D-list DJ can imitate it.

That oh oh oh hook by Louis is so overdone I can't.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Creyk

Wait, there are 5? I thought there were 4 :rip:

Anyway, I patiently checked out all the songs released by them put only Zayn has managed to put out good music, so he's the best

Harry's album was awful, just totally awful

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...