evidence that the Joanne era is maybe over

[Frankenztein 1,172]

38 minutes ago, MJHolland said:

 

Gaga's parents were wealthy enough to have a 4 bedroom apartment on the Upper East side of Manhattan, one of the most expensive housing markets in the world, and send both kids to private high schools and suuupper expensive colleges 

So no, they weren't really working class and that's what a lot of ppl hate how Hollywood describes "working class".

 

Yes, her parents were wealthy enough later in their lives, but they may have grown up working class. I'm not really sure though. I don't know enough about her family history to judge.

She has many times acknowledged how lucky she is to have lived in the Upper West Side of New York and have had a privileged education it's not like she denies that.

I think when she talks about her family coming from nothing she doesn't mean herself. She means the previous generations of her family. Gaga doesn't always communicate super clearly, but I believe this is what she's trying to say here.

[MJHolland 12,725]

34 minutes ago, Frankenztein said:

Yes, her parents were wealthy enough later in their lives, but they may have grown up working class. I'm not really sure though. I don't know enough about her family history to judge.

She has many times acknowledged how lucky she is to have lived in the Upper West Side of New York and have had a privileged education it's not like she denies that.

I think when she talks about her family coming from nothing she doesn't mean herself. She means the previous generations of her family. Gaga doesn't always communicate super clearly, but I believe this is what she's trying to say here.

You're totally right, I get it haha. I think what she said was construed a little by what Zane was saying.

[holy scheisse 22,173]

Joanne isn't over but it should be 

[Frankenztein 1,172]

Just now, MJHolland said:

You're totally right, I get it haha. I think what she said was construed a little by what Zane was saying.

Yeah, because Zane was implying she was working class which was confusing. I totally get what you were saying before though about many people in Hollywood talking about being "working class", but being so clueless and off-base with it that it get's annoying. 

Anyway, to be On-Topic. I don't think Gaga is giving any clues to Joanne being over. I think this album means a lot to her. She just moves on from things quickly. Always has.